search

ghoti57 / evofw3

Major overhaul of evofw2 Evohome listening software to use asynchronous radio mode
60 stars 10 forks source link

nanoCUL not transmitting #31

Closed trailro closed 7 months ago

trailro commented 1 year ago

Hi all,

I seem to have an issue with evofw3 and my "german" nanoCUL. I flashed initially the latest version of evofw3 but it does not seem to work - the device "is" transmitting (i think) but no one ever responds back.

If I flash the calibrate branch, I can now talk to most devices - they all respond and quickly. Unfortunately, it's only the controller that does not want to respond back but only randomly to some commands. It doesn't even work for ping. But it all works fine for OTH and other devices.

Any suggestions as to what I can try next?

Thanks.

trailro commented 1 year ago

nanoCUL atmega328p - seems to be somewhat a similar issue with https://github.com/ghoti57/evofw3/issues/6

ghoti57 commented 1 year ago

First of all forget the calibrate branch.  Anything in there is in the latest version.

How are you programming the nanoCUL?

Are you using my custom device definitions? What options are you using?

⁣Get BlueMail for Android ​

On 16 Oct 2022, 14:32, at 14:32, trailro @.***> wrote:

Hi all,

I seem to have an issue with evofw3 and my "german" nanoCUL. I flashed initially the latest version of evofw3 but it does not seem to work - the device "is" transmitting (i think) but no one ever responds back.

If I flash the calibrate branch, I can now talk to most devices - they all respond and quickly. Unfortunately, it's only the controller that does not want to respond back but only randomly to some commands. It doesn't even work for ping. But it all works fine for OTH and other devices.

Any suggestions as to what I can try next?

Thanks.

-- Reply to this email directly or view it on GitHub: https://github.com/ghoti57/evofw3/issues/31 You are receiving this because you are subscribed to this thread.

Message ID: @.***>

trailro commented 1 year ago

Hi. Yes, I am using your custom definition for sw uart when uploading the sketch. For some reason, only using that branch I can send packets and receive responses. Using the master branch only allows me to send but no response whatsoever even after doing multiple freq calibrations.

Pins are set to nano. And baud to 112k. Standard bootloader.

ghoti57 commented 1 year ago

What do you see as serial output when you run the calibration? In particular the last 20-30 lines.

From: trailro @. Sent: 16 October 2022 20:04 To: ghoti57/evofw3 @.> Cc: Peter Price @.>; Comment @.> Subject: Re: [ghoti57/evofw3] nanoCUL not transmitting (Issue #31)

Hi. Yes, I am using your custom definition for sw uart when uploading the sketch. For some reason, only using that branch I can send packets and receive responses. Using the master branch only allows me to send but no response whatsoever even after doing multiple freq calibrations.

Pins are set to nano. And baud to 112k. Standard bootloader.

— Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub https://github.com/ghoti57/evofw3/issues/31#issuecomment-1280032327 , or unsubscribe https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/AIRU2W4C4EUEEY6AHWHMPCTWDRGR5ANCNFSM6AAAAAARGKV3SY . You are receiving this because you commented. https://github.com/notifications/beacon/AIRU2W6AS4GILKHSUMLYL33WDRGR5A5CNFSM6AAAAAARGKV3S2WGG33NNVSW45C7OR4XAZNMJFZXG5LFINXW23LFNZ2KUY3PNVWWK3TUL5UWJTSMJO7EO.gif Message ID: @. @.> >

trailro commented 1 year ago

I will have to re-do the calibration. Do you want me to post the results with the master version or the current calibrate branch I have installed? Or both?

ghoti57 commented 1 year ago

Just forget the calibration branch exists

From: trailro @. Sent: 17 October 2022 07:26 To: ghoti57/evofw3 @.> Cc: Peter Price @.>; Comment @.> Subject: Re: [ghoti57/evofw3] nanoCUL not transmitting (Issue #31)

I will have to re-do the calibration. Do you want me to post the results with the master version or the current calibrate branch I have installed? Or both?

— Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub https://github.com/ghoti57/evofw3/issues/31#issuecomment-1280351410 , or unsubscribe https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/AIRU2WZWJU253UXOHVRAJ6LWDTWPDANCNFSM6AAAAAARGKV3SY . You are receiving this because you commented. https://github.com/notifications/beacon/AIRU2W6W6G32UIZKHRTBADTWDTWPDA5CNFSM6AAAAAARGKV3S2WGG33NNVSW45C7OR4XAZNMJFZXG5LFINXW23LFNZ2KUY3PNVWWK3TUL5UWJTSMKCOLE.gif Message ID: @. @.> >

trailro commented 1 year ago

Please see below full calibration using master branch:

14:19:00.857 -> ⸮# evofw3 0.7.1 14:19:05.687 -> 000 RQ --- 18:141092 10:256364 --:------ 0016 002 0017 14:19:10.103 -> 079 I --- 02:029004 --:------ 02:029004 22C9 024 0008660A28010108660A28010208660A28010307080A2801 14:19:11.348 -> 000 RQ --- 18:141092 01:256364 --:------ 0016 002 0017 14:19:12.908 -> 070 I --- 01:256364 --:------ 01:256364 2309 030 0008660108340207080308340408340601F40701F40801F40907080A0708 14:19:12.908 -> 072 I --- 01:256364 --:------ 01:256364 30C9 024 0008390207F003083106070707065708071E0907DD0A07D9 14:19:14.323 -> 083 RP --- 10:056759 01:256364 --:------ 3EF0 009 000010020000032600 14:19:14.645 -> 000 RQ --- 18:141092 01:256364 --:------ 0016 002 0017 14:19:19.595 -> 000 RQ --- 18:141092 01:256364 --:------ 0016 002 0017 14:19:22.769 -> # !F F=2165b4 14:19:35.389 -> # !F Tune 14:19:35.418 -> # !c 0d 21 65 b4 14:19:35.418 -> # !c 0d 21 65 a4 14:19:36.572 -> 068 I --- 22:163985 --:------ 22:163985 0008 002 00C4 14:19:36.572 -> # !c 0d 21 65 94 14:19:37.576 -> 068 I --- 22:163985 --:------ 22:163985 0008 002 00C4 14:19:37.576 -> # !c 0d 21 65 84 14:20:14.495 -> 071 RQ --- 01:256364 10:056759 --:------ 3EF0 ??? Invalid Manchester Code 14:20:14.495 -> # AA.5A.AA.95.56.69.96.5A.A6.6A.59.59.65.95.A5.56.55.AA.2A. 14:20:27.948 -> 075 I --- 04:092958 --:------ 01:256364 3150 002 0436 Invalid Manchester Code 14:20:27.948 -> # A9.6A.A9.A9.96.65.A9.56.AA.95.56.69.96.5A.A5.A9.99.AA.AA.A6.AA.9A.A5.96.25. 14:20:33.053 -> 095 I --- --:------ --:------ --:------ ???? ??? Invalid Manchester Code 14:20:33.089 -> # A9.6A.A9.A5.96.29. 14:21:08.364 -> 092 I --- 10:056759 --:------ 10:056759 3EF0 009 0032100A0000032600 14:21:08.364 -> # !c 0d 21 65 74 14:21:14.385 -> 060 I --- 01:256364 --:------ 01:256364 1F09 003 FF04BF 14:21:14.385 -> # !c 0d 21 65 64 14:21:14.418 -> 061 I --- 01:256364 --:------ 01:256364 000A 012 091001F40DAC0A1001F40DAC 14:21:14.418 -> # !c 0d 21 65 54 14:21:14.722 -> 060 RQ --- 01:256364 10:056759 --:------ 3EF0 001 00 14:21:14.722 -> # !c 0d 21 65 44 14:21:14.722 -> 092 RP --- 10:056759 01:256364 --:------ 3EF0 009 002B100A0000032600 14:21:14.758 -> # !c 0d 21 65 34 14:21:47.811 -> 094 I --- 22:163986 --:------ 22:163986 0008 002 0000 14:21:47.811 -> # !c 0d 21 65 24 14:21:51.801 -> 092 I --- 22:163986 --:------ 22:163986 0008 002 0000 14:21:51.833 -> # !c 0d 21 65 14 14:21:58.678 -> 091 I --- 10:056759 --:------ 10:056759 3EF0 009 000B10020000032600 14:21:58.678 -> # !c 0d 21 65 04 14:22:01.009 -> 078 I --- 02:029004 --:------ 01:256364 3150 002 0080 14:22:01.009 -> # !c 0d 21 64 f4 14:22:01.155 -> 080 I --- 02:029004 --:------ 01:256364 3150 002 0080 14:22:01.155 -> # !c 0d 21 64 e4 14:22:01.299 -> 078 I --- 02:029004 --:------ 01:256364 3150 002 0080 14:22:01.299 -> # !c 0d 21 64 d4 14:22:01.476 -> 078 I --- 02:029004 --:------ 01:256364 3150 002 0900 14:22:01.476 -> # !c 0d 21 64 c4 14:22:14.904 -> 061 RQ --- 01:256364 10:056759 --:------ 3EF0 001 00 14:22:14.941 -> # !c 0d 21 64 b4 14:22:14.941 -> 094 RP --- 10:056759 --:------ --:------ ???? ??? Invalid Manchester Code 14:22:14.941 -> # A5.5A.A6.6A.59.59.65.95.AA.95.57. 14:22:48.008 -> 080 I --- 02:029004 --:------ --:------ ???? ??? Invalid Manchester Code 14:22:48.008 -> # A9.6A.AA.6A.95.A9.9A.5A.AA.EA. 14:22:48.150 -> 079 I --- --:------ --:------ --:------ ???? ??? Invalid Manchester Code 14:22:48.150 -> # A9.6A.AA.6F. 14:23:15.859 -> 061 I --- 01:256364 --:------ 01:256364 1F09 003 FF04BF 14:23:15.895 -> # !c 0d 21 64 a4 14:23:15.954 -> 062 RQ --- 01:256364 --:------ --:------ ???? ??? Invalid Manchester Code 14:23:15.954 -> # AA.5A.AA.95.56.69.96.5A.A6.EA. 14:25:16.359 -> 060 RQ --- --:------ --:------ --:------ ???? ??? Invalid Manchester Code 14:25:16.359 -> # AA.5A.AA.D5. 14:27:15.571 -> # !c 0d 21 64 ac 14:31:15.256 -> # !c 0d 21 64 b0 14:35:14.905 -> # !c 0d 21 64 b2 14:36:02.549 -> 079 I --- 02:029004 --:------ 01:256364 3150 002 007E 14:36:02.549 -> # !c 0d 21 64 b1 14:36:02.686 -> 076 I --- 02:029004 --:------ --:------ ???? ??? Invalid Manchester Code 14:36:02.686 -> # A9.6A.AA.6A.95.A9.9A.5A.AA.9F. 14:40:02.236 -> # !c 0d 21 65 b4 14:40:02.236 -> # !c 0d 21 65 c4 14:40:29.513 -> 076 I --- 04:092958 --:------ 01:256364 3150 002 0436 14:40:29.513 -> # !c 0d 21 65 d4 14:40:30.786 -> 067 I --- 22:163985 --:------ 22:163985 30C9 003 00084F 14:40:30.786 -> # !c 0d 21 65 e4 14:40:33.796 -> 064 I --- 22:163985 --:------ 22:163985 30C9 003 00084F 14:40:33.796 -> # !c 0d 21 65 f4 14:40:34.602 -> 095 I --- 04:221671 --:------ 01:256364 3150 002 0700 14:40:34.602 -> # !c 0d 21 66 04 14:41:00.377 -> 092 I --- 10:056759 --:------ 10:056759 1FD4 003 0015AD 14:41:00.377 -> # !c 0d 21 66 14 14:41:05.581 -> 092 I --- 10:056759 --:------ 10:056759 3EF0 009 0033100A0000032600 14:41:05.614 -> # !c 0d 21 66 24 14:41:19.678 -> 060 RQ --- 01:256364 10:056759 --:------ 3EF0 001 00 14:41:19.678 -> # !c 0d 21 66 34 14:41:19.735 -> 092 RP --- 10:056759 01:256364 --:------ 3EF0 009 0028100A0000032600 14:41:19.735 -> # !c 0d 21 66 44 14:41:29.333 -> 061 I --- 01:256364 --:------ 01:256364 1F09 003 FF04BF 14:41:29.333 -> # !c 0d 21 66 54 14:41:29.396 -> 060 I --- 01:256364 --:------ 01:256364 30C9 024 00084F0207F003083106070707065708071E0907DD0A07D9 14:41:29.396 -> # !c 0d 21 66 64 14:41:45.822 -> 092 I --- 10:056759 --:------ 10:056759 3EF0 009 000310020000032600 14:41:45.854 -> # !c 0d 21 66 74 14:41:51.790 -> 093 I --- 22:163986 --:------ 22:163986 0008 002 0000 14:41:51.790 -> # !c 0d 21 66 84 14:42:02.493 -> 077 I --- 02:029004 --:------ 01:256364 3150 002 0074 14:42:02.493 -> # !c 0d 21 66 94 14:42:02.630 -> 078 I --- 02:029004 --:------ 01:256364 3150 002 0074 14:42:02.630 -> # !c 0d 21 66 a4 14:42:02.780 -> 078 I --- 02:029004 --:------ 01:256364 3150 002 0074 14:42:02.780 -> # !c 0d 21 66 b4 14:42:02.930 -> 077 RQ --- --:------ --:------ --:------ ???? ??? Invalid Manchester Code 14:42:02.930 -> # A9.62. 14:42:10.873 -> 077 I --- 02:029004 --:------ --:------ ???? ??? Invalid Manchester Code 14:42:10.873 -> # A9.6A.AA.6A.95.A9.9A.5A.AA.6A.95.A9.98. 14:42:11.014 -> 078 I --- --:------ --:------ --:------ ???? ??? Invalid Manchester Code 14:42:11.014 -> # A9.6A.AA.6A.95.89. 14:42:19.873 -> 061 RQ --- 01:256364 10:056759 --:------ 3EF0 001 Invalid Manchester Code 14:42:19.910 -> # AA.5A.AA.95.56.69.96.5A.A6.6A.59.59.65.95.A5.56.55.AA.AA.A9.A8. 14:42:19.910 -> 092 RP --- 10:056759 01:256364 --:------ 3EF0 009 000010020000032664 14:42:19.948 -> # !c 0d 21 66 c4 14:42:37.381 -> # !F F=2166c4 tuning 14:46:19.601 -> # !c 0d 21 66 bc 14:50:19.277 -> # !c 0d 21 66 b8 14:53:22.166 -> 060 RQ --- --:------ --:------ --:------ ???? ??? Invalid Manchester Code 14:53:22.199 -> # AA.1A. 14:53:22.199 -> 091 RP --- 10:056759 --:------ --:------ ???? ??? Invalid Manchester Code 14:53:22.199 -> # A5.5A.A6.6A.59.59.65.95.AA.95.46. 14:53:38.330 -> 061 I --- 01:256364 --:------ 01:256364 1F09 003 FF04BF 14:53:38.330 -> # !c 0d 21 66 ba 14:53:38.396 -> 061 I --- --:------ --:------ --:------ ???? ??? Invalid Manchester Code 14:53:38.396 -> # A9.6A.AA.95.56.61. 14:57:38.011 -> # !c 0d 21 66 b9 14:57:41.312 -> 062 I --- 01:256364 --:------ --:------ ???? ??? Invalid Manchester Code 14:57:41.312 -> # A9.6A.AA.95.56.69.96.5A.AA.95.56.61. 14:57:41.312 -> 061 I --- 01:256364 --:------ 01:256364 ???? ??? Invalid Manchester Code 14:57:41.369 -> # A9.6A.AA.95.56.69.96.5A.AA.95.56.69.96.5A.A6.A5.8A. 14:57:41.369 -> 061 I --- 01:256364 --:------ 01:256364 30C9 024 0008 Invalid Manchester Code 14:57:41.369 -> # A9.6A.AA.95.56.69.96.5A.AA.95.56.69.96.5A.A5.AA.5A.69.A9.6A.AA.AA.AA.6A.98. 14:57:58.697 -> # !F F=2166b9 tuning 14:58:23.238 -> 061 RQ --- --:------ --:------ --:------ ???? ??? Invalid Manchester Code 14:58:23.238 -> # AA.58. 15:01:37.689 -> # !c 0d 21 65 b5 15:02:24.068 -> 060 RQ --- 01:256364 10:056759 --:------ 3EF0 001 00 15:02:24.068 -> 091 RP --- 10:056759 01:256364 --:------ 3EF0 009 000010000000032600 15:02:33.368 -> 091 I --- 10:056759 --:------ 10:056759 3EF0 009 000010020000032600 15:02:40.249 -> # !F F=2165b5 15:02:44.840 -> # !F Saved F=2165b5

Now, having flashed this branch, I can no longer receive responses from any of the devices: 15:03:24.268 -> 077 RQ --- 01:256364 10:056759 --:------ 3EF0 001 00 15:03:24.314 -> 092 RP --- 10:056759 01:256364 --:------ 3EF0 009 000010020000032600 15:03:27.018 -> 092 I --- 04:092960 --:------ 04:092960 30C9 003 000839 15:03:45.820 -> 082 I --- 01:256364 --:------ 01:256364 1F09 003 FF04BF 15:03:45.878 -> 081 I --- 01:256364 --:------ 01:256364 000A 048 001001F40DAC010001F40DAC021001F40DAC031001F40DAC040001F40DAC061001F40DAC071001F40DAC081001F40DAC 15:03:45.878 -> 081 I --- 01:256364 --:------ 01:256364 000A 012 091001F40DAC0A1001F40DAC 15:03:53.475 -> 000 RQ --- 18:141092 01:256364 --:------ 0016 002 0017 15:04:03.117 -> 000 RQ --- 18:141092 01:256364 --:------ 0016 002 0017 15:04:05.759 -> 000 RQ --- 18:141092 01:256364 --:------ 0016 002 0017 15:04:12.220 -> 000 RQ --- 18:141092 01:256364 --:------ 1F09 001 00 15:04:18.765 -> 080 I --- 02:029004 --:------ 02:029004 22C9 024 0008660A28010108660A28010208660A28010301F40A2801 15:04:24.466 -> 075 RQ --- 01:256364 10:056759 --:------ 3EF0 001 00 15:04:24.523 -> 089 RP --- 10:056759 01:256364 --:------ 3EF0 009 000010020000032600 15:04:28.347 -> 000 RQ --- 18:141092 10:056759 --:------ 1F09 001 00

Previously: 2022-10-17T06:56:36.701422 000 RQ --- 18:141092 10:056759 --:------ 1290 001 00 2022-10-17T06:56:36.729984 077 RP --- 10:056759 18:141092 --:------ 1290 003 007FFF

trailro commented 1 year ago

As for flashing, this is what I used:

image
ghoti57 commented 1 year ago

The tuning has done nothing significant, the value it’s chosen is 003% from the ideal.

In case the nvram data is causing an issue reset it with the command

!ER

Power cycle and check the frequency value with

!F

It should be 21656A

Then try a TX operation again.

I think the guy who reported this issue

https://github.com/ghoti57/evofw3/issues/30

Bought the same stick and once he programmed it correctly had no problems.

He’s also using a MAC

You must have the correct programming options because otherwise you’d be getting no responses at all.

Peter

From: trailro @. Sent: 17 October 2022 13:13 To: ghoti57/evofw3 @.> Cc: Peter Price @.>; Comment @.> Subject: Re: [ghoti57/evofw3] nanoCUL not transmitting (Issue #31)

As for flashing, this is what I used:

https://user-images.githubusercontent.com/38461924/196174089-43fb73d7-1dad-4436-83be-6283e37dff25.png e tuning has achieved nt

— Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub https://github.com/ghoti57/evofw3/issues/31#issuecomment-1280761040 , or unsubscribe https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/AIRU2W265NZG7BKJF5FGRYTWDU7EHANCNFSM6AAAAAARGKV3SY . You are receiving this because you commented. https://github.com/notifications/beacon/AIRU2WZSCBNFFJGTKMMH4FDWDU7EHA5CNFSM6AAAAAARGKV3S2WGG33NNVSW45C7OR4XAZNMJFZXG5LFINXW23LFNZ2KUY3PNVWWK3TUL5UWJTSMK3ONA.gif Message ID: < @.> @.>

trailro commented 1 year ago

Hi Peter,

Just did that and unfortunately no luck in getting any responses :(

what's strange is that I was getting some using the calibrate branch. so i'm wondering what's changed since than that could cause this reaction.

18:25:26.571 -> # evofw3 0.7.1 18:25:32.261 -> # !F F=21656a 18:25:44.981 -> 000 RQ --- 18:141092 01:256364 --:------ 0016 001 00 18:25:50.066 -> 000 RQ --- 18:141092 01:256364 --:------ 0016 001 00 18:25:55.948 -> 000 RQ --- 18:141092 10:056759 --:------ 10E0 001 00 18:26:07.045 -> 066 RQ --- 01:256364 10:056759 --:------ 3EF0 001 00 18:26:15.754 -> 067 I --- 01:256364 --:------ 01:256364 1F09 003 FF04BF 18:26:15.776 -> 067 I --- 01:256364 --:------ 01:256364 2309 030 0008660108340201F40308340408340601F40701F40801F40908340A01F4 18:26:15.776 -> 067 I --- 01:256364 --:------ 01:256364 30C9 024 0008BD0207E90308410607370706CF0807270907C70A07C1 18:26:21.201 -> 000 RQ --- 18:141092 01:256364 --:------ 0016 001 00 18:26:25.760 -> 000 RQ --- 18:141092 01:256364 --:------ 0016 001 00

trailro commented 1 year ago

Oh, and yes, looks like it's the same devices purchased from amazon.de

djfanatix commented 1 year ago

Did you manage to fix this device? I have the same issues: not transmitting, device 'crashing' after a few minutes,..

I tried evofw2, calibrate and latest. I did autotune and !ER, but no major improvements. I think it is a hardware issue, so maybe I just return it and buy a proper one

trailro commented 1 year ago

Unfortunately, no. I have it running with the calibrate branch (which I shouldn't be using but at least I get some data out of it). Otherwise no luck whatsoever. I also think it might be a hardware issue - but it's strange that it somehow works when i use an older fw version. Hard to say. I already ordered another stick - hopefully the new one will work.

sciorty commented 1 year ago

@trailro i do have the same problem of a CC1101 + Arruino UNO apparently not transmitting. Dis you solve in any way?

noud-github commented 7 months ago

Looks like using the "calibrate" branch made my nanocul TX come alive to, unfortunately it looks like the nano version cul are the only once you can buy at the moment,

ghoti57 commented 7 months ago

I have stock of https://indalo-tech.onlineweb.shop/product/ssm-d2 but am unable to dispatch until the end of January.

I am hiding the stock level because I don't want people to order and then get frustrated when I don't post it out.

If you haven't done so already request an update on the page linked above and I'll notify you when you can place an order.

noud-github commented 7 months ago

@ghoti57 does that ship to the EU? (had some VAT issues before so asking it 😉

looks like 0.6.17 introduced the issue on my current stick on 0.6.16 I can send on 0.6.17 it is broken 😞
but not stable....

ghoti57 commented 7 months ago

It is available in the EU but you will have to pay VAT and a handling charge on import. See the delivery FAQ. I reduce the declared value by British VAT. So you don't pay tax on tax but am not VAT registered so it is difficult for me to stop duty paid.