Closed gocentral closed 9 years ago
Logged In: YES user_id=631592
Sensory perception requires higher order neuological processing, that is the point of the perception part. I propose that we have a term that is a child of response to external stimuls called reflex process. These terms and the current terms would then be is_a children of this new term. [Term] id: GO:new name: reflex process namespace: biological_process def: "An automatic response to a stimulus beginning with a nerve impulse from a receptor and ending with the action of an effector such as a gland or a muscle. Signaling never reaches a level of conciousness."[ISBN:087797099, GOC:dph] related_synonym: "" [] exact_synonym: "" [] is_a: GO:0009605 ! response to external stimulus
Then Li's terms would be is_a children of this new term.
Original comment by: ukemi
Logged In: YES user_id=436423
David - ok by me
thanks m
Original comment by: mah11
Original comment by: ukemi
Logged In: YES user_id=835115
I see no problem with this. The definitions may need a bit of a tweak though. What is the process?
Maybe it should be more like:
vestibular reflex Compensatory ocular motion elicited by the activation of vestibular afferent inputs in response to angular and translational acceleration of the head during locomotion.
angular vestibuloocular reflex Compensatory ocular motion elicited by the stimulation of semicircular canal-related inputs during locomotion.
linear vestibuloocular reflex: Compensatory ocular motion elicited by the stimulation of otolith-related inputs during locomotion.
-My 2c
Doug
Original comment by: doughowe
Logged In: YES user_id=631592
Doug,
I would define them all in an aristotelian way by differntiating the response to external stimulus and then specifying what Li gave in her proposed defs.
David
Original comment by: ukemi
Logged In: YES user_id=835115
I'm not sure I understand. In this case there is no differentia on the response...it is an ocular response in each case. The differentia seems to be the type of stimuls, right?
Original comment by: doughowe
Logged In: YES user_id=631592
[Term] id: GO:new1 name: reflex process namespace: biological_process def: "An automatic response to a stimulus beginning with a nerve impulse from a receptor and ending with the action of an effector such as a gland or a muscle. Signaling never reaches a level of conciousness."[ISBN:087797099, GOC:dph] related_synonym: "" [] exact_synonym: "" [] is_a: GO:0009605 ! response to external stimulus
[Term] id: GO:new2 name: vestibular reflex namespace: biological_process def: "A reflex process by which a response to an angular or linear acceleration stimulus begins with an afferent nerve impulse from a receptor in the inner ear and ends with the compensatory action of eye muscles. Signaling never reaches a level of conciousness."[GOC:dph] related_synonym: "" [] exact_synonym: "" [] is_a: GO:new1 ! reflex process
[Term] id: GO:new3 name: angular vestibuloocular reflex namespace: biological_process def: "A vestibular reflex by which a response to an angular acceleration stimulus begins with an afferent nerve impulse from a receptor in the semi-circular canal and ends with the compensatory action of eye muscles. Signaling never reaches a level of conciousness."[GOC:dph] related_synonym: "" [] exact_synonym: "" [] is_a: GO:new2 ! vestibular reflex
[Term] id: GO:new4 name: linear vestibular reflex namespace: biological_process def: "A vestibular reflex by which a response to a linear acceleration stimulus begins with an afferent nerve impulse from a receptor in the otolith and ends with the compensatory action of eye muscles. Signaling never reaches a level of conciousness."[GOC:dph] related_synonym: "" [] exact_synonym: "" [] is_a: GO:new2 ! vestibular reflex
Original comment by: ukemi
Logged In: YES user_id=835115
Ah..its clear to me now. Two thumbs up.
Original comment by: doughowe
Logged In: YES user_id=631592
We found this approach really helpful during the is_a complete work. When we got stuck we asked "What is it?" Then we asked can we define it as "x" by which "yyz". I'll implement this tomorrow.
David
Original comment by: ukemi
Logged In: YES user_id=631592
Added: reflex process GO:0060004 vestibular reflex GO:0060005 angular vestibuloocular reflex GO:0060006 linear vestibuloocular reflex GO:0060007
Original comment by: ukemi
Original comment by: ukemi
Please add vestibular reflexes as a child of GO term:sensory perception GO id:GO:0007600
Also please add angular vestibuloocular reflex linear vestibuloocular reflexes as child of Vestibular reflexes
Vestibular reflexes: Angular and translational accelerations of the head activate vestibular afferent inputs that initiate compensatory ocular reflexes during locomotion.
angular vestibuloocular reflexes: compensatory ocular reflexes generated from Semicircular canal-related inputs.
linear vestibuloocular reflexes: compensatory ocular reflexes generated from otolith-related inputs.
PMID: 11784757
Reported by: liniatmgi
Original Ticket: "geneontology/ontology-requests/3608":https://sourceforge.net/p/geneontology/ontology-requests/3608