geneontology / go-ontology

Source ontology files for the Gene Ontology
http://geneontology.org/page/download-ontology
Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International
222 stars 40 forks source link

Update definition ATPase activity #20498

Closed pgaudet closed 3 years ago

pgaudet commented 3 years ago

From the ontology call, and the discussion on compound functions:

We want all ATPases to have an is_a path to ATPase activity. To this end, we will change the definition of ATPase activity to "~A molecular function that uses ATP hydrolysis as an energy source~." (source: pdt).

A molecular function that uses ATP hydrolysis as an energy source, for example to catalyze a reaction or drive transport against a concentration gradient.

Thanks, Pascale

pgaudet commented 3 years ago

Note also that the EC:3.6.1.3 has been deleted.

@kaxelsen @amorgat Is there an EC/RHEA we should use in replacement ?

Thanks, Pascale

pgaudet commented 3 years ago

ATPases are now split into:

and

deustp01 commented 3 years ago

But none of these catagories apply to ABC transporters, which all have EC/7.# numbers (# = 2 or 3 or 4 or 5 or 6). FGrom the ontology discussion, don't we need to accommodate them also, or am I missing something here?

kaxelsen commented 3 years ago

Note also that the EC:3.6.1.3 has been deleted.

@kaxelsen @amorgat Is there an EC/RHEA we should use in replacement ?

Thanks, Pascale

There is RHEA:13065

ValWood commented 3 years ago

There are many ATPases not here including: DNA clamp loader activity  DNA/RNA helices DNA translocase activity (condensing cohesion) ATP-dependent peptidases (lon,M41 and others)

presumably these are classified elsewhere in EC

kaxelsen commented 3 years ago

@ValWood, no the enzymes you mention are not currently part of the EC list. Not, that generally the EC list tries to to create a distinct reaction for each EC entry. So when the entries currently sporting the reaction "ATP + H(2)O = ADP + phosphate" (RHEA:13065) are updated, we try to add the result of hydrolysing ATP to the reaction, as can be seen in the new EC 5.6 entries. The RHEA:13065 reaction is not very informative in itself.

pgaudet commented 3 years ago

RHEA:13065 is ATPase activity then ? Is there an equivalent general EC ?

kaxelsen commented 3 years ago

As RHEA:13065 = "ATP + H(2)O = ADP + phosphate" it is the most basic ATPase activity. There is no corresponding EC number, as no enzyme hydrolyses ATP without using the generated energy to do something, and as mentioned above the EC list tries now to describe what the energy is used for in the reactions, e.g. EC 5.6.1.2, dynein ATPase, "ATP + H(2)O + a dynein associated with a microtubule at position (n) = ADP + phosphate + a dynein associated with a microtubule at position (n-1, toward the minus end)"

ValWood commented 3 years ago

Makes sense! Thanks @kaxelsen

@pgaudet @cmungall @sjm41 @vanaukenk @thomaspd this makes me think that really has_part ATPase with a procedure to infer every ATPase might have been a better solution, in retrospect?

Especially since we need to be able to infer annotations over has_part anyway for components etc.

sjm41 commented 3 years ago

@hattrill

ValWood commented 3 years ago

Just playing devil's advocate. But are we sure about the dual parentage ????

pgaudet commented 3 years ago

no enzyme hydrolyses ATP without using the generated energy to do something

To me the logical conclusion is that ATPase activity is not a function ;)

In any event, it seems like there is a need to group /browse ATPases, and the only way we can support all tools doing that is with is_a (or part_of, but that doesn't work).

Thanks, Pascale

pgaudet commented 3 years ago

Removed synonyms corresponding to gene products or merge terms

-synonym: "chaperonin" RELATED [EC:3.6.4.9] -synonym: "chaperonin ATPase activity" RELATED [] -synonym: "complex V (mitochondrial electron transport)" NARROW [EC:3.6.1.3] -synonym: "HCO3--ATPase" NARROW [EC:3.6.1.3] -synonym: "non-chaperonin molecular chaperone ATPase activity" RELATED [] -synonym: "nucleoplasmin ATPase activity" RELATED [] -synonym: "peroxisome-assembly ATPase activity" RELATED [] -synonym: "SV40 T-antigen" RELATED [EC:3.6.1.3] -synonym: "vesicle-fusing ATPase activity" RELATED [EC:3.6.4.6] -synonym: "ATP phosphohydrolase (polypeptide-unfolding)" NARROW [EC:3.6.4.9]

Thanks, Pascale