search

goodformandspectacle / londonmuseums

Looking to make something that shows all the museums in London.
5 stars 1 forks source link

Make comparison between Wikipedia & OSM geodata #2

Open george08 opened 9 years ago

george08 commented 9 years ago

From @siznax:

here's a comparison of what we've extracted (so far) from Wp and from the Overpass query Brandon supplied; museums (240:175), osm coords (223:180), websites (120:20), locations (108:7). the "way" entries are those with closed shapes. hopefully, as i learn more about OSM i can help improve our results. do you happen to have a ref to the pull request Brandon mentioned below?

WIKIPEDIA (wplist.json)

"count": { "loc": 108, "museum": 240, "osm": 223, "web": 120, "wiki": 240 }

OVERPASS (overpass.json)

"count": { "loc": 7, "museum": 175, "osm": 180, "way": 95, "web": 20, "wiki": 16 }

siznax commented 9 years ago

@george08, thanks for sharing @bdon's pull request. i missed that. it'll be much easier to compare the geoJSON.

would you rather get a pull request for new files, or is it okay to checkin at will?

is this issue open for a more direct comparison, or merge, of the two datasources?

george08 commented 9 years ago

Go ahead and check in at will. I think @bdon was just being polite, and isn't in the github team (yet).

Some people are strict on what issues should be for. I'm not really, unless it's bug-related.