goat-community / goat

This is the home of Geo Open Accessibility Tool (GOAT)
GNU General Public License v3.0
89 stars 47 forks source link

Heatmap Bugs: Local Accessibility Heatmap misses POIs #2001

Closed Philipp-Otter closed 1 year ago

Philipp-Otter commented 1 year ago

This issue documents findings/ problems with the results of the new heatmap.

Philipp-Otter commented 1 year ago

Local accessibility heat map -> combined modified Gaussian function

Discount supermarkets in the study area Düren: 5358.

image

I checked the surrounding network of one of them:

image

Philipp-Otter commented 1 year ago

Local accessibility heat map -> combined modified Gaussian function

Discount supermarkets in the study area Breisgau-Hochschwarzwald: 8315.

image

Philipp-Otter commented 1 year ago

Local accessibility heat map -> combined modified Gaussian function

Supermarkets in the study area Düren: 5358.

image

Philipp-Otter commented 1 year ago

Local accessibility heat map -> combined modified Gaussian function

Discount supermarkets in the study area Landkreis Bad Tölz-Wolfratshausen: 9173.

image

Philipp-Otter commented 1 year ago

Local accessibility heat map -> combined modified Gaussian function

bus stops in the study area Landkreis Bad Tölz-Wolfratshausen: 9173.

image

Philipp-Otter commented 1 year ago

Local accessibility heat map -> combined modified Gaussian function

bus stops in the study area Düren: 5358.

image

Philipp-Otter commented 1 year ago

Local accessibility heat map -> combined modified Gaussian function

bus stops in the study area Städteregion Aachen: 5334

image

Philipp-Otter commented 1 year ago

Local accessibility heat map -> combined modified Gaussian function

rail stations in the study area Düren: 5358.

image

Philipp-Otter commented 1 year ago

Local accessibility heat map -> combined modified Gaussian function

restaurants in the study area Städteregion Aachen: 5334

image

Philipp-Otter commented 1 year ago

Local accessibility heat map -> combined modified Gaussian function

restaurants in the study area Düren: 5358.

image

Philipp-Otter commented 1 year ago

Local accessibility heat map -> combined modified Gaussian function

fast food in the study area Düren: 5358.

image

Philipp-Otter commented 1 year ago

Local accessibility heat map -> combined modified Gaussian function

nurseries in the study area Düren: 5358.

image

Philipp-Otter commented 1 year ago

Local accessibility heat map -> combined modified Gaussian function

nurseries in the study area Breisgau-Hochschwarzwald: 8315.

image

Philipp-Otter commented 1 year ago

Local accessibility heat map -> combined modified Gaussian function

kindergarten in the study area Düren: 5358.

image

Philipp-Otter commented 1 year ago

Local accessibility heat map -> combined modified Gaussian function

grundschule in the study area Düren: 5358.

image

Philipp-Otter commented 1 year ago

Local accessibility heat map -> combined modified Gaussian function

hauptschule_mittelschule in the study area Düren: 5358.

image

EPajares commented 1 year ago

I think this is not related to the POIs but it might be that the traveltime matrices are not calculated there. It would be good checking the connectivity heatmap at the same places

EPajares commented 1 year ago

It can happen with few points but having this cluster in Düren is a bit suspicious

Philipp-Otter commented 1 year ago

i will do so once i checked all the pois for indicator 2

Philipp-Otter commented 1 year ago

Local accessibility heat map -> combined modified Gaussian function

general_practitioner in the study area Düren: 5358.

image

Philipp-Otter commented 1 year ago

Local accessibility heat map -> combined modified Gaussian function

pharmarcy in the study area Düren: 5358.

image

Philipp-Otter commented 1 year ago

connectivity heatmap in düren seems fine

image

Philipp-Otter commented 1 year ago

Local accessibility heat map -> combined modified Gaussian function

forest in the study area Städteregion Aachen: 5334.

image

Philipp-Otter commented 1 year ago

Local accessibility heat map -> combined modified Gaussian function

cafe in the study area Landkreis Freising: 9178

image

image

EPajares commented 1 year ago

These issues are fixed.