get-salt-AI / SaltAI

GNU General Public License v3.0
71 stars 9 forks source link

Description on comfyUI-manager (and here for that matter)... #14

Open NeedsMoar opened 4 months ago

NeedsMoar commented 4 months ago

The current description is pure marketing department buzzword-bingo incoherence that doesn't say anything about what this actually does.

I don't want to read that a custom node is going to help me leverage my core competancies to circle back and create digital doubles for business 5.0, or that it's your goal to end world hunger with it, I want to know what it DOES. I didn't see anything about what this does in the manager, so I came here and there's a link to "Our nodes" after a bunch of more expanded and detailed but unenlightening marketing BS... naturally this doesn't link to a document but the directories full of python source without much if any real description in the readmes. Apparently one is supposed to read the source... If there's one thing messing around with stable diffusion for around a year now and having to temporarily fix hundreds of stupid little bugs to make things work for the day has taught me is that I was absolutely right in telling every programmer I've talked to for the past 20 years that python was a trash language that should be killed with fire. I can read it but won't voluntarily. Many (most?) people just can't read it at all and don't necessarily want to learn it if it's not important to what they're doing.

Write a description. It isn't that hard. Write what each thing does, put them in a bulleted list for github and jam them into a paragraph for the manager description. Nobody wants to go through 2 links to find a non-description, and nobody wants to read source code.

Or don't do it, I can't make you and I still have no idea what the intent of this whole thing is. Most people won't download it then, you just won't hear anything from them because they won't bother leaving a bug.

For all I know it's a test to see who will download a set of custom nodes with no real description. ;-)