search

gofair-foundation / fsr_curation

Qualifying FAIR Supporting/Enabling Resources
3 stars 1 forks source link

Linked Open Vocabularies #944

Open github-actions[bot] opened 3 months ago

github-actions[bot] commented 3 months ago

https://w3id.org/np/RANmsKH8sOiDq_gExnO5T7H3-VFVk2Cw1gNiFA9kVdJjQ

Document quality check

Item Detail
Editor name Fred van de Brug
Editor ORCID 0000-0002-3462-0967
FSR long name Linked Open Vocabularies
FSR thing URI LOV
URI of duplicate(s) (multiple separated by ';') N
Links correct (Y/N) Y
Proposed Links
Definition ok (Y/N) Y
FSR types ok (Y/N) N
FAIRSharing DOI to be added N
FSR creator in pubinfo: FIP Wizard (F) or the ORCID 0009-0004-3529-1159
Proposal: accept (A) / Improve (I) / Retract (R) / Disapprove (D) I
Proposed changes: add FSR types: Registry; Structured vocabulary

Review

Item Detail
Reviewer name Nikiforos Alygizakis
Reviewer ORCID 0000-0002-5727-4999
Decision: approve (A), reject (R), improve with comments (I) I by adding specific FSR subtype

Revisions

Item Action
Actual changes: accept (A) / Improve (I) / Retract (R) / Disapprove (D),URI of updated FSR I
If FSR is useless, check affected FIPs or SIPs (add project title) FSR is useful
Updated (U) / Deleted (D) entry in FIP/SIP U
nalygizakis commented 1 week ago

I approve your request for improving this specific nanopublication. FSR can be defined with higher accuracy. The nanopublication describes a registry and a structured vocabulary. Therefore, the nanopublication can be improved.

mabablue commented 1 week ago

hi all, this is a community nanopub not a structured vocabulary or registry; I agree a LOV registry nanopub would also be fine though, in addition to the community. I think the community needs a better definition. So you should start with This is the community of providers of semantic artefacts that ...

nalygizakis commented 1 week ago

The description was misleading "A vocabulary in LOV gathers...". Moreover, the LOV is called "Linked Open Vocabularies" confused us a bit. The creator of the nanopublication agreed to improve it.