glygener / glygen-issues

Repository for public GlyGen tickets
GNU General Public License v3.0
0 stars 0 forks source link

Question about Publications #1637

Closed ubhuiyan closed 2 weeks ago

ubhuiyan commented 4 weeks ago

I found an instance where we provided the DOI for a publication, but there appears to be a PMID available now (PMID: 33167210). In these instances, do we update the resource or leave it as is? I found this on the detail page for G56749GV.

Screenshot 2024-08-15 at 4 45 17 PM

rykahsay commented 4 weeks ago

Association of "10.1016/j.talanta.2020.121495" and "G56749GV" is for sure coming from some downloaded/source file and here is a framework (series of questions) I want you to answer to find out which download file is giving that information.

  1. which citations dataset is connecting "10.1016/j.talanta.2020.121495" and "G56749GV" ($species_$moleculecitations$dataset.csv)?
  2. which dataset ($species$molecule$dataset.csv) was used to make citations dataset ($species_$moleculecitations$dataset.csv)?
  3. what is the download/source file used to make $species$molecule$dataset.csv?
  4. how do we change the download/source file?
ubhuiyan commented 3 weeks ago

Okay, here is my thought process:

  1. The citation dataset appears to be: human_proteoform_citations_glycosylation_sites_unicarbkb.csv
  2. This means the dataset is: human_proteoform_glycosylation_sites_unicarbkb.csv
  3. The source file for this dataset appears to be: known_33167210_glygen.csv

When you look into the source file, the PMID is already listed (unsurprisingly given the file itself is named after this PMID):

[sbhuiyan28@glygen-vm-dev current]$ awk -F, '{print $6, $10, $(NF-10)}' known_33167210_glygen.csv | grep "G56749GV"
toucan, Pmid, doi 
G56749GV 33167210 10.1016/j.talanta.2020.121495
G56749GV 33167210 10.1016/j.talanta.2020.121495
G56749GV 33167210 10.1016/j.talanta.2020.121495
G56749GV 33167210 10.1016/j.talanta.2020.121495

So I am a bit unsure why we are displaying the DOI on the front end instead of the PMID in this case.

rykahsay commented 2 weeks ago

Great! Now, I will look into it

rykahsay commented 2 weeks ago

I see both of them, I don't see what the harm is ... let's ignore this problem for now.

image
ubhuiyan commented 2 weeks ago

I meant more so in the publications section. It displays the DOI but all other resources appear to have PMID displayed if it is available. Regardless, the paper is cited anyway so I suppose it is fine how it is.