Kubuntu 23.10 update breaks KZones [solved]

gerritdevriese / kzones

KDE KWin Script for snapping windows into zones

https://store.kde.org/p/1909220

GNU General Public License v3.0

307 stars 16 forks source link

Kubuntu 23.10 update breaks KZones [solved] #72

Closed markmaker closed 6 months ago

markmaker commented 6 months ago

Thank you for a great project! :+1:

I know this is an incomplete observation, but maybe it helps other users solve the same problem, and/or it might help the authors ping a package maintainer, or amend the README.MD, etc:

Kubuntu 23.10 updated one day, and KZones no longer worked (unfortunately don't know when exactly).
KDE Plasma version is now indicated as 5.27.8 (unfortunately don't know which it was when KZones still worked).
When I deleted KZones in System Settings/KWin Scripts, then downloaded it again using the built-in Get New Scripts... function, then logged out and back in, it worked again. And it preserved my layout and settings. :sunglasses:
I observed KZones auto-updating through Discover before, so I guess this could be solved by somehow triggering that auto-update.

_Mark

gerritdevriese commented 6 months ago

I think what happened is that you were auto-updated to KZones v0.7 which is incompatible with Plasma 5.27.x, and by removing and reinstalling the script you actually downloaded "KZones for Plasma 5"

There is a warning on the store page to not update if you are still on Plasma 5, but of course the auto updater doesn't look at this 😆

markmaker commented 6 months ago

There is no KZones v0.7 available in the Download New Windows Manager Scripts view:

Download New Windows Manager Scripts

But maybe it was removed after having caused problems?

gerritdevriese commented 6 months ago

There are two separate store pages; KZones (https://store.kde.org/p/1909220) and KZones for Plasma 5 (https://store.kde.org/p/2143914) The "Get new" window only shows scripts that are compatible with your version, that's why you only see that one. BUT if you were already subscribed to "KZones" before it was updated to Plasma 6 the script manager keeps it in the list and thinks it is compatible with your system even though the minimum version is set to Plasma 6 on the KDE store and the script manifest.

markmaker commented 6 months ago

Okay then it is explained. But users should still have guidance to resolve this. Perhaps in the readme?

gerritdevriese commented 6 months ago

I added some extra info to the readme, hopefully everything is clear now.

markmaker commented 6 months ago

Brilliant! :+1: