geneontology / pathways2GO

Code for converting between BioPAX pathways and Gene Ontology Causal Activity Models (GO-CAM)
8 stars 0 forks source link

Insulin Processing (R-HSA-264876) #193

Open ukemi opened 2 years ago

ukemi commented 2 years ago
ukemi commented 1 year ago

P4HB
I've also got a step catalyzed by Hsp90b1 as the chaperone: PMID: 30670477 I've got Ero1b upstream of the P4hb, but since it's a cycle I think this is consistent. I actually think you are more accurate. I've still got different transporters for the Zinc than you do. PMID: 12446736, PMID: 11997387

deustp01 commented 1 year ago

it's a cycle

Tangential but important and complicated rabbit hole - many model-building strategies, I am told, just can't handle cycles because the cycle gets turned into an infinite loop with no escape. Do issues like that arise with GO-CAM?

ukemi commented 1 year ago

Not according to what I have been told.

ukemi commented 1 year ago

I went back and changed the transporters in the mouse model to 5 and 8. This is similar to what you have, but I don't see evidence for 8 being in the Golgi in the mouse, so there is still that difference in our models. I removed the other two transporters that I had in the mouse model due to lack of evidence of their being in the beta cells.

deustp01 commented 1 year ago

I will re-check the evidence for human 8 in human Golgi.

Here's the re-check result. The Kambe et al. 2021 review PMID: 33485965, Figure 1a

Screen Shot 2022-09-27 at 4 02 10 PM

shows ZnT8 associated with Golgi vesicles and also with insulin granules, but (as far as I can see - time for new eyeglasses?) shows ZnT5 only as a heterodimer with ZnT6 and only associated with the Golgi, not with insulin granules.

Kambe et al. 2001 describe the localization of ZnT5 by immunofluorescence and immuno-EM as being only with secretory granules (Figure 4) but then in Figure 5 show ZnT5 localizing to the Golgi, albeit in cells in which the ZnT5 construct is overexpressed, in contrast to what I see in the later review cartoon.

Bottom line: evidence, more or less for both ZnT5 and ZnT8 in Golgi in a more or less human system; from the cartoon in Kambe et al. 2021 only ZnT8 is present in secretory granules, so when I get that far in the pathway I should delete the Reactome ZnT5 / secretory granule reaction, and leave only the ZnT8 one