search

godotengine / godot

Godot Engine – Multi-platform 2D and 3D game engine
https://godotengine.org
MIT License
91.59k stars 21.27k forks source link

Why do you not use latest Mono version? #24336

Closed ghost closed 5 years ago

ghost commented 5 years ago

Hello everyone,

Godot 3.1 Alpha 3 - Please recompile with Mono latest version :(

Because I want prove you because Mono 5.12.0 is very bug cause mkbundle can't generate end of bundle executable - I already tried. No success.

Please remember that Mono 5.23.0 ( very latest version ) is very stable with mkbundle cause mkbundle generates end of bundle executable.

Please believe me! You know I have been banned from Mono Project because they don't understand what current version of Mono is buggy:

Mono.5.12 - Failed - mkbundle cannot generate executable Mono 5.14 - Failed - mkbundle cannot generate executable Mono 5.16 - Failed cause mkbundle forget to add header aot_module_register error Mono 5.18 - Failed same aot_module_register error Mono 5.19 - success - all work fine Mono 5.20 - success - all work fine Mono 5.21 , 5.22, 5.23 - success - all work fine.

// EDIT: Please remember and pick up LLVM ( It should compile for x64 and x86 ) [ EDIT: LLVM is bug, We need skip llvm / clang ] Because they can't generate gen files if we use older than LLVM 8.0 version Please remember custom mono build like ./autogen.sh --prefix=/usr --enable-large-heap=yes --enable-big-arrays than Godot mono version // END OF EDIT:

All OS , latest version of Godot 3.1 Alpha 1, 2, 3. and Godot 3.0.6 same

Thanks

Chaosus commented 5 years ago

cc @neikeq

ghost commented 5 years ago

@Chaosus thanks for note with latest mono version! And check error if I build like this:

See log: https://gist.githubusercontent.com/SourceSkyBoxer/37c55516b83229c83fb8415f457ce01a/raw/fbfb80879132592e28aa60cb05b24e336863c9dc/godot3.1-alpha3-error.log

Chaosus commented 5 years ago

Im not a mono specialist - thats why I call @neikeq to help you )

Chaosus commented 5 years ago

Personally I use custom Godot build with mono 5.16 cuz its latest stable version

ghost commented 5 years ago

"mono 5.16 cuz its latest stable version" it still bug with mkbundle check out my issue! Did you check mkbundle? Make simple if you write hello.cs with static void main and Console.WriteLine("Hello, Sir"); than compile mcs/CSC's than you generate bundled executable like this mkbundle --deps --static -z -L /usr/lib/mono/4.5 yourhello.exe -o hello_bundle -v Than it shows for you error cause it forgets to embed aot_module_register from header file like aot_register.h

That is reason - I wait for @neikeq

hpvb commented 5 years ago

We're certainly not going to ship stable releases of Godot against unstable versions of Mono. 5.16 is the current stable and that's what will be used for the official downloads for 3.1. If you need a feature from an unstable Mono release you can build your own.