search

gianni-rosato / aviator

A lightweight, Flatpak-first, easy-to-use GUI utility for encoding with SVT-AV1 & Opus.
GNU General Public License v3.0
172 stars 15 forks source link

Feature: Hardware transcoding #45

Closed TriVoxel closed 11 months ago

TriVoxel commented 11 months ago

Some GPU's such as my AMD Radeon 7900XTX should have AV1 hardware encoding support, as well as decoding for other formats. This could speed up transcodes considerably if you could get this working! Maybe as a preference? I think newer Intel CPUs and GPUs support AV1 in hardware, as well...

JND94 commented 11 months ago

Maybe as a preference?

Never. Hardware encoding is shit > AMD hardware encoding is even shittier > AMD vaapi encoding is the bigger pile of shit out there

TriVoxel commented 11 months ago

Maybe as a preference?

Never. Hardware encoding is shit > AMD hardware encoding is even shittier > AMD vaapi encoding is the bigger pile of shit out there

Perhaps consider using Jellyfin's FFMPEG fork. It's very good in my experience. It handles transcoding very seamlessly and I've had good experience with it. MUCH faster than software, at least for X265...

190n commented 11 months ago

I suspect @JND94's complaint is regarding efficiency (quality per bitrate), not speed. The tradeoff for speed is that you get worse quality at the same bitrate, or need a higher bitrate for the same quality, than a software encoder.

TriVoxel commented 11 months ago

I suspect @JND94's complaint is regarding efficiency (quality per bitrate), not speed. The tradeoff for speed is that you get worse quality at the same bitrate, or need a higher bitrate for the same quality, than a software encoder.

I mean, that is fair, but honestly, sometimes you just want speed for certain things. I get it though. Again, though, Jellyfin did a fantastic job with their fork, and I highly recommend we check it out because their GPU transcoding is fast, stable, reliable, and seems to look pretty good as well. Better than stock anyways...

JND94 commented 11 months ago

Perhaps consider using Jellyfin's FFMPEG fork. It's very good in my experience. It handles transcoding very seamlessly and I've had good experience with it. MUCH faster than software, at least for X265...

You mean H265/HEVC, x265 is an encoder. And you're talking about realtime encoding. aviator is intended for efficient encoding and not realtime, software encoding is the only way to achieve this, speed isn't the main goal, if you want speed you have alternatives.

gianni-rosato commented 11 months ago

This isn't in scope. Aviator is A lightweight, Flatpak-first, easy-to-use GUI utility for encoding with SVT-AV1 & Opus.

Expanding on this a bit, Aviator is a utility for encoding with SVT-AV1 & libopus (opusenc) as efficiently as possible, focused solely on extracting maximum perceptual quality per bit in the medium fidelity range out of any given source video. Other encoders are not in scope. I have a command line tool called rAV1ator CLI that is focused on such things.