glygener / glygen-issues

Repository for public GlyGen tickets
GNU General Public License v3.0
0 stars 0 forks source link

Next species targets (2.5+) #1084

Closed ReneRanzinger closed 6 months ago

ReneRanzinger commented 6 months ago

with adding pig in the current release, we will finish our high target species list. We need to select new targets for 2.5 and onwards. We had a species collection based on one of my games from the F2F:

https://gwu0.sharepoint.com/:x:/r/sites/GlyGenTeam-GRP/_layouts/15/Doc.aspx?sourcedoc=%7BB4FE21C6-4AB7-417C-9AB7-D9A0FF6546C1%7D&file=Species-Evaluation-Mockup.xlsx&action=default&mobileredirect=true

Sheet: Species

We also have Nathans old statistic about available species annotations:

https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1uTjCUd6CHuNz-WT589TaFzjpiKT-lJDCvsXJIrNpdj4/edit#gid=1592450874

Based on Nathans list cow, hamster, E.coli or Chicken seem to be next choices. But a quick review in GlyConnect showed that hamster and E. coli are essentially non existing.

Let me know you suggestions for the next 3-5 targets.

ReneRanzinger commented 6 months ago

Raja My preferences First one is Arabidopsis. Reasons

ReneRanzinger commented 6 months ago

Mike I can agree on arabidopsis but we need to keep in mind how to circumscribe our effort. Like bacteria, the funky monosaccharides and crazy polymers might be a black hole. Limit to N-glycans??

Chicken has historic value and might attract some immunologists/vaccinologists. And, might interface in interesting ways with campy if we get the NSF.

HIV presents challenges that might also help us think about antibody glycosylation as well. Can we consider antibodies as a 'species'?

Hamster interfaces with CHO cell as a resource. I would be surprised if there is that much hamster data that is not really CHO cells??

So, I guess I would rank in the order listed above: arabidopsis, chicken, HIV, Ab, hamster.

ReneRanzinger commented 6 months ago

Raja Agree with Mike's list. And yes Ab can be a special category. We might need to collaborate with a UniProt curator to do that one to make our life easier.

ReneRanzinger commented 6 months ago
  1. arabidopsis
  2. Chicken
  3. HIV
  4. Hamster