search

geoffhumphrey / brewcompetitiononlineentry

https://brewingcompetitions.com
77 stars 78 forks source link

Anonymous Labels / Judging #630

Open elronalds opened 8 years ago

elronalds commented 8 years ago

If I have the system configured with anonymous labels then I'd like to propose the following options in the settings to make things more anonymous for an organiser / judge.

or

On the entries screen, there should be options to hide the brewer's name and beer name. That way I'm less likely to remember and identify any beers if I am organising and judging in the same comp. If I need to see the brewers name I could then click and load each entry. So maybe show these as [Hidden] with a link that goes to the full entry details.

I don't see any issue with this as we don't take responsibility for mislabeled bottles etc. Let me know your thoughts and I might be able to work on some of this.

geoffhumphrey commented 8 years ago

Luke, you are absolutely more than welcome to generate pull requests for what you've described here. Personally, however, I never have served as the overall organizer and a judge in the same competition. I feel that the organizer is definitely too close to the the overall operation - the risk that he/she will see/hear information that supposed to be anonymous is much too great, especially when they have access to lists, databases, and other information (as they should).

elronalds commented 8 years ago

I think it depends on the type and the location of the competition. In the USA you probably don't have much trouble finding BJCP judges compared to some other countries. Limited judges and smaller competitions might mean an organiser has to choice but to judge.

I think with anonymous labels, longer entry numbers (think 10 digits) there isn't much chance of association an entry number with a person. I managed to hide the beer name and brewer name (using just CSS) with some minor modifications. I'll look into submitting some pull requests for some of the other issues I've raised.

For some of the data shown in tables, it would be nice to have span elements and classes so you have more CSS selectors available.