Other users can't load my prebuild

[shaal]

Bug description

DrupalPod repo is based on the fact that I run the prebuild ahead of time, and all other users open the workspace and ready to work. A user reported that when they open a workspace with DrupalPod, instead of loading the prebuild, when opening the workspace init task starts running.

Steps to reproduce

Open https://github.com/shaal/gitpod--prebuild-for-other-users in Gitpod by following this link - https://gitpod.io/#https://github.com/shaal/gitpod--prebuild-for-other-users

There's a 60 seconds countdown timer that already ran in prebuild, if you see the countdown in your workspace, it failed loading prebuild.

Workspace affected

No response

Expected behavior

When a prebuild is available, any user who open the workspace should get the prebuild.

Example repository

https://github.com/shaal/gitpod--prebuild-for-other-users https://github.com/shaal/DrupalPod

Anything else?

It seems to be inconsistent who gets to load prebuild and who doesn't. @rfay can load prebuilds of my repos, @tyler36 cannot load prebuild of my repos.

Tyler36 couldn't load the prebuild for https://github.com/shaal/ddev-gitpod, after I confirmed the prebuild loads for me. I asked him to fork my ddev-gitpod repo, and generate the prebuild in his Gitpod account - https://github.com/tyler36/ddev-gitpod He was able to open his fork and it loaded the prebuild for him. I tried opening his fork but it did NOT load the perbuild for me.

[rfay]

Was it ever intentional with Gitpod that one user would be able to use the prebuilds of another user?

[rfay]

@shaal a better title might be "Other users can't load my prebuild" or something like that?

[shaal]

@rfay I found this in the docs -

Prebuilds are shared!

Gitpod can trigger a prebuild whenever there is a commit to a repository. That prebuild will then be used for all new workspaces opened on that branch. This is ideal for working together on branches for testing or code reviews. https://www.gitpod.io/docs/configure/projects/prebuilds#prebuilds-are-shared

[axonasif]

Hi @shaal, sorry for the trouble.

Can you please check if you have prebuilds enabled on the project settings for the repos you mentioned?

[shaal]

@axonasif yes, prebuilds are enabled on these projects/repos. I use these prebuilds myself, and I've been using prebuilds successfully for a couple of years now. The new issue is that some people do not get the prebuild loaded in their workspace, while other people do.

[shaal]

(removed this comment)

[tyler36]

Still having the issue with not get prebuilds from @shaal 's repo.

[axonasif]

Sorry for the late update on this. There has been a few other people asking about it. I learned that only organization members tied to the Gitpod project can load the prebuild.

See https://www.gitpod.io/docs/configure/projects/prebuilds#prebuilds-are-only-available-to-organization-members

We may need to introduce an option to allow public loading of prebuilds.

[shaal]

@axonasif The approach you described in your last comment would be a breaking change, since previously everyone was able to use the existing prebuilds for a repository.

This is also related to my separate feature request at https://github.com/gitpod-io/gitpod/issues/19175 - if Gitpod saved a prebuild whenever someone opened a commit or branch in a workspace (after running all .gitpod.yml tasks), it could save a lot of resources. By default caching that state as a prebuild, Gitpod could avoid re-running all the setup each time, which would be more efficient.

[github-actions[bot]]

This issue has been automatically marked as stale because it has not had recent activity. It will be closed if no further activity occurs. Thank you for your contributions.

[tyler36]

Still on issue.