Closed ValWood closed 1 year ago
I think this was done because it isn't clear that ALL processing is part of glycosylation.
It sounds like that are from the def:
The conversion of N-linked glycan (N = nitrogen) structures from the initially transferred oligosaccharide to a mature form, by the actions of glycosidases and glycosyltransferases
and all my annotations are. Which parts of N-glycan processing are not part of glycosylation, do you have an example?
PMID:17074831? @krchristie will decide.
The processing (trimming) is part of the ER QC system, but it is still part of the broader glycosylation process i.e:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/N-linked_glycosylation#Processing_of_glycan
(when people talk about the process fo glycosylation, they don't exclude these steps which are absolutely required for maturation- otherwise, we no longer have a term to refer to the entire pathway)
==
wikepedia entry says:
This initial trimming step is thought to act as a quality control step in the ER to monitor protein folding.
Once the protein is folded correctly, the three glucose residues are removed by glucosidase I and II. The removal of the final glucose residue signals that the glycoprotein is ready for transit from the ER to the cis-Golgi.[4] However, if the protein is not folded properly, the glucose residues are not removed and thus the glycoprotein can’t leave the endoplasmic reticulum. A chaperone protein (calnexin/calreticulin) binds to the unfolded or partially folded protein to assist protein folding.
It looks to me that the lack of a relationship between these two terms is consistent with their current definitions and positions in the graph, where the first term is described as the addition of the initial carbohydrate or derivative to a protein, while the second term is described as subsequent modifications to that initial carbohydrate.
protein N-linked glycosylation Def: A protein glycosylation process in which a carbohydrate or carbohydrate derivative unit is added to a protein via the N4 atom of peptidyl-asparagine, the omega-N of arginine, or the N1' atom peptidyl-tryptophan.
N-glycan processing Def: The conversion of N-linked glycan (N = nitrogen) structures from the initially transferred oligosaccharide to a mature form, by the actions of glycosidases and glycosyltransferases. The early processing steps are conserved and play roles in glycoprotein folding and trafficking.
To group these two things, I think you would need some other broader term. Perhaps the existing term 'glycoprotein metabolic process' would be appropriate (def below). To do that would mean giving 'protein N-linked glycosylation' additional is_a parentage under 'glycoprotein metabolic process'. We could also add think about adding a more specific term for 'protein N-glycan metabolic process', or perhaps for 'N-linked proteoglycan biosynthetic process', which I think we could make under 'proteoglycan biosynthetic process'.
Let me know what you think.
-K
glycoprotein metabolic process Def: The chemical reactions and pathways involving glycoproteins, any protein that contains covalently bound glycose (i.e. monosaccharide) residues; the glycose occurs most commonly as oligosaccharide or fairly small polysaccharide but occasionally as monosaccharide.
proteoglycan biosynthetic process Def: The chemical reactions and pathways resulting in the formation of proteoglycans, any glycoprotein in which the carbohydrate units are glycosaminoglycans.
I'm a bit confused, and not an expert. But I really thought that people who study this refer to the entire pathway as "protein glycosylation". And indeed that is still a parent because all GO:0006491 N-glycan processing is still part of https://www.pombase.org/term/GO:0006486 I think this is correct?
However, if this Is true, then logically
GO:0006491 N-glycan processing should be part_of GO:0006487 protein N-linked glycosylation
Can close this for now, I resolved by co-annotating to "protein glycosylation" If anyone built a GO-CAM of this pathway, I think this would be placed under "protein glycosylation"
GO:0006491 N-glycan processing
2017-01-27 | Deleted | RELATION | part of GO:0006487 (protein N-linked glycosylation)
I wondered why this is. Now some of the "N-linked glycosylation pathway" no longer slim to glycosylation?