geneontology / go-ontology

Source ontology files for the Gene Ontology
http://geneontology.org/page/download-ontology
Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International
223 stars 40 forks source link

Obsoletion request: GO:0039668 viral entry into host cell via pilus basal pore and GO:0039669 viral entry into host cell via pilus retraction and membrane fusion #26669

Closed pgaudet closed 11 months ago

pgaudet commented 11 months ago

GO:0039667 viral entry into host cell via pilus retraction, GO:0039668 viral entry into host cell via pilus basal pore > 4 annotations CAFA, will be remapped GO:0039669 viral entry into host cell via pilus retraction and membrane fusion > 0 annotations

are more granular than the ViralZone term. Replace by
virion attachment to host cell pilus which corresponds to the VZ term, https://viralzone.expasy.org/981

pgaudet commented 11 months ago

Obsolete GO:0035635 entry of bacterium into host cell >> 10 manual annotations >> replace by symbiont entry into host cell Obsolete GO:0039707 virus-mediated pore formation in host cell membrane > 2 EXP; replace by symbiont entry into host cell via pore formation in plasma membrane

pgaudet commented 11 months ago

Dear all,

The proposal has been made to obsolete the following 'entry into host cell' terms: GO:0039667 viral entry into host cell via pilus retraction > Replace by GO:0039666 virion attachment to host cell pilus GO:0039668 viral entry into host cell via pilus basal pore > Replace by GO:0039666 virion attachment to host cell pilus GO:0039669 viral entry into host cell via pilus retraction and membrane fusion > Replace by GO:0039666 virion attachment to host cell pilus GO:0035635 entry of bacterium into host cell > replace by GO:0046718 symbiont entry into host cell GO:0039707 virus-mediated pore formation in host cell membrane > replace by GO:0044694 symbiont entry into host cell via pore formation in plasma membrane

There are 16 EXP annotations, 2 Reactome mappings, 6 InterPro and 1 HAMAP mapping, see https://github.com/geneontology/go-annotation/issues/4882

Impacted groups: Database Count
AgBase 4
CACAO 1
GO_Central 1
MGI 2
CAFA 4
UniProt 2
 Reactome 2
 InterPro 6
 HAMAP 1

You can comment on the ticket: https://github.com/geneontology/go-ontology/issues/26669

Thanks, Pascale

deustp01 commented 11 months ago

GO:0035635 entry of bacterium into host cell > replace by GO:0046718 symbiont entry into host cell

This line seems wrong. GO:0046718 is "viral entry into host cell", and I can't find a term with the name "symbiont entry into host cell" nor any plausible children of GO:0044409 "entry into host".

Help!

deustp01 commented 11 months ago

Obsolete GO:0035635 entry of bacterium into host cell >> 10 manual annotations >> replace by symbiont entry into host cell

Same discrepancy in immediately preceding comment, above. The text says "symbiont" but the link points to a term for "virus"

pgaudet commented 11 months ago

Hi @deustp01 I have renamed the terms, but I agree for now this is confusing.

deustp01 commented 11 months ago

Hi @deustp01 I have renamed the terms, but I agree for now this is confusing.

I'm OK with being confused. So I should use GO:0046718 to replace the existing terms and the "viral" name will get corrected the next time we update our local copy of GO against the central one?

pgaudet commented 11 months ago

That's right. GO:0046718 is now 'symbiont entry into host cell'; this will show up with the next snapshot.

Pascale

suzialeksander commented 3 months ago

Just noting that GO:0035635 entry of bacterium into host cell is still a valid term.