georgringer / news

TYPO3 Extension news
GNU General Public License v2.0
265 stars 355 forks source link

Why that odd plugin name? Sticky article list view #2255

Closed kitzberger closed 1 year ago

kitzberger commented 1 year ago

Hi,

our users are at first always confused by the odd name for the list plugin that comes without an detail view: "Sticky article list view"

Is there any particular reason behind that name? Why is it supposed to be sticky?

Wouldn't "List articles" be a simpler and better name because it'd align nicer with the default plugins name: "List articles with detail view" within the CType select field.

georgringer commented 1 year ago

I just didn't have a better idea and "list view" without any information felt wrong

kitzberger commented 1 year ago

Ahhh, it is "sticky" in the sense of being stuck to the list view and cannot change to the detail view, right?

What about these names and descriptions?

CType Title Description
news_pi1 News article list (+ detail view) Listing of news articles chosen by various properties like storage folder, categories, time constraints, etc. This plugin is capable of rendering the detail view as well.
news_newsstickylist News article list Listing of news articles chosen by various properties like storage folder, categories, time constraints, etc. This plugin cannot render the detail view of news articles.
news_newsdetail News article detail view Rendering the detail view of a news article.

I think "news" should be part of the titles, so they make sense outside of the new element wizard as well.

georgringer commented 1 year ago

looks good to me

kitzberger commented 1 year ago

@georgringer, I've prepared a PR for this. My goal was to find names that I backend user would easily understand without further explanation. What do you think?