The stack cannot be correctly deobfuscation

JDongKhan commented 6 months ago

Hello, I am a Flutter developer and I will be preparing to use Sentry to collect user crash reports. During the testing process, I found that the Flutter code was not properly deobfuscation, and I also uploaded the symbol file according to the Sentry Dart plugin document. Did I do something wrong with this?

build app

 flutter build ios --obfuscate --split-debug-info=build

upload symbol files

 flutter packages pub run sentry_dart_plugin

configure

  upload_debug_symbols: true
  upload_source_maps: true
  upload_sources: false
  project: flutter_test
  org: tc-tc
  url:  https://sentry.io
  commits: auto
  ignore_missing: true
  wait_for_processing: true
  log_level: info

I found that app.ios-arm64.symbols symbols file was not uploaded to the sentry.

buenaflor commented 6 months ago

Hi which version of the plugin and flutter SDK are you using?

JDongKhan commented 6 months ago

The latest version

  sentry: ^8.1.0
  sentry_dart_plugin: ^2.0.0

buenaflor commented 6 months ago

@JDongKhan thanks, can you try the plugin 1.7.1? It might be an issue with 2.0.0

JDongKhan commented 6 months ago

It still exists.

 flutter packages pub run sentry_dart_plugin

[❚❚❚❚❚❚❚❚❚❚❚❚❚❚❚❚❚❚❚❚❚❚] 0% reading config values..        
Downloaded Sentry CLI binary checksum verification passed successfully (hash: 8693527282890285f55d9b55414905e8621dd788ad3ae4c85175b84e8eeb6a04).

retrieving config from pubspec.yaml
☑ reading config values                                                             
☑ validating config values                                                             
[❚❚❚❚❚❚❚❚❚❚❚❚❚❚❚❚❚❚❚❚❚❚] 18% uploading debug symbols..                                
includeSources is disabled, not uploading sources.

INFO    2024-05-14 09:16:19.453377 +08:00 sentry-cli was invoked with the following command line: "/Users/jd/Documents/Developer/flutter_sentry/.dart_tool/pub/bin/sentry_dart_plugin/sentry-cli" "--url" "https://sentry.io" "--auth-token" "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" "--log-level" "info" "debug-files" "upload" "--org" "tc-tc" "--project" "flutter_test" "/Users/jd/Documents/Developer/flutter_sentry" "--wait"
  INFO    2024-05-14 09:16:19.453634 +08:00 Issuing a command for Organization: tc-tc Project: flutter_test

> Found 48 debug information files

> Prepared debug information files for upload

> Uploaded 21 missing debug information files

> File processing complete:

       OK 81edf08c-2467-393a-ba8d-1c0f3fb75220 (App; arm64 library)
       OK 81edf08c-2467-393a-ba8d-1c0f3fb75220 (App; arm64 debug companion)
       OK 81edf08c-2467-393a-ba8d-1c0f3fb75220 (App; arm64 library)
       OK 4c4c441b-5555-3144-a195-4ed41e4451ee (Flutter; arm64 library)
       OK bc79134a-4383-30b5-bf4e-3902b5c2617a (Runner; arm64 executable)
       OK bc79134a-4383-30b5-bf4e-3902b5c2617a (Runner; arm64 debug companion)
       OK ad0cad3b-1b51-3327-8644-8be1ff1f0ae9 (libswiftCore.dylib; arm64 library)
       OK e4b0cd52-10f6-32f3-9855-e87134f2d030 (libswiftCoreAudio.dylib; arm64 library)
       OK 25114ae1-4ae9-3dbc-b3de-7f9f9a5b45d2 (libswiftCoreFoundation.dylib; arm64 library)
       OK dc548ef9-00f9-3a15-b5db-05e39d9b5c5b (libswiftCoreGraphics.dylib; arm64 library)
       OK 62f04b7b-b664-3893-b12d-9a999cc44faf (libswiftCoreImage.dylib; arm64 library)
       OK 2989001b-87a1-36f3-80ce-9a9bc6a5e194 (libswiftCoreMedia.dylib; arm64 library)
       OK 999c2967-8a06-3cd5-82d7-d156e9440a0c (libswiftDarwin.dylib; arm64 library)
       OK 9fcba8ed-d8fd-3c16-9740-5e2a31f3e959 (libswiftDispatch.dylib; arm64 library)
       OK 9702769f-1f06-3001-ab75-5ad38e1f7d66 (libswiftFoundation.dylib; arm64 library)
       OK c466f0fe-15c1-33ee-bd5b-395407bd9982 (libswiftMetal.dylib; arm64 library)
       OK 1180ac10-0a92-39db-8497-2b6d4217b8eb (libswiftObjectiveC.dylib; arm64 library)
       OK c22bc3e2-45df-3516-95f3-31d55e664a89 (libswiftQuartzCore.dylib; arm64 library)
       OK 107c11f3-dd62-3fb4-9c8a-c74bd56c2abc (libswiftUIKit.dylib; arm64 library)
       OK 4a3b0c78-ffb3-358b-9a11-9d40c6999ffd (libswiftos.dylib; arm64 library)
       OK da93014d-0455-3eb6-8cf6-f29ebf8dc160 (package_info_plus; arm64 library)
☑ uploading debug symbols                                                             

INFO    2024-05-14 09:16:39.144015 +08:00 sentry-cli was invoked with the following command line: "/Users/jd/Documents/Developer/flutter_sentry/.dart_tool/pub/bin/sentry_dart_plugin/sentry-cli" "--url" "https://sentry.io" "--auth-token" "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" "--log-level" "info" "releases" "--org" "tc-tc" "--project" "flutter_test" "new" "flutter_sentry@1.0.2+1"

Created release flutter_sentry@1.0.2+1
[❚❚❚❚❚❚❚❚❚❚❚❚❚❚❚❚❚❚❚❚❚❚] 27% uploading source maps..                               
INFO    2024-05-14 09:16:40.383401 +08:00 sentry-cli was invoked with the following command line: "/Users/jd/Documents/Developer/flutter_sentry/.dart_tool/pub/bin/sentry_dart_plugin/sentry-cli" "--url" "https://sentry.io" "--auth-token" "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" "--log-level" "info" "releases" "--org" "tc-tc" "--project" "flutter_test" "files" "flutter_sentry@1.0.2+1" "upload-sourcemaps" "/Users/jd/Documents/Developer/flutter_sentry/build/web" "--ext" "map" "--ext" "js" "--dist" "1" "--wait"

> Rewriting sources
> Adding source map references

> Nothing to upload

INFO    2024-05-14 09:16:42.182767 +08:00 sentry-cli was invoked with the following command line: "/Users/jd/Documents/Developer/flutter_sentry/.dart_tool/pub/bin/sentry_dart_plugin/sentry-cli" "--url" "https://sentry.io" "--auth-token" "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" "--log-level" "info" "releases" "--org" "tc-tc" "--project" "flutter_test" "files" "flutter_sentry@1.0.2+1" "upload-sourcemaps" "/Users/jd/Documents/Developer/flutter_sentry" "--ext" "dart" "--dist" "1" "--wait"

> Found 2 files
> Analyzing 2 sources

> Rewriting sources
> Adding source map references

> Bundled 2 files for upload
> Bundle ID: 2a731a5b-e54a-54cd-b5f1-11d87d8129b4

> Nothing to upload, all files are on the server

> File processing complete
> Organization: tc-tc
> Project: flutter_test
> Release: flutter_sentry@1.0.2+1
> Dist: 1
> Upload type: artifact bundle

Source Map Upload Report
  Scripts
    ~/lib/main.dart
    ~/test/widget_test.dart
☑ uploading source maps                                                             

Commit integration is disabled.

INFO    2024-05-14 09:16:44.117359 +08:00 sentry-cli was invoked with the following command line: "/Users/jd/Documents/Developer/flutter_sentry/.dart_tool/pub/bin/sentry_dart_plugin/sentry-cli" "--url" "https://sentry.io" "--auth-token" "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" "--log-level" "info" "releases" "--org" "tc-tc" "--project" "flutter_test" "finalize" "flutter_sentry@1.0.2+1"

Finalized release flutter_sentry@1.0.2+1

JDongKhan commented 6 months ago

buenaflor commented 6 months ago

Could you share more about your set up? is this problem only on iOS ?

JDongKhan commented 6 months ago

None of it works. This is my example. https://github.com/JDongKhan/flutter_sentry_demo

buenaflor commented 6 months ago

can you confirm that the debug symbols have been uploaded to sentry?

JDongKhan commented 6 months ago

It exists for android, but not work.

for ios, the app.ios-arm64 file not uploaded.

denrase commented 5 months ago

@JDongKhan Looking through the sample, there were several configuration issues.

You need to use SentryFlutter.init instead of Sentry.init
You need to provide sentry with the app runner
You don't need to call WidgetsFlutterBinding.ensureInitialized(); in your main app
You don't need a custom FlutterError.onError, sentry is handling this automatically for you
You don't need to manually set the options.release, this format is used per default
You don't need to provide the url param in the plugin config with sentry.io, this is the default

After fixing those I could capture a sample exception and see it with stacktrace on sentry.io:

Check out the documentation on how to further config Sentry: https://docs.sentry.io/platforms/flutter/

alanalanlu commented 3 months ago

@denrase is it possible to do this for sentry-dart and not sentry-flutter? I cannot use sentry-flutter for app size limitations

buenaflor commented 3 months ago

@alanalanlu you mean only using sentry-dart (e.g Sentry.init instead of SentryFlutter.init) in flutter applications?

denrase commented 3 months ago

@alanalanlu @buenaflor How much overhead does sentry-flutter add compared to sentry-dart in your case?

alanalanlu commented 3 months ago

@denrase sentr-flutter is 2-3mb while sentry-dart is ~250kb

alanalanlu commented 3 months ago

@ buenaflor yes Sentry.init and not SentryFlutter.init

buenaflor commented 2 months ago

@alanalanlu we have released sentry-dart/flutter8.9.0 which allows you to have stacktrace symbolication with only using Sentry.init on iOS, macOS and Android. Please try it out.

getsentry / sentry-dart-plugin

The stack cannot be correctly deobfuscation #237