goatygoatygoat / pe

0 stars 0 forks source link

Only the addition of a fixed number of modules is allowed #6

Open goatygoatygoat opened 3 years ago

goatygoatygoat commented 3 years ago

Although I understand that this product may not be a fully fledged production level project as stated in the User Guide, I still think that it should be a product somewhat usable for your target audience at least. For your project, you target NUS students, but the modules your users are able to add are mostly only Computer Science modules. This makes your project unusable for most NUS students.

nus-pe-bot commented 3 years ago

Team's Response

In the user guide we specifically mentioned that we haven't implement all the modules. It is rather not hard to add additional modules to the app if we want to. We did not do this because we feel that the current number of modules are good for demo purpose, and to showcase the idea of our app. Hence I don't see the reason why this should be a high feature flaw.

Items for the Tester to Verify

:question: Issue response

Team chose [response.Rejected]

Reason for disagreement: I have labelled it as a feature flaw with high severity as this bug makes your app a lot less useful to your intended target users. I feel your app is incomplete and does not solve the problem of your target users because users can only add a fixed number (27) of modules. Your app should be usable by your target user, it is not supposed to just be for demonstration purposes.