search

google-ai-edge / mediapipe

Cross-platform, customizable ML solutions for live and streaming media.
https://ai.google.dev/edge/mediapipe
Apache License 2.0
27.12k stars 5.12k forks source link

E0415 02:46:11.517655 15 scene_cropping_calculator.cc:296] #611

Closed numb3r3 closed 4 years ago

numb3r3 commented 4 years ago

I run the autoflip for the shared test video _life_atgoogle.mp4 in a docker container, and got Killed message. You can reproduce my issue using Dockerfile. 

I0415 02:46:04.683199    11 simple_run_graph_main.cc:106] Get calculator graph config contents: # Autoflip graph that only renders the final cropped video. For use with
# end user applications.
max_queue_size: -1

# VIDEO_PREP: Decodes an input video file into images and a video header.
node {
  calculator: "OpenCvVideoDecoderCalculator"
  input_side_packet: "INPUT_FILE_PATH:input_video_path"
  output_stream: "VIDEO:video_raw"
  output_stream: "VIDEO_PRESTREAM:video_header"
  output_side_packet: "SAVED_AUDIO_PATH:audio_path"
}

# VIDEO_PREP: Scale the input video before feature extraction.
node {
  calculator: "ScaleImageCalculator"
  input_stream: "FRAMES:video_raw"
  input_stream: "VIDEO_HEADER:video_header"
  output_stream: "FRAMES:video_frames_scaled"
  options: {
    [mediapipe.ScaleImageCalculatorOptions.ext]: {
      preserve_aspect_ratio: true
      output_format: SRGB
      target_width: 480
      algorithm: DEFAULT_WITHOUT_UPSCALE
    }
  }
}

# VIDEO_PREP: Create a low frame rate stream for feature extraction.
node {
  calculator: "PacketThinnerCalculator"
  input_stream: "video_frames_scaled"
  output_stream: "video_frames_scaled_downsampled"
  options: {
    [mediapipe.PacketThinnerCalculatorOptions.ext]: {
      thinner_type: ASYNC
      period: 200000
    }
  }
}

# DETECTION: find borders around the video and major background color.
node {
  calculator: "BorderDetectionCalculator"
  input_stream: "VIDEO:video_raw"
  output_stream: "DETECTED_BORDERS:borders"
}

# DETECTION: find shot/scene boundaries on the full frame rate stream.
node {
  calculator: "ShotBoundaryCalculator"
  input_stream: "VIDEO:video_frames_scaled"
  output_stream: "IS_SHOT_CHANGE:shot_change"
  options {
    [mediapipe.autoflip.ShotBoundaryCalculatorOptions.ext] {
      min_shot_span: 0.2
      min_motion: 0.3
      window_size: 15
      min_shot_measure: 10
      min_motion_with_shot_measure: 0.05
    }
  }
}

# DETECTION: find faces on the down sampled stream
node {
  calculator: "AutoFlipFaceDetectionSubgraph"
  input_stream: "VIDEO:video_frames_scaled_downsampled"
  output_stream: "DETECTIONS:face_detections"
}
node {
  calculator: "FaceToRegionCalculator"
  input_stream: "VIDEO:video_frames_scaled_downsampled"
  input_stream: "FACES:face_detections"
  output_stream: "REGIONS:face_regions"
}

# DETECTION: find objects on the down sampled stream
node {
  calculator: "AutoFlipObjectDetectionSubgraph"
  input_stream: "VIDEO:video_frames_scaled_downsampled"
  output_stream: "DETECTIONS:object_detections"
}
node {
  calculator: "LocalizationToRegionCalculator"
  input_stream: "DETECTIONS:object_detections"
  output_stream: "REGIONS:object_regions"
  options {
    [mediapipe.autoflip.LocalizationToRegionCalculatorOptions.ext] {
      output_all_signals: true
    }
  }
}

# SIGNAL FUSION: Combine detections (with weights) on each frame
node {
  calculator: "SignalFusingCalculator"
  input_stream: "shot_change"
  input_stream: "face_regions"
  input_stream: "object_regions"
  output_stream: "salient_regions"
  options {
    [mediapipe.autoflip.SignalFusingCalculatorOptions.ext] {
      signal_settings {
        type { standard: FACE_CORE_LANDMARKS }
        min_score: 0.85
        max_score: 0.9
        is_required: false
      }
      signal_settings {
        type { standard: FACE_ALL_LANDMARKS }
        min_score: 0.8
        max_score: 0.85
        is_required: false
      }
      signal_settings {
        type { standard: FACE_FULL }
        min_score: 0.8
        max_score: 0.85
        is_required: false
      }
      signal_settings {
        type: { standard: HUMAN }
        min_score: 0.75
        max_score: 0.8
        is_required: false
      }
      signal_settings {
        type: { standard: PET }
        min_score: 0.7
        max_score: 0.75
        is_required: false
      }
      signal_settings {
        type: { standard: CAR }
        min_score: 0.7
        max_score: 0.75
        is_required: false
      }
      signal_settings {
        type: { standard: OBJECT }
        min_score: 0.1
        max_score: 0.2
        is_required: false
      }
    }
  }
}

# CROPPING: make decisions about how to crop each frame.
node {
  calculator: "SceneCroppingCalculator"
  input_side_packet: "EXTERNAL_ASPECT_RATIO:aspect_ratio"
  input_stream: "VIDEO_FRAMES:video_raw"
  input_stream: "KEY_FRAMES:video_frames_scaled_downsampled"
  input_stream: "DETECTION_FEATURES:salient_regions"
  input_stream: "STATIC_FEATURES:borders"
  input_stream: "SHOT_BOUNDARIES:shot_change"
  output_stream: "CROPPED_FRAMES:cropped_frames"
  options: {
    [mediapipe.autoflip.SceneCroppingCalculatorOptions.ext]: {
      max_scene_size: 600
      key_frame_crop_options: {
        score_aggregation_type: CONSTANT
      }
      scene_camera_motion_analyzer_options: {
        motion_stabilization_threshold_percent: 0.5
        salient_point_bound: 0.499
      }
      padding_parameters: {
        blur_cv_size: 200
        overlay_opacity: 0.6
      }
      target_size_type: MAXIMIZE_TARGET_DIMENSION
    }
  }
}

# ENCODING(required): encode the video stream for the final cropped output.
node {
  calculator: "VideoPreStreamCalculator"
  # Fetch frame format and dimension from input frames.
  input_stream: "FRAME:cropped_frames"
  # Copying frame rate and duration from original video.
  input_stream: "VIDEO_PRESTREAM:video_header"
  output_stream: "output_frames_video_header"
}

node {
  calculator: "OpenCvVideoEncoderCalculator"
  input_stream: "VIDEO:cropped_frames"
  input_stream: "VIDEO_PRESTREAM:output_frames_video_header"
  input_side_packet: "OUTPUT_FILE_PATH:output_video_path"
  input_side_packet: "AUDIO_FILE_PATH:audio_path"
  options: {
    [mediapipe.OpenCvVideoEncoderCalculatorOptions.ext]: {
      codec: "avc1"
      video_format: "mp4"
    }
  }
}
I0415 02:46:04.688714    11 simple_run_graph_main.cc:121] Initialize the calculator graph.
I0415 02:46:04.692718    11 simple_run_graph_main.cc:134] Start running the calculator graph.
/tmp/filev2mmuV
I0415 02:46:09.042798    15 shot_boundary_calculator.cc:116] Shot change at: 1.16783 seconds.
E0415 02:46:09.308573    13 scene_cropping_calculator.cc:296] ------------------------ (Breathing) Time(s): 0
E0415 02:46:09.327798    13 scene_cropping_calculator.cc:296] ------------------------ (Breathing) Time(s): 0.333666
E0415 02:46:09.394467    14 scene_cropping_calculator.cc:296] ------------------------ (Breathing) Time(s): 0.667333
I0415 02:46:09.566853    16 shot_boundary_calculator.cc:116] Shot change at: 3.37003 seconds.
E0415 02:46:09.674623    14 scene_cropping_calculator.cc:296] ------------------------ (Breathing) Time(s): 1.001
E0415 02:46:10.100425    15 scene_cropping_calculator.cc:296] ------------------------ (Breathing) Time(s): 1.33467
E0415 02:46:10.271445    14 scene_cropping_calculator.cc:296] ------------------------ (Breathing) Time(s): 1.66833
I0415 02:46:10.475579    15 shot_boundary_calculator.cc:116] Shot change at: 6.47313 seconds.
E0415 02:46:10.611480    16 scene_cropping_calculator.cc:296] ------------------------ (Breathing) Time(s): 2.002
I0415 02:46:10.858661    15 shot_boundary_calculator.cc:116] Shot change at: 8.04137 seconds.
E0415 02:46:10.936367    16 scene_cropping_calculator.cc:296] ------------------------ (Breathing) Time(s): 2.33567
I0415 02:46:11.215296    16 shot_boundary_calculator.cc:116] Shot change at: 9.3093 seconds.
E0415 02:46:11.233227    13 scene_cropping_calculator.cc:296] ------------------------ (Breathing) Time(s): 2.66933
I0415 02:46:11.398821    15 shot_boundary_calculator.cc:116] Shot change at: 10.1768 seconds.
E0415 02:46:11.517655    15 scene_cropping_calculator.cc:296] ------------------------ (Breathing) Time(s): 3.003
E0415 02:46:11.807808    14 scene_cropping_calculator.cc:296] ------------------------ (Breathing) Time(s): 3.33667
E0415 02:46:12.054368    14 scene_cropping_calculator.cc:296] ------------------------ (Breathing) Time(s): 3.67033
E0415 02:46:12.314015    14 scene_cropping_calculator.cc:296] ------------------------ (Breathing) Time(s): 4.004
E0415 02:46:12.568878    15 scene_cropping_calculator.cc:296] ------------------------ (Breathing) Time(s): 4.33767
E0415 02:46:12.833395    15 scene_cropping_calculator.cc:296] ------------------------ (Breathing) Time(s): 4.67133
E0415 02:46:13.070551    14 scene_cropping_calculator.cc:296] ------------------------ (Breathing) Time(s): 5.005
E0415 02:46:13.383461    16 scene_cropping_calculator.cc:296] ------------------------ (Breathing) Time(s): 5.33867
E0415 02:46:13.711052    15 scene_cropping_calculator.cc:296] ------------------------ (Breathing) Time(s): 5.67233
I0415 02:46:13.871870    13 shot_boundary_calculator.cc:116] Shot change at: 18.1515 seconds.
E0415 02:46:14.055469    15 scene_cropping_calculator.cc:296] ------------------------ (Breathing) Time(s): 6.006
I0415 02:46:14.186884    15 shot_boundary_calculator.cc:116] Shot change at: 19.4194 seconds.
E0415 02:46:14.400894    14 scene_cropping_calculator.cc:296] ------------------------ (Breathing) Time(s): 6.33967
I0415 02:46:14.448408    14 shot_boundary_calculator.cc:116] Shot change at: 20.2869 seconds.
Killed
jiuqiant commented 4 years ago

I use your Dockerfile to reproduce this issue but it works fine on my local machine (Debian). I guess the issue is more or less related to the computer's resources. I will try to reproduce this on a fresh Google Cloud Ubuntu instance with limited resources (CPUs and memory) to verify my theory.

Docker build:

$ docker build --tag=autoflip .
Sending build context to Docker daemon  306.5MB
Step 1/21 : FROM ubuntu:latest
 ---> 7698f282e524
Step 2/21 : MAINTAINER <mediapipe@google.com>
 ---> Using cache
 ---> 3410d770a6c0
Step 3/21 : WORKDIR /io
 ---> Using cache
 ---> c3366441f622
Step 4/21 : WORKDIR /mediapipe
 ---> Using cache
 ---> b6ce973bba13
Step 5/21 : ENV DEBIAN_FRONTEND=noninteractive
 ---> Using cache
 ---> 55c9b779338e
Step 6/21 : RUN apt-get update && apt-get install -y --no-install-recommends         build-essential            ca-certificates                 curl                    git                 wget                            unzip                               python                                  python-pip                  python3-pip                                                     cmake ffmpeg libavformat-dev libdc1394-22-dev libgtk2.0-dev                             libjpeg-dev libpng-dev libswscale-dev libtbb2 libtbb-dev                            libtiff-dev                                                     software-properties-common &&                                       add-apt-repository -y ppa:openjdk-r/ppa &&                                      apt-get update && apt-get install -y openjdk-8-jdk &&                           apt-get clean &&                                                    rm -rf /var/lib/apt/lists/*
 ---> Using cache
 ---> 0cf6e8413c89
Step 7/21 : RUN pip install --upgrade setuptools
 ---> Using cache
 ---> 4e273a3ff1ea
Step 8/21 : RUN pip install future
 ---> Using cache
 ---> 41e39bbe11e0
Step 9/21 : RUN pip3 install six
 ---> Using cache
 ---> 77ec5dc40af5
Step 10/21 : ARG BAZEL_VERSION=2.0.0
 ---> Using cache
 ---> ef8eb72bdb86
Step 11/21 : RUN mkdir /bazel &&     wget --no-check-certificate -O /bazel/installer.sh "https://github.com/bazelbuild/bazel/releases/download/${BAZEL_VERSION}/bazel-${BAZEL_VERSION}-installer-linux-x86_64.sh" &&     wget --no-check-certificate -O  /bazel/LICENSE.txt "https://raw.githubusercontent.com/bazelbuild/bazel/master/LICENSE" &&         chmod +x /bazel/installer.sh &&      /bazel/installer.sh  &&             rm -f /bazel/installer.sh
 ---> Using cache
 ---> 1d1cb225a1c0
Step 12/21 : RUN echo "Installing OpenCV from source"
 ---> Using cache
 ---> 3dfeca8b7f2f
Step 13/21 : ARG OPENCV_VERSION=3.4.0
 ---> Using cache
 ---> 96834bdc06db
Step 14/21 : RUN rm -rf /tmp/build_opencv     && mkdir /tmp/build_opencv         && cd /tmp/build_opencv        && wget -q https://github.com/opencv/opencv_contrib/archive/${OPENCV_VERSION}.tar.gz && tar xvzf ${OPENCV_VERSION}.tar.gz && rm ${OPENCV_VERSION}.tar.gz            && wget -q https://github.com/opencv/opencv/archive/${OPENCV_VERSION}.tar.gz && tar xvzf ${OPENCV_VERSION}.tar.gz && rm ${OPENCV_VERSION}.tar.gz
 ---> Using cache
 ---> c73555d6cb48
Step 15/21 : RUN cd /tmp/build_opencv && mkdir opencv-${OPENCV_VERSION}/release     && cd opencv-${OPENCV_VERSION}/release         && cmake .. -DCMAKE_BUILD_TYPE=RELEASE -DCMAKE_INSTALL_PREFIX=/usr/local               -DBUILD_TESTS=OFF -DBUILD_PERF_TESTS=OFF -DBUILD_opencv_ts=OFF                    -DOPENCV_EXTRA_MODULES_PATH=/tmp/build_opencv/opencv_contrib-${OPENCV_VERSION}/modules                    -DBUILD_opencv_aruco=OFF -DBUILD_opencv_bgsegm=OFF -DBUILD_opencv_bioinspired=OFF                         -DBUILD_opencv_ccalib=OFF -DBUILD_opencv_datasets=OFF -DBUILD_opencv_dnn=OFF                  -DBUILD_opencv_dnn_objdetect=OFF -DBUILD_opencv_dpm=OFF -DBUILD_opencv_face=OFF                   -DBUILD_opencv_fuzzy=OFF -DBUILD_opencv_hfs=OFF -DBUILD_opencv_img_hash=OFF                           -DBUILD_opencv_js=OFF -DBUILD_opencv_line_descriptor=OFF -DBUILD_opencv_phase_unwrapping=OFF                                                  -DBUILD_opencv_plot=OFF -DBUILD_opencv_quality=OFF -DBUILD_opencv_reg=OFF                                 -DBUILD_opencv_rgbd=OFF -DBUILD_opencv_saliency=OFF -DBUILD_opencv_shape=OFF                      -DBUILD_opencv_structured_light=OFF -DBUILD_opencv_surface_matching=OFF                           -DBUILD_opencv_world=OFF -DBUILD_opencv_xobjdetect=OFF -DBUILD_opencv_xphoto=OFF                && make -j 2 && make install                                        && rm -rf /tmp/build_opencv                                             && echo "OpenCV has been built. You can find the header files and libraries in /usr/local/include/opencv2/ and /usr/local/lib"                                          && touch /etc/ld.so.conf.d/mp_opencv.conf                                           && bash -c  "echo /usr/local/lib >> /etc/ld.so.conf.d/mp_opencv.conf"                       && ldconfig -v
 ---> Using cache
 ---> e2f5be1030d3
Step 16/21 : WORKDIR /mediapipe
 ---> Using cache
 ---> 0068d23cffbf
Step 17/21 : COPY . /mediapipe/
 ---> Using cache
 ---> 478f9ff413ad
Step 18/21 : RUN echo "Modifying MediaPipe opencv config"
 ---> Using cache
 ---> 8334c58c3b34
Step 19/21 : RUN opencv_build_file=/mediapipe/third_party/opencv_linux.BUILD     && workspace_file=/mediapipe/WORKSPACE         && sed -i "s/lib\/x86_64-linux-gnu/lib/g" $opencv_build_file        && linux_opencv_config=$(grep -n 'linux_opencv' $workspace_file | awk -F  ":" '{print $1}')             && path_line=$((linux_opencv_config + 2))           && sed -i "$path_line d" $workspace_file                && sed -i "$path_line i\    path = \"/usr/local\"," $workspace_file             && echo "Done"
 ---> Using cache
 ---> ab13c90b3429
Step 20/21 : RUN bazel build --jobs=2 --sandbox_debug -c opt --define MEDIAPIPE_DISABLE_GPU=1   mediapipe/examples/desktop/autoflip:run_autoflip
 ---> Using cache
 ---> 2df8e7ef8337
Step 21/21 : ENV GLOG_logtostderr=1
 ---> Using cache
 ---> 1137ba7d2be8
Successfully built 1137ba7d2be8
Successfully tagged autoflip:latest

Run binary:

root@b87e4ad32e5e:/mediapipe# bazel-bin/mediapipe/examples/desktop/autoflip/run_autoflip --calculator_graph_config_file=mediapipe/examples/desktop/autoflip/autoflip_graph.pbtxt --input_side_packets=input_video_path=/mediapipe/life_at_google.mp4,output_video_path=/mediapipe/life_at_google_output.mp4,aspect_ratio=1:1
...
I0415 18:43:48.084107    11 simple_run_graph_main.cc:121] Initialize the calculator graph.
I0415 18:43:48.086108    11 simple_run_graph_main.cc:134] Start running the calculator graph.
/tmp/fileHHJGKP
I0415 18:43:52.473032    37 shot_boundary_calculator.cc:116] Shot change at: 1.16783 seconds.
E0415 18:43:52.653165    34 scene_cropping_calculator.cc:296] ------------------------ (Breathing) Time(s): 0
E0415 18:43:52.670934    34 scene_cropping_calculator.cc:296] ------------------------ (Breathing) Time(s): 0.333666
E0415 18:43:52.689848    34 scene_cropping_calculator.cc:296] ------------------------ (Breathing) Time(s): 0.667333
E0415 18:43:52.749868    38 scene_cropping_calculator.cc:296] ------------------------ (Breathing) Time(s): 1.001
I0415 18:43:53.066108    26 shot_boundary_calculator.cc:116] Shot change at: 3.37003 seconds.
E0415 18:43:53.472573    19 scene_cropping_calculator.cc:296] ------------------------ (Breathing) Time(s): 1.33467
E0415 18:43:53.479622    19 scene_cropping_calculator.cc:296] ------------------------ (Breathing) Time(s): 1.66833
E0415 18:43:53.498073    19 scene_cropping_calculator.cc:296] ------------------------ (Breathing) Time(s): 2.002
E0415 18:43:53.517328    19 scene_cropping_calculator.cc:296] ------------------------ (Breathing) Time(s): 2.33567
E0415 18:43:53.672381    22 scene_cropping_calculator.cc:296] ------------------------ (Breathing) Time(s): 2.66933
I0415 18:43:53.902549    36 shot_boundary_calculator.cc:116] Shot change at: 6.47313 seconds.
E0415 18:43:53.906495    24 scene_cropping_calculator.cc:296] ------------------------ (Breathing) Time(s): 3.003
E0415 18:43:54.170825    28 scene_cropping_calculator.cc:296] ------------------------ (Breathing) Time(s): 3.33667
I0415 18:43:54.383972    29 shot_boundary_calculator.cc:116] Shot change at: 8.04137 seconds.
E0415 18:43:54.415611    30 scene_cropping_calculator.cc:296] ------------------------ (Breathing) Time(s): 3.67033
E0415 18:43:54.550602    30 scene_cropping_calculator.cc:296] ------------------------ (Breathing) Time(s): 4.004
I0415 18:43:54.713011    25 shot_boundary_calculator.cc:116] Shot change at: 9.3093 seconds.
E0415 18:43:54.795744    38 scene_cropping_calculator.cc:296] ------------------------ (Breathing) Time(s): 4.33767
I0415 18:43:54.934108    15 shot_boundary_calculator.cc:116] Shot change at: 10.1768 seconds.
E0415 18:43:55.043102    31 scene_cropping_calculator.cc:296] ------------------------ (Breathing) Time(s): 4.67133
E0415 18:43:55.303258    32 scene_cropping_calculator.cc:296] ------------------------ (Breathing) Time(s): 5.005
E0415 18:43:55.572466    19 scene_cropping_calculator.cc:296] ------------------------ (Breathing) Time(s): 5.33867
E0415 18:43:55.832547    14 scene_cropping_calculator.cc:296] ------------------------ (Breathing) Time(s): 5.67233
E0415 18:43:56.123279    19 scene_cropping_calculator.cc:296] ------------------------ (Breathing) Time(s): 6.006
E0415 18:43:56.370955    35 scene_cropping_calculator.cc:296] ------------------------ (Breathing) Time(s): 6.33967
E0415 18:43:56.824383    33 scene_cropping_calculator.cc:296] ------------------------ (Breathing) Time(s): 6.67333
E0415 18:43:56.844684    33 scene_cropping_calculator.cc:296] ------------------------ (Breathing) Time(s): 7.007
...
E0415 18:45:27.719717    32 scene_cropping_calculator.cc:296] ------------------------ (Breathing) Time(s): 124.791
E0415 18:45:27.974804    34 scene_cropping_calculator.cc:296] ------------------------ (Breathing) Time(s): 125.125
E0415 18:45:28.223284    13 scene_cropping_calculator.cc:296] ------------------------ (Breathing) Time(s): 125.459
E0415 18:45:28.467175    26 scene_cropping_calculator.cc:296] ------------------------ (Breathing) Time(s): 125.792
E0415 18:45:28.706929    35 scene_cropping_calculator.cc:296] ------------------------ (Breathing) Time(s): 126.126
E0415 18:45:28.943146    20 scene_cropping_calculator.cc:296] ------------------------ (Breathing) Time(s): 126.46
E0415 18:45:29.198134    29 scene_cropping_calculator.cc:296] ------------------------ (Breathing) Time(s): 126.793
E0415 18:45:29.440160    32 scene_cropping_calculator.cc:296] ------------------------ (Breathing) Time(s): 127.127
E0415 18:45:29.693228    34 scene_cropping_calculator.cc:296] ------------------------ (Breathing) Time(s): 127.461
E0415 18:45:29.943795    13 scene_cropping_calculator.cc:296] ------------------------ (Breathing) Time(s): 127.794
E0415 18:45:30.202262    26 scene_cropping_calculator.cc:296] ------------------------ (Breathing) Time(s): 128.128
E0415 18:45:30.461272    35 scene_cropping_calculator.cc:296] ------------------------ (Breathing) Time(s): 128.462
E0415 18:45:30.729924    20 scene_cropping_calculator.cc:296] ------------------------ (Breathing) Time(s): 128.795
E0415 18:45:31.000581    29 scene_cropping_calculator.cc:296] ------------------------ (Breathing) Time(s): 129.129
E0415 18:45:31.263389    32 scene_cropping_calculator.cc:296] ------------------------ (Breathing) Time(s): 129.463
E0415 18:45:31.520186    34 scene_cropping_calculator.cc:296] ------------------------ (Breathing) Time(s): 129.796
E0415 18:45:32.502835    14 scene_cropping_calculator.cc:296] ------------------------ (Breathing) Time(s): 130.13
E0415 18:45:32.510994    14 scene_cropping_calculator.cc:296] ------------------------ (Breathing) Time(s): 130.464
I0415 18:45:34.913347    11 simple_run_graph_main.cc:149] Success!
numb3r3 commented 4 years ago

@jiuqiant Thanks for your timely response. Yes, this issue is related RAM resource. So sad, docker for Mac limits the resource available to 2GB by default! I have fixed this issue by now. Thank you again!

jiuqiant commented 4 years ago

Glad to hear that the problem is solved!