search

getsentry / sentry

Developer-first error tracking and performance monitoring
https://sentry.io
Other
39.16k stars 4.2k forks source link

Discord Global Integration or Slack Webhook Global Integration #10925

Closed nepeat closed 1 year ago

nepeat commented 5 years ago

Summary

With the new Global Integrations feature in Sentry, I've tried to adapt my existing setup that uses Discord's Slack compatible webhooks and found that the new Global Integrations feature uses Slack's oAuth API instead of webhook API. I am thinking that either the integration can be expanded to support Slack webhooks or have a separate integration for Discord.

Motivation

This would improve support for Discord, organizations that do not want to use slack apps and other chat apps that have Slack compatible webhook APIs, depending on the implementation.

Additional Context

evanpurkhiser commented 5 years ago

We've moved away from using Slack webhooks as they lacked a lot of flexibility which the (unfortunately now deprecated) workspace tokens provided us.

We don't currently have any plans to provide the webhook Slack interface through any integrations.

elderlabs commented 4 years ago

I believe there's been a bit of miscommunication/confusion here. The request is to add Discord webhook integration, which is identical to the now deprecated legacy Slack webhook. This is not asking to use anything related to Slack whatsoever. More here: getsentry/sentry-plugins/#249

nepeat commented 4 years ago

Correct. At the time I did not realize that the legacy Slack webhook settings were hidden behind the search menu and I made a issue that is definitely unclear now. As the issue's original text stands, I should have split it down to two separate issues.

  1. Adding an integration for native Discord webhooks.
  2. Re adding Slack webhooks to the Slack integration to support workgroups that do not wish to use Slack apps or have similar chat services that support Slack webhooks.

I am more interested in the first, like the majority of users but I recognize that the second case is also a thing that would be nice with the potential for future services that implement the Slack hooks API.

rdvo commented 4 years ago

I too want this integration to my Discord. I saw a prior thread mentioned using the Slack (Legacy) integration and modifying the URL's for discord as a work around, but i know longer see that in the integrations search results

Thanks

jacc commented 4 years ago

+1 on this, if possible it would be appreciated.

StoneSet commented 4 years ago

+1, good idea !

vitormm commented 4 years ago

+1, it would be great!

scrlkx commented 4 years ago

+1, we need it.

arjunbazinga commented 4 years ago

+1 Would love this

Russia9 commented 4 years ago

+1, good!

SebastianGiro commented 4 years ago

+1 We need this integration, the webhook plugin is not working correctly with discord and the slack legacy plugin (that we can use for discord) is not in the list anymore. Can you recheck this issue please? @EvanPurkhiser

elderlabs commented 4 years ago

I should have dropped a note here a few days ago. Sorry folks 😅

You can still use the old Slack Legacy Webhook Integration, but it's hidden. You can find it by navigating to your team/project's settings page and appending /plugins/slack/ to the URL.

Example: https://sentry.io/settings/ORG_ID/projects/PROJECT_NAME/plugins/slack/

From there, you configure the Webhook URL provided from your desired Discord Channel with /slack appended to the end of the URL.

Example: https://canary.discord.com/api/webhooks/###channel-id-here###/###elaborate-webhook-key-here###/slack

I personally have a Bot Name and Tags configured/enabled, but otherwise you should be able to leave the rest of the settings blank.

Don't forget to enable the plugin! Afterwards, it will appear in your integrations as 'Slack (Legacy).'

Enjoy!

SebastianGiro commented 4 years ago

I should have dropped a note here a few days ago. Sorry folks 😅

You can still use the old Slack Legacy Webhook Integration, but it's hidden. You can find it by navigating to your team/project's settings page and appending /plugins/slack/ to the URL.

Example: https://sentry.io/settings/###my-team-name-or-whatever###/plugins/slack/

From there, you configure the Webhook URL provided from your desired Discord Channel with /slack appended to the end of the URL.

Example: https://canary.discord.com/api/webhooks/###channel-id-here###/###elaborate-webhook-key-here###/slack

I personally have a Bot Name and Tags configured/enabled, but otherwise you should be able to leave the rest of the settings blank.

Don't forget to enable the plugin! Afterwards, it will appear in your integrations as 'Slack (Legacy).'

Enjoy!

Amazing, please leave a // NOTE to never fully remove it, so we can keep using it for discord. Thanks! Working great

evanpurkhiser commented 4 years ago

+1 We need this integration, the webhook plugin is not working correctly with discord and the slack legacy plugin (that we can use for discord) is not in the list anymore. Can you recheck this issue please? @EvanPurkhiser

I can't speak towards any roadmap on adding Discord, but I do know someone who may be able to!

/cc @jonesphillip to get this on your radar :)

(also I think my comment above may have been my most downvoted comment on github haha)

dkotama commented 4 years ago

I should have dropped a note here a few days ago. Sorry folks 😅 You can still use the old Slack Legacy Webhook Integration, but it's hidden. You can find it by navigating to your team/project's settings page and appending /plugins/slack/ to the URL. Example: https://sentry.io/settings/###my-team-name-or-whatever###/plugins/slack/ From there, you configure the Webhook URL provided from your desired Discord Channel with /slack appended to the end of the URL. Example: https://canary.discord.com/api/webhooks/###channel-id-here###/###elaborate-webhook-key-here###/slack I personally have a Bot Name and Tags configured/enabled, but otherwise you should be able to leave the rest of the settings blank. Don't forget to enable the plugin! Afterwards, it will appear in your integrations as 'Slack (Legacy).' Enjoy!

Amazing, please leave a // NOTE to never fully remove it, so we can keep using it for discord. Thanks! Working great

Thank you, I just want to add that you should enable the rules for legacy notification for each event happened at project via : https://sentry.io/settings/YOUR_TEAM_NAME/projects/YOUR_PROJECTS/alerts/

Screen Shot 2020-06-02 at 14 51 38
victornpb commented 4 years ago

How to add discord webhook to sentry

  1. Visit this hidden page https://sentry.io/settings/PROJECT_NAME/plugins/slack/

  2. Enable the plugin image

  3. Add to project Add to project

  4. Configure webhook Configuring webhook

  5. Click Test

  6. Now enable an Alert rule to your project Navigate to https://sentry.io/settings/ORG/projects/PROJECT/alerts/

noisyblue commented 4 years ago

I couldn't access webhook configuration page using https://sentry.io/settings/PROJECT_NAME/plugins/slack/ Instead https://sentry.io/settings/ORG_ID/projects/PROJECT_NAME/plugins/slack/ worked.

elderlabs commented 4 years ago

I couldn't access webhook configuration page using https://sentry.io/settings/PROJECT_NAME/plugins/slack/ Instead https://sentry.io/settings/ORG_ID/projects/PROJECT_NAME/plugins/slack/ worked.

@noisyblue updated my post to reflect your correction. Thank you.

nemoralis commented 3 years ago

+1

HunterInSpace commented 3 years ago

Discord Webhook Integration would be awesome; +1

ooo27 commented 3 years ago

Is this still working? When I click Test Plugin I receive:

"There was an internal error with the Plugin, {\"message\": \"Cannot send an empty message\", \"code\": 50006}"

elderlabs commented 3 years ago

Is this still working? When I click Test Plugin I receive:

"There was an internal error with the Plugin, {"message": "Cannot send an empty message", "code": 50006}"

Depends on your config, likely there's something misconfigured. This still works.

ooo27 commented 3 years ago

Is this still working? When I click Test Plugin I receive:

"There was an internal error with the Plugin, {"message": "Cannot send an empty message", "code": 50006}"

Depends on your config, likely there's something misconfigured. This still works.

Indeed it was a configuration error. I neglected to change the endpoint from discord.com to canary.discord.com. Thanks!

IanMitchell commented 3 years ago

I wrote a service to forward Sentry Webhooks to Discord - it adds more information than the Slack compatible one does. I'm still testing its reliability, but if anyone is interested in richer embeds check out https://sentrydiscord.dev (repo)

jonesphillip commented 3 years ago

@IanMitchell This is great! Would love to discuss how we could get involved, I'll reach out.

landsman commented 3 years ago

Yes please!

igl commented 2 years ago

We will enter 2022 without discord integration? What the!

FeMaffezzolli commented 2 years ago

Any update?

I've been using this service as a workaround -> https://sentrydiscord.dev/.

elderlabs commented 2 years ago

Any update?

I've been using this service as a workaround -> https://sentrydiscord.dev/.

There are multiple posts here detailing how to natively configure Sentry to work with Discord using the legacy Slack integration. As for something labeled "Discord" in Sentry, no dice as of yet.

guntiss commented 2 years ago

Please Sentry, this is a must have feature. It's shame that we need to use some workarounds or hacks to receive notifications on a mainstream platform...

Benoss commented 2 years ago

With the new Free tier slack model and the increase of the paid plan on Slack. I am exploring moving to Discord instead of Slack as our company communication app. Sentry Slack integration is really good, would love to have the same on Discord!

raphahardt commented 2 years ago

+1

boosteffect commented 2 years ago

+1 DIscord integration would be awesome

Lutacon commented 1 year ago

+1 Discord integration

braincomb commented 1 year ago

We will enter 2022 without discord integration? What the!

We are entering 2023 without Discord integration still.

therealarkin commented 1 year ago

Hi Folks! Welcome to 2023 :-)

I would love to learn more about Discord so that we can properly think about it -

  1. Why do you need discord integration?
  2. What type of projects/company are you part of?
  3. If you used Slack+Sentry, what do you like about it? What did you dislike?
  4. If you used https://sentrydiscord.dev/, what did you like about it? What did you dislike?
  5. Are there any Discord-specific patterns/capabilities that we should consider?
chris-erickson commented 1 year ago

Thanks for the questions!

  1. We use Slack now, and are likely to move to Discord for it's better positioning as a community hub.
  2. All our internal app, maybe 10-20 from web frontend, backends and all kinds of other behind the scenes apps.
  3. We like that it works, and notifies us of things. Not really much to dislike, it's just far better than email alerts which don't scale well for an open-ish development process. We have many people who one would consider developers, but they aren't added to most systems for quite a long time, for security reasons. This also is how we immediately discuss an issue, or reference it in conversations around Slack.
  4. That third-party thing seems to make really nicely formatted messages in Discord. A lot more detail than Slack has, it seems. Not sure that would always be desired but it's nice looking.
  5. We aren't super expert users of Discord so no use cases immediately come to mind. Maybe @ mentioning Roles?
cognitus commented 1 year ago
  1. Discord is our main method of communicating in our (small) team
  2. We develop Internal apps and web application for business in our country
  3. -
  4. Pretty easy for use inside discord, details of context (it would be nice if was editable). About dislike... the lack configure propriety alerts, sometimes doesn't work with multiples proyects
  5. Alert to roles (mentioning). The use of threads, https://support.discord.com/hc/en-us/articles/4403205878423-Threads-FAQ
IanMitchell commented 1 year ago

Happy to chat about both the limitations of sentrydiscord and what Sentry could do with the Discord API if you'd like! I had a plan for how to convert the service into a bot, but unfortunately time just hasn't allowed it 😅

SteffanDonal commented 1 year ago

Responding to the list, too!

  1. In my case, Discord is the primary place our team communicates, and it acts as our shared inbox. I want to improve the visibility of incoming issues and provide a "single dashboard" for the team to pay attention to.
  2. Distributed, muti-timezone collaboration for desktop applications.
  3. Been many years since I used it!
  4. I think simply having notifications with links to the web is just the "minimum effort" kind of integration. Discord bots can have many interactive features that could significantly smooth our workflow! New issues could come in with buttons that allow quick muting/assignment/triage without having to leave the Discord app.
  5. Role mentions, as the others have said, but taking full advantage of Discord embeds, commands and interactions. Discord can show select boxes, text inputs, buttons, and modals.

I'd like to see "regular workflow" parts of Sentry implemented within Discord in ways that encourage developers to engage more with it!

nepeat commented 1 year ago

Hi Folks! Welcome to 2023 :-)

I would love to learn more about Discord so that we can properly think about it -

  1. Why do you need discord integration?
  2. What type of projects/company are you part of?
  3. If you used Slack+Sentry, what do you like about it? What did you dislike?
  4. If you used https://sentrydiscord.dev/, what did you like about it? What did you dislike?
  5. Are there any Discord-specific patterns/capabilities that we should consider?

Hello again, it's been 5 years! Hoping that more traction for a native integration with Discord is coming this year~

  1. Discord is the only communications platform of my hackerspace and other groups that I know. We have used the Slack integration which sorta works but given the lesser priority Slack webhooks have been given, it is a lesser experience than going native with the notifications.
  2. Hackerspace with a few bots and backend facing services.
  3. N/A, never used it with Slack.
  4. N/A, never used that service.
  5. Embed colors, embed fields, arbitrary user names and icons based on projects, more customizability that integrated with the Discord ecosystem, and adding interactiveness (Ack/Mute/etc) to responses to the alerts.
krokovicsmate commented 1 year ago

Hi all!

  1. Our company just moved to discord from slack, and we love the slack integration and we are really missing the features of it.
  2. PHP projects, mostly CMS, CRM and Webshop systems.
  3. The most missing part of it the mention system, we configured the integration to mention a person who is leading the project.
  4. Missing options, only the default layout of messages available.
  5. The mention sytem :)
irfanfadilah commented 1 year ago

Whoa, it's been more than 4 years and still no native integration for Discord.

joaofraga commented 1 year ago

Why do you need discord integration? It's the main communication channel of my company.

What type of projects/company are you part of? Payments

If you used Slack+Sentry, what do you like about it? What did you dislike? TBH I haven't used Slack integration before.

If you used https://sentrydiscord.dev/, what did you like about it? What did you dislike? It did not work for me, it asks me to add a discord webhook even though I add the correct url.

Are there any Discord-specific patterns/capabilities that we should consider? Simple alerts are enough to me.

igl commented 1 year ago

Why do you need discord integration? It's the main communication channel of my company.

What type of projects/company are you part of? Development

If you used Slack+Sentry, what do you like about it? What did you dislike? The Slack client has very bad performance (not Sentrys fault)

If you used https://sentrydiscord.dev/, what did you like about it? What did you dislike? It did not work for me.

Are there any Discord-specific patterns/capabilities that we should consider? We need High visibility about new errors appearing after a release. Possiblity to get daily or weekly summaries.

ryantam626 commented 1 year ago

Just for more visbility - https://github.com/getsentry/sentry/pull/50623#issuecomment-1583985056 indicates that Discord integration work has already been started :tada:

I have a branch in my fork that added a stopgap solution that still uses webhook (but the native one) which allows mentioning, just in case this is of interests for folks that self hosts (like me).

getsantry[bot] commented 1 year ago

Routing to @getsentry/product-owners-settings-integrations for triage ⏲️

crabsinger commented 1 year ago

+1 would like this

spalmurray commented 1 year ago

Hey Everyone,

We’re excited to announce that the eagerly awaited Discord integration for Sentry is coming soon! 🎉

This integration will allow users to receive and act on notifications about critical issues as they are surfaced by Sentry, directly in Discord.

Issue alerts support will come first with plans to support metric alerts and personal notifications in the future.

You can sign up here to gain early access to the latest functionality and give us input as we build.

If you have any questions or feedback, please get in touch with us on our Discord server in the #discord-integration channel.

Thank you all for advocating for this feature and sharing your use cases with us!

Spencer from Sentry

braincomb commented 1 year ago

@spalmurray very excited to try this!