microwindows on 64bit ARM

[uklatt]

I try to port an existing microwindows program from i.MX6 (32 Bit code, 16 Bit framebuffer) to i.MX8 (64 Bit code, 32 Bit framebuffer).

I can compile the libs and demo programs. When starting mdemo (or any other microwindows programs), the program crashes.

It looks like tbe initial erasing of the framebuffer is not working and there are writes outside of the allowed framebuffer memory.

Should the code work with a 64Bit compiler?

Uwe

[ghaerr]

Hello @uklatt,

Should the code work with a 64Bit compiler?

Yes - Microwindows has been working on 64-bit systems for some time.

It looks like tbe initial erasing of the framebuffer is not working and there are writes outside of the allowed framebuffer memory.

Are you running the drivers/scr_fb.c framebuffer driver? It sounds like perhaps the framebuffer width, stride or overall length/height values might be improperly set. Another possibility is that your framebuffer requires 64-bit (not 32-bit) writes, or otherwise segfaults. If this is the case, then we'll have to look into rewriting whichever framebuffer sub driver you're using (likely drivers/fblin32.c) to use 64-bit moves when accessing the framebuffer. IIRC some of the upper-level routines may expect only 32-bit padding for images etc, which might also have to change.

Thank you!

[ghaerr]

I try to port an existing microwindows program from i.MX6 (32 Bit code, 16 Bit framebuffer) to i.MX8 (64 Bit code, 32 Bit framebuffer).

Oops - I missed that! This means you can likely ignore my last comment about 64-bit framebuffer. Perhaps the issue then is that the scr_fb.c framebuffer driver is not picking up the fblin32.c 32-bit linear driver, or that the size (length in bytes) of the framebuffer is incorrect.

[uklatt]

Hi @ghaerr Thank you for the fast comment! I checked with an older version 0.91 with some additions. Now I am testing with the last 0.92 from http://www.microwindows.org/

With this version I have a different error:

Starting program: /home/root/mtest/mtest [Thread debugging using libthread_db enabled] Using host libthread_db library "/lib/libthread_db.so.1". 1920x1080x32bpp linelen 7680 type 0 visual 2 colors 281470698520576 pixtype 3 createfont: (height == 0) found builtin font System (0) createfont: (height == 0) found builtin font System (0) createfont: (height == 0) found builtin font System (0) Program received signal SIGSEGV, Segmentation fault. 0x0000aaaaaaaa973c in FillRect (hdc=0xaaaaaab1dde0, lprc=0xfffffffff568, hbr=0xaab103b8) at /home/root/microwindows-0.92/src/mwin/wingdi.c:766 766 if(obr->style == BS_NULL) (gdb) bt

0 0x0000aaaaaaaa973c in FillRect (hdc=0xaaaaaab1dde0, lprc=0xfffffffff568, hbr=0xaab103b8)

at /home/root/microwindows-0.92/src/mwin/wingdi.c:766

1 0x0000aaaaaaaaec2c in DefWindowProc (hwnd=0xaaaaaab1d970, msg=20, wParam=2863783280, lParam=0)

at /home/root/microwindows-0.92/src/mwin/windefw.c:366

2 0x0000aaaaaaaa2be4 in wproc (hwnd=0xaaaaaab1d970, iMsg=20, wParam=2863783280, lParam=0)

at mtest.c:70

3 0x0000aaaaaaaa439c in SendMessage (hwnd=0xaaaaaab1d970, Msg=20, wParam=2863783280, lParam=0)

at /home/root/microwindows-0.92/src/mwin/winuser.c:81

4 0x0000aaaaaaaa83c4 in BeginPaint (hwnd=0xaaaaaab1d970, lpPaint=0xfffffffff820)

at /home/root/microwindows-0.92/src/mwin/wingdi.c:223

5 0x0000aaaaaaaa2b7c in wproc (hwnd=0xaaaaaab1d970, iMsg=15, wParam=0, lParam=0) at mtest.c:60

6 0x0000aaaaaaaa439c in SendMessage (hwnd=0xaaaaaab1d970, Msg=15, wParam=0, lParam=0)

at /home/root/microwindows-0.92/src/mwin/winuser.c:81

7 0x0000aaaaaaaa5800 in UpdateWindow (hwnd=0xaaaaaab1d970)

at /home/root/microwindows-0.92/src/mwin/winuser.c:769

8 0x0000aaaaaaaa2ad8 in WinMain (hInstance=0xaaaaaab1d670, hPrevInstance=0x0,

szCmdLine=0xaaaaaab1d6b0 "", iCmdShow=5) at mtest.c:41

9 0x0000aaaaaaaa2c94 in main (ac=1, av=0xfffffffffb78)

at /home/root/microwindows-0.92/src/mwin/winmain.c:115 My framebuffer:

fbset -i mode "1920x1080" geometry 1920 1080 1920 1080 32 timings 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 accel true rgba 8/16,8/8,8/0,0/0 endmode Frame buffer device information: Name : imx-drmdrmfb Address : (nil) Size : 8294400 Type : PACKED PIXELS Visual : TRUECOLOR XPanStep : 1 YPanStep : 1 YWrapStep : 0 LineLength : 7680 Accelerator : No

My config: config.txt

[ghaerr]

Looking at your stack trace, I can see the problem with v0.92 that you're running: the hbr HBRUSH is being truncated from 64 to 32 bits:

Program received signal SIGSEGV, Segmentation fault. 0x0000aaaaaaaa973c in FillRect (hdc=0xaaaaaab1dde0, lprc=0xfffffffff568, hbr=0xaab103b8) at /home/root/microwindows-0.92/src/mwin/wingdi.c:766

Notice that the heap variables are all at addresses 0x0000aaaaaaaa.... while hbr above has its high 32 bits zero. This was fixed on 18 Dec 2018 in commit https://github.com/ghaerr/microwindows/commit/a3564f45d2332b4765dd935878b8b56fdcb9195f as can be seen in the "blame" report on src/mwin/windefw.c. Long story short - v0.92 is not 64-bit compiler clean and should not be used.

If you can produce a stack trace of the latest source code segfault I can probably help get this problem figured out.

Thank you!

[uklatt]

Hi Greg, many thanks for this tip! I will try the last snapshot next week and report what happens...

[uklatt]

@ghaerr I was able to compile and run the last snapshot 0.94 with success! Thank you for your help!