Deprecate Page.IsNode

[jmooring]

Why?

• It's meaning is unclear
• It's superfluous (use if not .IsPage instead)
• Not sure anyone actually uses it

[onedrawingperday]

Not in favour of this proposal as I am using it in my templating.

It is an older variable and there are still projects from 5 years ago that make use of it.

Please don’t make breaking changes because some things seem unclear.

[bep]

This needs to at least wait (and in any case, we can limit the change to the documentation to start with).

[jmooring]

Updated documentation.

[github-actions[bot]]

This issue has been automatically locked since there has not been any recent activity after it was closed. Please open a new issue for related bugs.

[jmooring]

I'm reopening this because we recently introduced the concept of logical paths, and the easiest way to describe a logical path is the path between two nodes on a node tree, either relative to each other or absolute from the root of the tree.

In a data structure, the term "node" is never limited to a parent. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tree_(data_structure)

But our existing definition of node is limited to page kinds home, section, taxonomy, term, 404, and maybe some others, but the definition excludes page kind page.

I would like to deprecate .Page.IsNode recommending the use of not .IsPage instead. .IsPage returns false for page kinds home, section, taxonomy, term, 404, and maybe some others.

This is not a technical issue... .IsNode works fine. This is about the language of Hugo, the opportunity to clarify concepts in documentation, and to use terminology that is generally accepted.

---

Alternatively we could rename .Page.IsNode (and how we name it internally) to .Page.IsList per: https://github.com/gohugoio/hugo/blob/master/resources/page/page.go#L214

IsNode returns whether this is an item of one of the list types in Hugo,

[jmooring]

@bep Please comment when you have a moment. Thanks.