gnzlbg / static_vector

A dynamically-resizable vector with fixed capacity and embedded storage
https://gnzlbg.github.io/static_vector
167 stars 21 forks source link

Incorporate LEWG feedback #41

Open gnzlbg opened 5 years ago

gnzlbg commented 5 years ago

The feedback from Kona is that:

So AFAICT there is nothing to do here, except for summarizing the meeting notes for LWG. In particular, I'll add the following to the changelog at the top of the document:

The recommendation seems to be to forward the revised document to LWG, I will do it for the next mailing (or if I make it, post-meeting mailing):


@tituswinters @AlisdairM I think there was a concern raised by @AlisdairM about whether this can be replaced with a vector and a stack allocator. It is unclear to me whether this resolved itself during the discussion, or whether this issue is still open and I should raise this concern to LWG.

gnzlbg commented 5 years ago

@tituswinters also mentioned a couple of times in the minutes that the proposal does not feel fully baked.

I'm as surprised from the votes wanting to put this in C++20 as from the votes wanting to put this in Library Fundamentals TS v3.

Unless I missed it, neither LEWG nor LWG have gone through the wording in detail. Shouldn't one of the groups, either LEWG or LWG, go through the wording in detail to make sure that this is the wording we want, before deciding where to put it?

Did this happened already and I missed it or is the wording "good enough" ? Or is this the task of some other group ?

This is my first proposal and I feel a bit lost about how the steps being proposed fit into the process.