search

ghoti57 / evofw3

Major overhaul of evofw2 Evohome listening software to use asynchronous radio mode
60 stars 10 forks source link

Sending commands #2

Closed dystechnic closed 3 years ago

dystechnic commented 4 years ago

Hi,

I'm using evfw3 on a DiY NanoCul and receiving communication from the evohome environment goes well. I also tried to send commands but without result. Is sending of commands supported with evofw3?

Regards, Ed.

ghoti57 commented 4 years ago

Ed,

I've only just got TX working (this week!) but it's had limited test.

You currently need to use the UART branch, it hasn't been merged to master yet.

Feedback at this stage very welcome

Pete

On 25 Aug 2020, 16:47, at 16:47, dystechnic notifications@github.com wrote:

Hi,

I'm using evfw3 on a DiY NanoCul and receiving communication from the evohome environment goes well. I also tried to send commands but without result. Is sending of commands supported with evofw3?

Regards, Ed.

-- You are receiving this because you are subscribed to this thread. Reply to this email directly or view it on GitHub: https://github.com/ghoti57/evofw3/issues/2

dystechnic commented 4 years ago

Thanx. I will try that branche this weekend. I have a separate Cul for testing purposes only, so it won't interfere with my production environment ;-)

I'll keep you informed of the results.

dystechnic commented 4 years ago

Hi Pete,

I did some testing with the UART branche tonight. But without success for now. First I tried to change a setpoint of one of my TRV's. to 15 degrees This was the result:

2020-08-26 20:25:23 |1/ - | COMMAND_OUT         | SETPOINT_OVERRIDE ['Woonkamer': 15 deg C] Command SENT
2020-08-26 20:25:53 |     | COMMAND_OUT         | SETPOINT_OVERRIDE ['Woonkamer': 15 deg C] Command NOT acknowledged. Resending attempt 1 of 5...
2020-08-26 20:25:53 |1/ - | COMMAND_OUT         | SETPOINT_OVERRIDE ['Woonkamer': 15 deg C] Command SENT
2020-08-26 20:25:53 |1/000| SETPOINT_OVERRIDE   | W | GWAY EvoGateway        -> 01:139901              | 15.00°C @ Woonkamer               [Zone 1  ]
2020-08-26 20:26:23 |     | COMMAND_OUT         | SETPOINT_OVERRIDE ['Woonkamer': 15 deg C] Command NOT acknowledged. Resending attempt 2 of 5...
2020-08-26 20:26:23 |1/ - | COMMAND_OUT         | SETPOINT_OVERRIDE ['Woonkamer': 15 deg C] Command SENT
2020-08-26 20:26:23 |1/000| SETPOINT_OVERRIDE   | W | GWAY EvoGateway        -> 01:139901              | 15.00°C @ Woonkamer               [Zone 1  ]
2020-08-26 20:26:53 |     | COMMAND_OUT         | SETPOINT_OVERRIDE ['Woonkamer': 15 deg C] Command NOT acknowledged. Resending attempt 3 of 5...
2020-08-26 20:26:53 |1/ - | COMMAND_OUT         | SETPOINT_OVERRIDE ['Woonkamer': 15 deg C] Command SENT
2020-08-26 20:26:53 |1/000| SETPOINT_OVERRIDE   | W | GWAY EvoGateway        -> 01:139901              | 15.00°C @ Woonkamer               [Zone 1  ]
2020-08-26 20:27:23 |     | COMMAND_OUT         | SETPOINT_OVERRIDE ['Woonkamer': 15 deg C] Command NOT acknowledged. Resending attempt 4 of 5...
2020-08-26 20:27:23 |1/ - | COMMAND_OUT         | SETPOINT_OVERRIDE ['Woonkamer': 15 deg C] Command SENT
2020-08-26 20:27:23 |1/000| SETPOINT_OVERRIDE   | W | GWAY EvoGateway        -> 01:139901              | 15.00°C @ Woonkamer               [Zone 1  ]
2020-08-26 20:27:53 |     | COMMAND_OUT         | SETPOINT_OVERRIDE ['Woonkamer': 15 deg C] Command NOT acknowledged. Resending attempt 5 of 5...
2020-08-26 20:27:53 |1/ - | COMMAND_OUT         | SETPOINT_OVERRIDE ['Woonkamer': 15 deg C] Command SENT
2020-08-26 20:27:53 |1/000| SETPOINT_OVERRIDE   | W | GWAY EvoGateway        -> 01:139901              | 15.00°C @ Woonkamer               [Zone 1  ]
2020-08-26 20:27:53 |     | COMMAND             | ERROR: Previously sent command 'setpoint_override' failed to send. No ack received from controller

Then I tried a ping to the controller, and this was the result:

2020-08-26 20:30:01 |1/ - | COMMAND_OUT         | PING : Command SENT
2020-08-26 20:30:01 |1/000| DATE_REQUEST        | RQ| GWAY EvoGateway        -> 01:139901              | Ping/Datetime Sync
2020-08-26 20:30:31 |     | COMMAND_OUT         | PING : Command NOT acknowledged. Resending attempt 1 of 5...
2020-08-26 20:30:31 |1/ - | COMMAND_OUT         | PING : Command SENT
2020-08-26 20:30:42 |1/000| DATE_REQUEST        | RQ| GWAY EvoGateway        -> 01:139901              | Ping/Datetime Sync
2020-08-26 20:31:01 |     | COMMAND_OUT         | PING : Command NOT acknowledged. Resending attempt 2 of 5...
2020-08-26 20:31:01 |1/ - | COMMAND_OUT         | PING : Command SENT
2020-08-26 20:31:01 |1/000| DATE_REQUEST        | RQ| GWAY EvoGateway        -> 01:139901              | Ping/Datetime Sync
2020-08-26 20:31:31 |     | COMMAND_OUT         | PING : Command NOT acknowledged. Resending attempt 3 of 5...
2020-08-26 20:31:31 |1/ - | COMMAND_OUT         | PING : Command SENT
2020-08-26 20:31:31 |1/000| DATE_REQUEST        | RQ| GWAY EvoGateway        -> 01:139901              | Ping/Datetime Sync
2020-08-26 20:32:01 |     | COMMAND_OUT         | PING : Command NOT acknowledged. Resending attempt 4 of 5...
2020-08-26 20:32:01 |1/ - | COMMAND_OUT         | PING : Command SENT
2020-08-26 20:32:01 |1/000| DATE_REQUEST        | RQ| GWAY EvoGateway        -> 01:139901              | Ping/Datetime Sync
2020-08-26 20:32:31 |     | COMMAND_OUT         | PING : Command NOT acknowledged. Resending attempt 5 of 5...
2020-08-26 20:32:31 |1/ - | COMMAND_OUT         | PING : Command SENT
2020-08-26 20:32:31 |1/000| DATE_REQUEST        | RQ| GWAY EvoGateway        -> 01:139901              | Ping/Datetime Sync
2020-08-26 20:32:32 |     | COMMAND             | ERROR: Previously sent command 'ping' failed to send. No ack received from controller

Thes logs are from the evo-listener script I use to read (and write)_ to the evo environment. The raw log for the two commands was:

2020-08-26 20:25:23 |-| MQTT_SUB           {u'command': u'setpoint_override', u'arguments': {u'setpoint': 15, u'zone_id': 1}}
2020-08-26 20:25:23 |1| COMMAND_OUT        SETPOINT_OVERRIDE: Sending 'W --- 30:071715 01:139901 --:------ 2349 007 0005DC02FFFFFF'
2020-08-26 20:25:53 |1| COMMAND_OUT        SETPOINT_OVERRIDE: Sending 'W --- 30:071715 01:139901 --:------ 2349 007 0005DC02FFFFFF'
2020-08-26 20:25:53 |1| RELAY_HEAT_DEMAND  --- 048  I --- 01:187875 --:------ 01:187875 0008 002 FC00
2020-08-26 20:25:53 |1| SETPOINT_OVERRIDE  --- 000  W --- 30:071715 01:139901 --:------ 2349 007 0005DC02FFFFFF
2020-08-26 20:26:03 |1| ZONE_HEAT_DEMAND   --- 072  I --- 04:024003 --:------ 01:187875 3150 002 0800
2020-08-26 20:26:15 |1| OPENTHERM_TICKER   --- 061  I --- 10:006288 --:------ 10:006288 1FD4 003 0069E1
2020-08-26 20:26:23 |1| COMMAND_OUT        SETPOINT_OVERRIDE: Sending 'W --- 30:071715 01:139901 --:------ 2349 007 0005DC02FFFFFF'
2020-08-26 20:26:23 |1| SETPOINT_OVERRIDE  --- 000  W --- 30:071715 01:139901 --:------ 2349 007 0005DC02FFFFFF
2020-08-26 20:26:44 |1| ZONE_TEMPERATURE   --- 057  I --- 04:170491 --:------ 04:170491 30C9 003 00081E
2020-08-26 20:26:53 |1| COMMAND_OUT        SETPOINT_OVERRIDE: Sending 'W --- 30:071715 01:139901 --:------ 2349 007 0005DC02FFFFFF'
2020-08-26 20:26:53 |1| SETPOINT_OVERRIDE  --- 000  W --- 30:071715 01:139901 --:------ 2349 007 0005DC02FFFFFF
2020-08-26 20:27:13 |1| ZONE_HEAT_DEMAND   --- 057  I --- 04:170491 --:------ 01:187875 3150 002 0500
2020-08-26 20:27:23 |1| COMMAND_OUT        SETPOINT_OVERRIDE: Sending 'W --- 30:071715 01:139901 --:------ 2349 007 0005DC02FFFFFF'
2020-08-26 20:27:23 |1| SETPOINT_OVERRIDE  --- 000  W --- 30:071715 01:139901 --:------ 2349 007 0005DC02FFFFFF
2020-08-26 20:27:53 |1| COMMAND_OUT        SETPOINT_OVERRIDE: Sending 'W --- 30:071715 01:139901 --:------ 2349 007 0005DC02FFFFFF'
2020-08-26 20:27:53 |1| SETPOINT_OVERRIDE  --- 000  W --- 30:071715 01:139901 --:------ 2349 007 0005DC02FFFFFF
2020-08-26 20:27:59 |1| SYNC               --- 048  I --- 01:187875 --:------ 01:187875 1F09 003 FF0744
2020-08-26 20:27:59 |1| SETPOINT_CTL       --- 048  I --- 01:187875 --:------ 01:187875 2309 030 0001F40101F40201F40301F40401F40501F40601F40701F40801F40901F4
2020-08-26 20:27:59 |1| ZONE_TEMPERATURE   --- 048  I --- 01:187875 --:------ 01:187875 30C9 030 007FFF017FFF027FFF037FFF047FFF05081E067FFF077FFF087FFF097FFF
2020-08-26 20:28:42 |1| WINDOW_STATUS      --- 055  I --- 04:042911 --:------ 01:187875 12B0 003 000000
2020-08-26 20:28:43 |1| OPENTHERM_TICKER   --- 061  I --- 10:006288 --:------ 10:006288 1FD4 003 0069E2
2020-08-26 20:28:43 |1| WINDOW_STATUS      --- 055  I --- 04:042911 --:------ 01:187875 12B0 003 000000
2020-08-26 20:29:06 |1| ZONE_HEAT_DEMAND   --- 044  I --- 04:170497 --:------ 01:187875 3150 002 0300
2020-08-26 20:30:01 |-| MQTT_SUB           {u'command': u'ping'}
2020-08-26 20:30:01 |1| COMMAND_OUT        PING: Sending 'RQ --- 30:071715 01:139901 --:------ 313F 001 00'
2020-08-26 20:30:01 |1| DATE_REQUEST       --- 000 RQ --- 30:071715 01:139901 --:------ 313F 001 00
2020-08-26 20:30:31 |1| COMMAND_OUT        PING: Sending 'RQ --- 30:071715 01:139901 --:------ 313F 001 00'
2020-08-26 20:30:42 |1| ACTUATOR_STATE     --- 061  I --- 10:006288 --:------ 10:006288 3EF0 009 0000100000FF020A00
2020-08-26 20:30:42 |1| DATE_REQUEST       --- 000 RQ --- 30:071715 01:139901 --:------ 313F 001 00
2020-08-26 20:31:01 |1| COMMAND_OUT        PING: Sending 'RQ --- 30:071715 01:139901 --:------ 313F 001 00'
2020-08-26 20:31:01 |1| DATE_REQUEST       --- 000 RQ --- 30:071715 01:139901 --:------ 313F 001 00
2020-08-26 20:31:05 |1| SYNC               --- 048  I --- 01:187875 --:------ 01:187875 1F09 003 FF0744
2020-08-26 20:31:05 |1| SETPOINT_CTL       --- 048  I --- 01:187875 --:------ 01:187875 2309 030 0001F40101F40201F40301F40401F40501F40601F40701F40801F40901F4
2020-08-26 20:31:05 |1| ZONE_TEMPERATURE   --- 048  I --- 01:187875 --:------ 01:187875 30C9 030 007FFF017FFF027FFF037FFF047FFF05081E067FFF077FFF087FFF097FFF
2020-08-26 20:31:10 |1| OPENTHERM_TICKER   --- 062  I --- 10:006288 --:------ 10:006288 1FD4 003 0069E3
2020-08-26 20:31:31 |1| COMMAND_OUT        PING: Sending 'RQ --- 30:071715 01:139901 --:------ 313F 001 00'
2020-08-26 20:31:31 |1| DATE_REQUEST       --- 000 RQ --- 30:071715 01:139901 --:------ 313F 001 00
2020-08-26 20:32:01 |1| COMMAND_OUT        PING: Sending 'RQ --- 30:071715 01:139901 --:------ 313F 001 00'
2020-08-26 20:32:01 |1| DATE_REQUEST       --- 000 RQ --- 30:071715 01:139901 --:------ 313F 001 00
2020-08-26 20:32:15 |1| ZONE_TEMPERATURE   --- 082  I --- 04:042913 --:------ 04:042913 30C9 003 0007ED
2020-08-26 20:32:29 |1| ZONE_TEMPERATURE   --- 070  I --- 04:024005 --:------ 04:024005 30C9 003 0007C9
2020-08-26 20:32:31 |1| COMMAND_OUT        PING: Sending 'RQ --- 30:071715 01:139901 --:------ 313F 001 00'
2020-08-26 20:32:31 |1| DATE_REQUEST       --- 000 RQ --- 30:071715 01:139901 --:------ 313F 001 00
2020-08-26 20:32:48 |1| ZONE_TEMPERATURE   --- 058  I --- 04:170491 --:------ 04:170491 30C9 003 00081B
2020-08-26 20:33:02 |1| WINDOW_STATUS      --- 081  I --- 04:042915 --:------ 01:187875 12B0 003 020000
2020-08-26 20:33:04 |1| WINDOW_STATUS      --- 082  I --- 04:042915 --:------ 01:187875 12B0 003 020000
2020-08-26 20:33:38 |1| OPENTHERM_TICKER   --- 061  I --- 10:006288 --:------ 10:006288 1FD4 003 0069E4
2020-08-26 20:33:44 |1| ZONE_TEMPERATURE   --- 077  I --- 04:024001 --:------ 04:024001 30C9 003 00079A
2020-08-26 20:33:56 |1| ACTUATOR_CHECK_REQ --- 048  I --- 01:187875 --:------ 01:187875 3B00 002 FCC8
2020-08-26 20:34:11 |1| SYNC               --- 048  I --- 01:187875 --:------ 01:187875 1F09 003 FF0744
2020-08-26 20:34:11 |1| SETPOINT_CTL       --- 048  I --- 01:187875 --:------ 01:187875 2309 030 0001F40101F40201F40301F40401F40501F40601F40701F40801F40901F4
2020-08-26 20:34:11 |1| ZONE_TEMPERATURE   --- 048  I --- 01:187875 --:------ 01:187875 30C9 030 007FFF017FFF027FFF037FFF047FFF05081B0607C907079A087FFF097FFF

There is some other communication in that log, but they are not relevant to this issue. Hope this helps you perfecting the code. If you want me to test something more specific, just let me know.

Regards, Ed.

ghoti57 commented 4 years ago

Can you ask the Evo listener developer for their view of what's happening. Tell them which evofw3.  I don't use this system and I have problems interpreting the logs.

I'd rather see the raw serial logs from the com port.

On 26 Aug 2020, 20:20, at 20:20, dystechnic notifications@github.com wrote:

Hi Pete,

I did some testing with the UART branche tonight. But without success for now. First I tried to change a setpoint of one of my TRV's. to 15 degrees This was the result:

2020-08-26 20:25:23 |1/ - | COMMAND_OUT         | SETPOINT_OVERRIDE
['Woonkamer': 15 deg C] Command SENT
2020-08-26 20:25:53 |     | COMMAND_OUT         | SETPOINT_OVERRIDE
['Woonkamer': 15 deg C] Command NOT acknowledged. Resending attempt 1
of 5...
2020-08-26 20:25:53 |1/ - | COMMAND_OUT         | SETPOINT_OVERRIDE
['Woonkamer': 15 deg C] Command SENT
2020-08-26 20:25:53 |1/000| SETPOINT_OVERRIDE   | W | GWAY EvoGateway  
-> 01:139901              | 15.00°C @ Woonkamer               [Zone 1 
]
2020-08-26 20:26:23 |     | COMMAND_OUT         | SETPOINT_OVERRIDE
['Woonkamer': 15 deg C] Command NOT acknowledged. Resending attempt 2
of 5...
2020-08-26 20:26:23 |1/ - | COMMAND_OUT         | SETPOINT_OVERRIDE
['Woonkamer': 15 deg C] Command SENT
2020-08-26 20:26:23 |1/000| SETPOINT_OVERRIDE   | W | GWAY EvoGateway  
-> 01:139901              | 15.00°C @ Woonkamer               [Zone 1 
]
2020-08-26 20:26:53 |     | COMMAND_OUT         | SETPOINT_OVERRIDE
['Woonkamer': 15 deg C] Command NOT acknowledged. Resending attempt 3
of 5...
2020-08-26 20:26:53 |1/ - | COMMAND_OUT         | SETPOINT_OVERRIDE
['Woonkamer': 15 deg C] Command SENT
2020-08-26 20:26:53 |1/000| SETPOINT_OVERRIDE   | W | GWAY EvoGateway  
-> 01:139901              | 15.00°C @ Woonkamer               [Zone 1 
]
2020-08-26 20:27:23 |     | COMMAND_OUT         | SETPOINT_OVERRIDE
['Woonkamer': 15 deg C] Command NOT acknowledged. Resending attempt 4
of 5...
2020-08-26 20:27:23 |1/ - | COMMAND_OUT         | SETPOINT_OVERRIDE
['Woonkamer': 15 deg C] Command SENT
2020-08-26 20:27:23 |1/000| SETPOINT_OVERRIDE   | W | GWAY EvoGateway  
-> 01:139901              | 15.00°C @ Woonkamer               [Zone 1 
]
2020-08-26 20:27:53 |     | COMMAND_OUT         | SETPOINT_OVERRIDE
['Woonkamer': 15 deg C] Command NOT acknowledged. Resending attempt 5
of 5...
2020-08-26 20:27:53 |1/ - | COMMAND_OUT         | SETPOINT_OVERRIDE
['Woonkamer': 15 deg C] Command SENT
2020-08-26 20:27:53 |1/000| SETPOINT_OVERRIDE   | W | GWAY EvoGateway  
-> 01:139901              | 15.00°C @ Woonkamer               [Zone 1 
]
2020-08-26 20:27:53 |     | COMMAND             | ERROR: Previously
sent command 'setpoint_override' failed to send. No ack received from
controller

Then I tried a ping to the controller, and this was the result:

2020-08-26 20:30:01 |1/ - | COMMAND_OUT         | PING : Command SENT
2020-08-26 20:30:01 |1/000| DATE_REQUEST        | RQ| GWAY EvoGateway  
    -> 01:139901              | Ping/Datetime Sync
2020-08-26 20:30:31 |     | COMMAND_OUT         | PING : Command NOT
acknowledged. Resending attempt 1 of 5...
2020-08-26 20:30:31 |1/ - | COMMAND_OUT         | PING : Command SENT
2020-08-26 20:30:42 |1/000| DATE_REQUEST        | RQ| GWAY EvoGateway  
    -> 01:139901              | Ping/Datetime Sync
2020-08-26 20:31:01 |     | COMMAND_OUT         | PING : Command NOT
acknowledged. Resending attempt 2 of 5...
2020-08-26 20:31:01 |1/ - | COMMAND_OUT         | PING : Command SENT
2020-08-26 20:31:01 |1/000| DATE_REQUEST        | RQ| GWAY EvoGateway  
    -> 01:139901              | Ping/Datetime Sync
2020-08-26 20:31:31 |     | COMMAND_OUT         | PING : Command NOT
acknowledged. Resending attempt 3 of 5...
2020-08-26 20:31:31 |1/ - | COMMAND_OUT         | PING : Command SENT
2020-08-26 20:31:31 |1/000| DATE_REQUEST        | RQ| GWAY EvoGateway  
    -> 01:139901              | Ping/Datetime Sync
2020-08-26 20:32:01 |     | COMMAND_OUT         | PING : Command NOT
acknowledged. Resending attempt 4 of 5...
2020-08-26 20:32:01 |1/ - | COMMAND_OUT         | PING : Command SENT
2020-08-26 20:32:01 |1/000| DATE_REQUEST        | RQ| GWAY EvoGateway  
    -> 01:139901              | Ping/Datetime Sync
2020-08-26 20:32:31 |     | COMMAND_OUT         | PING : Command NOT
acknowledged. Resending attempt 5 of 5...
2020-08-26 20:32:31 |1/ - | COMMAND_OUT         | PING : Command SENT
2020-08-26 20:32:31 |1/000| DATE_REQUEST        | RQ| GWAY EvoGateway  
    -> 01:139901              | Ping/Datetime Sync
2020-08-26 20:32:32 |     | COMMAND             | ERROR: Previously
sent command 'ping' failed to send. No ack received from controller

Thes logs are from the evo-listener script I use to read (and write)_ to the evo environment. The raw log for the two commands was:

2020-08-26 20:25:23 |-| MQTT_SUB           {u'command':
u'setpoint_override', u'arguments': {u'setpoint': 15, u'zone_id': 1}}
2020-08-26 20:25:23 |1| COMMAND_OUT        SETPOINT_OVERRIDE: Sending
'W --- 30:071715 01:139901 --:------ 2349 007 0005DC02FFFFFF'
2020-08-26 20:25:53 |1| COMMAND_OUT        SETPOINT_OVERRIDE: Sending
'W --- 30:071715 01:139901 --:------ 2349 007 0005DC02FFFFFF'
2020-08-26 20:25:53 |1| RELAY_HEAT_DEMAND  --- 048  I --- 01:187875
--:------ 01:187875 0008 002 FC00
2020-08-26 20:25:53 |1| SETPOINT_OVERRIDE  --- 000  W --- 30:071715
01:139901 --:------ 2349 007 0005DC02FFFFFF
2020-08-26 20:26:03 |1| ZONE_HEAT_DEMAND   --- 072  I --- 04:024003
--:------ 01:187875 3150 002 0800
2020-08-26 20:26:15 |1| OPENTHERM_TICKER   --- 061  I --- 10:006288
--:------ 10:006288 1FD4 003 0069E1
2020-08-26 20:26:23 |1| COMMAND_OUT        SETPOINT_OVERRIDE: Sending
'W --- 30:071715 01:139901 --:------ 2349 007 0005DC02FFFFFF'
2020-08-26 20:26:23 |1| SETPOINT_OVERRIDE  --- 000  W --- 30:071715
01:139901 --:------ 2349 007 0005DC02FFFFFF
2020-08-26 20:26:44 |1| ZONE_TEMPERATURE   --- 057  I --- 04:170491
--:------ 04:170491 30C9 003 00081E
2020-08-26 20:26:53 |1| COMMAND_OUT        SETPOINT_OVERRIDE: Sending
'W --- 30:071715 01:139901 --:------ 2349 007 0005DC02FFFFFF'
2020-08-26 20:26:53 |1| SETPOINT_OVERRIDE  --- 000  W --- 30:071715
01:139901 --:------ 2349 007 0005DC02FFFFFF
2020-08-26 20:27:13 |1| ZONE_HEAT_DEMAND   --- 057  I --- 04:170491
--:------ 01:187875 3150 002 0500
2020-08-26 20:27:23 |1| COMMAND_OUT        SETPOINT_OVERRIDE: Sending
'W --- 30:071715 01:139901 --:------ 2349 007 0005DC02FFFFFF'
2020-08-26 20:27:23 |1| SETPOINT_OVERRIDE  --- 000  W --- 30:071715
01:139901 --:------ 2349 007 0005DC02FFFFFF
2020-08-26 20:27:53 |1| COMMAND_OUT        SETPOINT_OVERRIDE: Sending
'W --- 30:071715 01:139901 --:------ 2349 007 0005DC02FFFFFF'
2020-08-26 20:27:53 |1| SETPOINT_OVERRIDE  --- 000  W --- 30:071715
01:139901 --:------ 2349 007 0005DC02FFFFFF
2020-08-26 20:27:59 |1| SYNC               --- 048  I --- 01:187875
--:------ 01:187875 1F09 003 FF0744
2020-08-26 20:27:59 |1| SETPOINT_CTL       --- 048  I --- 01:187875
--:------ 01:187875 2309 030
0001F40101F40201F40301F40401F40501F40601F40701F40801F40901F4
2020-08-26 20:27:59 |1| ZONE_TEMPERATURE   --- 048  I --- 01:187875
--:------ 01:187875 30C9 030
007FFF017FFF027FFF037FFF047FFF05081E067FFF077FFF087FFF097FFF
2020-08-26 20:28:42 |1| WINDOW_STATUS      --- 055  I --- 04:042911
--:------ 01:187875 12B0 003 000000
2020-08-26 20:28:43 |1| OPENTHERM_TICKER   --- 061  I --- 10:006288
--:------ 10:006288 1FD4 003 0069E2
2020-08-26 20:28:43 |1| WINDOW_STATUS      --- 055  I --- 04:042911
--:------ 01:187875 12B0 003 000000
2020-08-26 20:29:06 |1| ZONE_HEAT_DEMAND   --- 044  I --- 04:170497
--:------ 01:187875 3150 002 0300
2020-08-26 20:30:01 |-| MQTT_SUB           {u'command': u'ping'}
2020-08-26 20:30:01 |1| COMMAND_OUT        PING: Sending 'RQ ---
30:071715 01:139901 --:------ 313F 001 00'
2020-08-26 20:30:01 |1| DATE_REQUEST       --- 000 RQ --- 30:071715
01:139901 --:------ 313F 001 00
2020-08-26 20:30:31 |1| COMMAND_OUT        PING: Sending 'RQ ---
30:071715 01:139901 --:------ 313F 001 00'
2020-08-26 20:30:42 |1| ACTUATOR_STATE     --- 061  I --- 10:006288
--:------ 10:006288 3EF0 009 0000100000FF020A00
2020-08-26 20:30:42 |1| DATE_REQUEST       --- 000 RQ --- 30:071715
01:139901 --:------ 313F 001 00
2020-08-26 20:31:01 |1| COMMAND_OUT        PING: Sending 'RQ ---
30:071715 01:139901 --:------ 313F 001 00'
2020-08-26 20:31:01 |1| DATE_REQUEST       --- 000 RQ --- 30:071715
01:139901 --:------ 313F 001 00
2020-08-26 20:31:05 |1| SYNC               --- 048  I --- 01:187875
--:------ 01:187875 1F09 003 FF0744
2020-08-26 20:31:05 |1| SETPOINT_CTL       --- 048  I --- 01:187875
--:------ 01:187875 2309 030
0001F40101F40201F40301F40401F40501F40601F40701F40801F40901F4
2020-08-26 20:31:05 |1| ZONE_TEMPERATURE   --- 048  I --- 01:187875
--:------ 01:187875 30C9 030
007FFF017FFF027FFF037FFF047FFF05081E067FFF077FFF087FFF097FFF
2020-08-26 20:31:10 |1| OPENTHERM_TICKER   --- 062  I --- 10:006288
--:------ 10:006288 1FD4 003 0069E3
2020-08-26 20:31:31 |1| COMMAND_OUT        PING: Sending 'RQ ---
30:071715 01:139901 --:------ 313F 001 00'
2020-08-26 20:31:31 |1| DATE_REQUEST       --- 000 RQ --- 30:071715
01:139901 --:------ 313F 001 00
2020-08-26 20:32:01 |1| COMMAND_OUT        PING: Sending 'RQ ---
30:071715 01:139901 --:------ 313F 001 00'
2020-08-26 20:32:01 |1| DATE_REQUEST       --- 000 RQ --- 30:071715
01:139901 --:------ 313F 001 00
2020-08-26 20:32:15 |1| ZONE_TEMPERATURE   --- 082  I --- 04:042913
--:------ 04:042913 30C9 003 0007ED
2020-08-26 20:32:29 |1| ZONE_TEMPERATURE   --- 070  I --- 04:024005
--:------ 04:024005 30C9 003 0007C9
2020-08-26 20:32:31 |1| COMMAND_OUT        PING: Sending 'RQ ---
30:071715 01:139901 --:------ 313F 001 00'
2020-08-26 20:32:31 |1| DATE_REQUEST       --- 000 RQ --- 30:071715
01:139901 --:------ 313F 001 00
2020-08-26 20:32:48 |1| ZONE_TEMPERATURE   --- 058  I --- 04:170491
--:------ 04:170491 30C9 003 00081B
2020-08-26 20:33:02 |1| WINDOW_STATUS      --- 081  I --- 04:042915
--:------ 01:187875 12B0 003 020000
2020-08-26 20:33:04 |1| WINDOW_STATUS      --- 082  I --- 04:042915
--:------ 01:187875 12B0 003 020000
2020-08-26 20:33:38 |1| OPENTHERM_TICKER   --- 061  I --- 10:006288
--:------ 10:006288 1FD4 003 0069E4
2020-08-26 20:33:44 |1| ZONE_TEMPERATURE   --- 077  I --- 04:024001
--:------ 04:024001 30C9 003 00079A
2020-08-26 20:33:56 |1| ACTUATOR_CHECK_REQ --- 048  I --- 01:187875
--:------ 01:187875 3B00 002 FCC8
2020-08-26 20:34:11 |1| SYNC               --- 048  I --- 01:187875
--:------ 01:187875 1F09 003 FF0744
2020-08-26 20:34:11 |1| SETPOINT_CTL       --- 048  I --- 01:187875
--:------ 01:187875 2309 030
0001F40101F40201F40301F40401F40501F40601F40701F40801F40901F4
2020-08-26 20:34:11 |1| ZONE_TEMPERATURE   --- 048  I --- 01:187875
--:------ 01:187875 30C9 030
007FFF017FFF027FFF037FFF047FFF05081B0607C907079A087FFF097FFF

There is some other communication in that log, but they are not relevant to this issue. Hope this helps you perfecting the code. If you want me to test something more specific, just let me know.

Regards, Ed.

-- You are receiving this because you commented. Reply to this email directly or view it on GitHub: https://github.com/ghoti57/evofw3/issues/2#issuecomment-681074708

ghoti57 commented 4 years ago

From this line (an RX message)

2020-08-26 20:25:53 |1| RELAY_HEAT_DEMAND --- 048 I --- 01:187875 --:------ 01:187875 0008 002 FC00

Your controller appears to be 01:187875

The standard address for the gateway (CUL) device in the existing FW is 18:318170

This is a message sent from the gateway device

2020-08-26 20:26:23 |1| SETPOINT_OVERRIDE --- 000 W --- 30:071715 01:139901 --:------ 2349 007 0005DC02FFFFFF

It seems to be trying to send to 01:139901 which isn’t the correct controller address (so nothing will respond)

I do not know what the address 30:071715 represents.

The messages you are sending do not appear to have the correct addresses.

Pete

From: dystechnic [mailto:notifications@github.com] Sent: 26 August 2020 20:20 To: ghoti57/evofw3 evofw3@noreply.github.com Cc: ghoti57 peteraprice@btinternet.com; Comment comment@noreply.github.com Subject: Re: [ghoti57/evofw3] Sending commands (#2)

Hi Pete,

I did some testing with the UART branche tonight. But without success for now. First I tried to change a setpoint of one of my TRV's. to 15 degrees This was the result:

2020-08-26 20:25:23 |1/ - | COMMAND_OUT | SETPOINT_OVERRIDE ['Woonkamer': 15 deg C] Command SENT

2020-08-26 20:25:53 | | COMMAND_OUT | SETPOINT_OVERRIDE ['Woonkamer': 15 deg C] Command NOT acknowledged. Resending attempt 1 of 5...

2020-08-26 20:25:53 |1/ - | COMMAND_OUT | SETPOINT_OVERRIDE ['Woonkamer': 15 deg C] Command SENT

2020-08-26 20:25:53 |1/000| SETPOINT_OVERRIDE | W | GWAY EvoGateway -> 01:139901 | 15.00°C @ Woonkamer [Zone 1 ]

2020-08-26 20:26:23 | | COMMAND_OUT | SETPOINT_OVERRIDE ['Woonkamer': 15 deg C] Command NOT acknowledged. Resending attempt 2 of 5...

2020-08-26 20:26:23 |1/ - | COMMAND_OUT | SETPOINT_OVERRIDE ['Woonkamer': 15 deg C] Command SENT

2020-08-26 20:26:23 |1/000| SETPOINT_OVERRIDE | W | GWAY EvoGateway -> 01:139901 | 15.00°C @ Woonkamer [Zone 1 ]

2020-08-26 20:26:53 | | COMMAND_OUT | SETPOINT_OVERRIDE ['Woonkamer': 15 deg C] Command NOT acknowledged. Resending attempt 3 of 5...

2020-08-26 20:26:53 |1/ - | COMMAND_OUT | SETPOINT_OVERRIDE ['Woonkamer': 15 deg C] Command SENT

2020-08-26 20:26:53 |1/000| SETPOINT_OVERRIDE | W | GWAY EvoGateway -> 01:139901 | 15.00°C @ Woonkamer [Zone 1 ]

2020-08-26 20:27:23 | | COMMAND_OUT | SETPOINT_OVERRIDE ['Woonkamer': 15 deg C] Command NOT acknowledged. Resending attempt 4 of 5...

2020-08-26 20:27:23 |1/ - | COMMAND_OUT | SETPOINT_OVERRIDE ['Woonkamer': 15 deg C] Command SENT

2020-08-26 20:27:23 |1/000| SETPOINT_OVERRIDE | W | GWAY EvoGateway -> 01:139901 | 15.00°C @ Woonkamer [Zone 1 ]

2020-08-26 20:27:53 | | COMMAND_OUT | SETPOINT_OVERRIDE ['Woonkamer': 15 deg C] Command NOT acknowledged. Resending attempt 5 of 5...

2020-08-26 20:27:53 |1/ - | COMMAND_OUT | SETPOINT_OVERRIDE ['Woonkamer': 15 deg C] Command SENT

2020-08-26 20:27:53 |1/000| SETPOINT_OVERRIDE | W | GWAY EvoGateway -> 01:139901 | 15.00°C @ Woonkamer [Zone 1 ]

2020-08-26 20:27:53 | | COMMAND | ERROR: Previously sent command 'setpoint_override' failed to send. No ack received from controller

Then I tried a ping to the controller, and this was the result:

2020-08-26 20:30:01 |1/ - | COMMAND_OUT | PING : Command SENT

2020-08-26 20:30:01 |1/000| DATE_REQUEST | RQ| GWAY EvoGateway -> 01:139901 | Ping/Datetime Sync

2020-08-26 20:30:31 | | COMMAND_OUT | PING : Command NOT acknowledged. Resending attempt 1 of 5...

2020-08-26 20:30:31 |1/ - | COMMAND_OUT | PING : Command SENT

2020-08-26 20:30:42 |1/000| DATE_REQUEST | RQ| GWAY EvoGateway -> 01:139901 | Ping/Datetime Sync

2020-08-26 20:31:01 | | COMMAND_OUT | PING : Command NOT acknowledged. Resending attempt 2 of 5...

2020-08-26 20:31:01 |1/ - | COMMAND_OUT | PING : Command SENT

2020-08-26 20:31:01 |1/000| DATE_REQUEST | RQ| GWAY EvoGateway -> 01:139901 | Ping/Datetime Sync

2020-08-26 20:31:31 | | COMMAND_OUT | PING : Command NOT acknowledged. Resending attempt 3 of 5...

2020-08-26 20:31:31 |1/ - | COMMAND_OUT | PING : Command SENT

2020-08-26 20:31:31 |1/000| DATE_REQUEST | RQ| GWAY EvoGateway -> 01:139901 | Ping/Datetime Sync

2020-08-26 20:32:01 | | COMMAND_OUT | PING : Command NOT acknowledged. Resending attempt 4 of 5...

2020-08-26 20:32:01 |1/ - | COMMAND_OUT | PING : Command SENT

2020-08-26 20:32:01 |1/000| DATE_REQUEST | RQ| GWAY EvoGateway -> 01:139901 | Ping/Datetime Sync

2020-08-26 20:32:31 | | COMMAND_OUT | PING : Command NOT acknowledged. Resending attempt 5 of 5...

2020-08-26 20:32:31 |1/ - | COMMAND_OUT | PING : Command SENT

2020-08-26 20:32:31 |1/000| DATE_REQUEST | RQ| GWAY EvoGateway -> 01:139901 | Ping/Datetime Sync

2020-08-26 20:32:32 | | COMMAND | ERROR: Previously sent command 'ping' failed to send. No ack received from controller

Thes logs are from the evo-listener script https://github.com/smar000/evohome-Listener I use to read (and write)_ to the evo environment. The raw log for the two commands was:

2020-08-26 20:25:23 |-| MQTT_SUB {u'command': u'setpoint_override', u'arguments': {u'setpoint': 15, u'zone_id': 1}}

2020-08-26 20:25:23 |1| COMMAND_OUT SETPOINT_OVERRIDE: Sending 'W --- 30:071715 01:139901 --:------ 2349 007 0005DC02FFFFFF'

2020-08-26 20:25:53 |1| COMMAND_OUT SETPOINT_OVERRIDE: Sending 'W --- 30:071715 01:139901 --:------ 2349 007 0005DC02FFFFFF'

2020-08-26 20:25:53 |1| RELAY_HEAT_DEMAND --- 048 I --- 01:187875 --:------ 01:187875 0008 002 FC00

2020-08-26 20:25:53 |1| SETPOINT_OVERRIDE --- 000 W --- 30:071715 01:139901 --:------ 2349 007 0005DC02FFFFFF

2020-08-26 20:26:03 |1| ZONE_HEAT_DEMAND --- 072 I --- 04:024003 --:------ 01:187875 3150 002 0800

2020-08-26 20:26:15 |1| OPENTHERM_TICKER --- 061 I --- 10:006288 --:------ 10:006288 1FD4 003 0069E1

2020-08-26 20:26:23 |1| COMMAND_OUT SETPOINT_OVERRIDE: Sending 'W --- 30:071715 01:139901 --:------ 2349 007 0005DC02FFFFFF'

2020-08-26 20:26:23 |1| SETPOINT_OVERRIDE --- 000 W --- 30:071715 01:139901 --:------ 2349 007 0005DC02FFFFFF

2020-08-26 20:26:44 |1| ZONE_TEMPERATURE --- 057 I --- 04:170491 --:------ 04:170491 30C9 003 00081E

2020-08-26 20:26:53 |1| COMMAND_OUT SETPOINT_OVERRIDE: Sending 'W --- 30:071715 01:139901 --:------ 2349 007 0005DC02FFFFFF'

2020-08-26 20:26:53 |1| SETPOINT_OVERRIDE --- 000 W --- 30:071715 01:139901 --:------ 2349 007 0005DC02FFFFFF

2020-08-26 20:27:13 |1| ZONE_HEAT_DEMAND --- 057 I --- 04:170491 --:------ 01:187875 3150 002 0500

2020-08-26 20:27:23 |1| COMMAND_OUT SETPOINT_OVERRIDE: Sending 'W --- 30:071715 01:139901 --:------ 2349 007 0005DC02FFFFFF'

2020-08-26 20:27:23 |1| SETPOINT_OVERRIDE --- 000 W --- 30:071715 01:139901 --:------ 2349 007 0005DC02FFFFFF

2020-08-26 20:27:53 |1| COMMAND_OUT SETPOINT_OVERRIDE: Sending 'W --- 30:071715 01:139901 --:------ 2349 007 0005DC02FFFFFF'

2020-08-26 20:27:53 |1| SETPOINT_OVERRIDE --- 000 W --- 30:071715 01:139901 --:------ 2349 007 0005DC02FFFFFF

2020-08-26 20:27:59 |1| SYNC --- 048 I --- 01:187875 --:------ 01:187875 1F09 003 FF0744

2020-08-26 20:27:59 |1| SETPOINT_CTL --- 048 I --- 01:187875 --:------ 01:187875 2309 030 0001F40101F40201F40301F40401F40501F40601F40701F40801F40901F4

2020-08-26 20:27:59 |1| ZONE_TEMPERATURE --- 048 I --- 01:187875 --:------ 01:187875 30C9 030 007FFF017FFF027FFF037FFF047FFF05081E067FFF077FFF087FFF097FFF

2020-08-26 20:28:42 |1| WINDOW_STATUS --- 055 I --- 04:042911 --:------ 01:187875 12B0 003 000000

2020-08-26 20:28:43 |1| OPENTHERM_TICKER --- 061 I --- 10:006288 --:------ 10:006288 1FD4 003 0069E2

2020-08-26 20:28:43 |1| WINDOW_STATUS --- 055 I --- 04:042911 --:------ 01:187875 12B0 003 000000

2020-08-26 20:29:06 |1| ZONE_HEAT_DEMAND --- 044 I --- 04:170497 --:------ 01:187875 3150 002 0300

2020-08-26 20:30:01 |-| MQTT_SUB {u'command': u'ping'}

2020-08-26 20:30:01 |1| COMMAND_OUT PING: Sending 'RQ --- 30:071715 01:139901 --:------ 313F 001 00'

2020-08-26 20:30:01 |1| DATE_REQUEST --- 000 RQ --- 30:071715 01:139901 --:------ 313F 001 00

2020-08-26 20:30:31 |1| COMMAND_OUT PING: Sending 'RQ --- 30:071715 01:139901 --:------ 313F 001 00'

2020-08-26 20:30:42 |1| ACTUATOR_STATE --- 061 I --- 10:006288 --:------ 10:006288 3EF0 009 0000100000FF020A00

2020-08-26 20:30:42 |1| DATE_REQUEST --- 000 RQ --- 30:071715 01:139901 --:------ 313F 001 00

2020-08-26 20:31:01 |1| COMMAND_OUT PING: Sending 'RQ --- 30:071715 01:139901 --:------ 313F 001 00'

2020-08-26 20:31:01 |1| DATE_REQUEST --- 000 RQ --- 30:071715 01:139901 --:------ 313F 001 00

2020-08-26 20:31:05 |1| SYNC --- 048 I --- 01:187875 --:------ 01:187875 1F09 003 FF0744

2020-08-26 20:31:05 |1| SETPOINT_CTL --- 048 I --- 01:187875 --:------ 01:187875 2309 030 0001F40101F40201F40301F40401F40501F40601F40701F40801F40901F4

2020-08-26 20:31:05 |1| ZONE_TEMPERATURE --- 048 I --- 01:187875 --:------ 01:187875 30C9 030 007FFF017FFF027FFF037FFF047FFF05081E067FFF077FFF087FFF097FFF

2020-08-26 20:31:10 |1| OPENTHERM_TICKER --- 062 I --- 10:006288 --:------ 10:006288 1FD4 003 0069E3

2020-08-26 20:31:31 |1| COMMAND_OUT PING: Sending 'RQ --- 30:071715 01:139901 --:------ 313F 001 00'

2020-08-26 20:31:31 |1| DATE_REQUEST --- 000 RQ --- 30:071715 01:139901 --:------ 313F 001 00

2020-08-26 20:32:01 |1| COMMAND_OUT PING: Sending 'RQ --- 30:071715 01:139901 --:------ 313F 001 00'

2020-08-26 20:32:01 |1| DATE_REQUEST --- 000 RQ --- 30:071715 01:139901 --:------ 313F 001 00

2020-08-26 20:32:15 |1| ZONE_TEMPERATURE --- 082 I --- 04:042913 --:------ 04:042913 30C9 003 0007ED

2020-08-26 20:32:29 |1| ZONE_TEMPERATURE --- 070 I --- 04:024005 --:------ 04:024005 30C9 003 0007C9

2020-08-26 20:32:31 |1| COMMAND_OUT PING: Sending 'RQ --- 30:071715 01:139901 --:------ 313F 001 00'

2020-08-26 20:32:31 |1| DATE_REQUEST --- 000 RQ --- 30:071715 01:139901 --:------ 313F 001 00

2020-08-26 20:32:48 |1| ZONE_TEMPERATURE --- 058 I --- 04:170491 --:------ 04:170491 30C9 003 00081B

2020-08-26 20:33:02 |1| WINDOW_STATUS --- 081 I --- 04:042915 --:------ 01:187875 12B0 003 020000

2020-08-26 20:33:04 |1| WINDOW_STATUS --- 082 I --- 04:042915 --:------ 01:187875 12B0 003 020000

2020-08-26 20:33:38 |1| OPENTHERM_TICKER --- 061 I --- 10:006288 --:------ 10:006288 1FD4 003 0069E4

2020-08-26 20:33:44 |1| ZONE_TEMPERATURE --- 077 I --- 04:024001 --:------ 04:024001 30C9 003 00079A

2020-08-26 20:33:56 |1| ACTUATOR_CHECK_REQ --- 048 I --- 01:187875 --:------ 01:187875 3B00 002 FCC8

2020-08-26 20:34:11 |1| SYNC --- 048 I --- 01:187875 --:------ 01:187875 1F09 003 FF0744

2020-08-26 20:34:11 |1| SETPOINT_CTL --- 048 I --- 01:187875 --:------ 01:187875 2309 030 0001F40101F40201F40301F40401F40501F40601F40701F40801F40901F4

2020-08-26 20:34:11 |1| ZONE_TEMPERATURE --- 048 I --- 01:187875 --:------ 01:187875 30C9 030 007FFF017FFF027FFF037FFF047FFF05081B0607C907079A087FFF097FFF

There is some other communication in that log, but they are not relevant to this issue. Hope this helps you perfecting the code. If you want me to test something more specific, just let me know.

Regards, Ed.

— You are receiving this because you commented. Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub https://github.com/ghoti57/evofw3/issues/2#issuecomment-681074708 , or unsubscribe https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/AIRU2W2ZY7EQ6ZBSXJO2YS3SCVN7DANCNFSM4QKZYZYQ . https://github.com/notifications/beacon/AIRU2W7LIGHJR3V3Q66T7ETSCVN7DA5CNFSM4QKZYZY2YY3PNVWWK3TUL52HS4DFVREXG43VMVBW63LNMVXHJKTDN5WW2ZLOORPWSZGOFCMGAFA.gif

ghoti57 commented 4 years ago

Sorry the gateway address is 18:056026

dystechnic commented 4 years ago

Hi Pete,

I did some more testing, maybe that helps. First , my setup is as follows: I have a NanoCul wich I've configured to have the address 18:056026 as you mentioned before. Then there is the evohome controller (the touchscreen thermostate) wich has address 01:187875. When I send a ping command to the controller this is what happens on the serial port

␑# uart\evofw3 0.4.1
000 RQ --- 18:056026 01:187875 --:------ 313F 001 00
066  I --- 01:187875 --:------ 01:187875 0008 002 FC00
080  I --- 10:006288 --:------ 01:187875 3150 002 FC00
000 RQ --- 18:056026 01:187875 --:------ 313F 001 00
083  I --- 10:006288 --:------ 10:006288 1FD4 003 006D91
065  I --- 01:187875 --:------ 01:187875 3B00 002 FCC8
000 RQ --- 18:056026 01:187875 --:------ 313F 001 00
000 RQ --- 18:056026 01:187875 ----- 313F 001 00
000 RQ --- 18:056026 01:187875 --:------ 313F 001 00
065  I --- 01:187875 --:------ 01:187875 1F09 003 FF0744
066  I --- 01:187875 --:------ 01:187875 2309 030 0001F40101F40201F40301F40401F40501F40601F40701F40801F40901F4
065  I --- 01:187875 --:------ 01:187875 30C9 030 0007CD0107820207810307FC04079105082F06079E07079E080802090820
000 RQ --- 18:056026 01:187875 --:------ 313F 001 00

To me it seems that the CUL (18:056026) is now sending to the controller (01:187875). That should be the correct communication. But there is no communication back from the controller to the CUL device, am I understanding this correctly?

I've also asked the author of the evo-listener script to have a look at the problem but have had no reply yet.

dystechnic commented 4 years ago

HI,

It's working now. Sending is working with the uart branche. On my side it was a configuration issue and as soon as I had that resolved it started working. Thank you for your support, and if you need someone to do some testing for you then just let me know.

Regards, Ed.

ghoti57 commented 4 years ago

Glad it's working.

Just let me know if you see anything that definitely looks like it's my problem.

Peter

On 30 Aug 2020, 13:18, at 13:18, dystechnic notifications@github.com wrote:

HI,

It's working now. Sending is working with the uart branche. On my side it was a configuration issue and as soon as I had that resolved it started working. Thank you for your support, and if you need someone to do some testing for you then just let me know.

Regards, Ed.

-- You are receiving this because you commented. Reply to this email directly or view it on GitHub: https://github.com/ghoti57/evofw3/issues/2#issuecomment-683413662