search

getgrav / grav-plugin-admin

Grav Admin Plugin
http://getgrav.org
MIT License
354 stars 227 forks source link

[UX issue] Non intuitive way to create translations of page / "Page has not been translated" and no way to handle it. #2160

Open dexterxx-pl opened 3 years ago

dexterxx-pl commented 3 years ago

Solved in second comment.

Issue

I can't create new page with translation for existing page. Trying to edit admin panel shows (1):

This page has not been translated to English language yet! Falling back to Polski language.

The language switcher on editing page (it is language switcher?) does nothing (2).

grav issue

Whatever which not yet translated language I'm gonna choose in drop-menu there's same behaviour.

grav issue

Reproduce

  1. Enable multilang
  2. Create new page on your context - whatever it finally would be the "default" language or first supported
  3. Try to edit translation page (any red dot in second screenshot)

or

  1. Edit any page with only one translation
  2. Play with language URL section of that page:

Config

languages:
  supported:
    - pl
    - en
  default_lang: pl
  include_default_lang: true
  include_default_lang_file_extension: false
  translations: true
  translations_fallback: true
  session_store_active: false
  http_accept_language: false
  override_locale: false
  pages_fallback_only: false

Admin account config

language: en
content_editor: default

Admin plugin conf

route: '/somewhere'

What I tried

  1. Change user context / relogin -- same issue
  2. Playing with almost all settings from languages section.
  3. Default admin plugin conf (ommit route confi)

Workaround

Manually create file for specified translation eg. default.en.md. After that you can edit both languages.

Could not find workaround without server access / using Admin panel.

Some more info

  1. Looks like admin panel improperly failing back with language - should allow to create file if it not exists for specified language
  2. Even if I have two files default.md and default.en.md the default file is in lang switcher interpreted as first language (Polish) - cannot choose "default" instead of first language. That should be also fixed IMO - to be able to manage default language in case having more than overall two.

Versions

Grav: latest 1.7.17 Grav admin: latest 1.10.17

dexterxx-pl commented 3 years ago

Oh boy...

That's not a bug but... UX issue.

I've found finally how it works.

  1. You need to open content that already you have created in specified language.
  2. Translate it.
  3. Use little dropdown and "Save as ..."

oh boy

Not fully intuitive. I've spent hour jumping around it and creating issue... :cry:

angusmcb commented 3 years ago

+1 for fixing this 'bug'.

I came here to file the same bug report, although thanks to @dexterxx-pl I now have the work around :-)