search

google / fonts

Font files available from Google Fonts, and a public issue tracker for all things Google Fonts
https://fonts.google.com
18.26k stars 2.62k forks source link

Add Estedad #2228

Open eliheuer opened 5 years ago

eliheuer commented 5 years ago

Estedad is a Sans Serif Arabic-Latin typeface in 5 weights and variable version. Created with fontforge and fontmake. Licensed under SIL open font License V1.1

https://github.com/aminabedi68/Estedad https://aminabedi68.github.io/Estedad/

estedad

davelab6 commented 1 year ago

Since this has fontforge sources and @yanone is out for summer soon, I'm reassigning to @eliheuer

Amir-A-M commented 7 months ago

Hi. Any updates?

yanone commented 7 months ago

Any updates?

This font has a Kashida (KSHD) axis, which needs to be registered with Google Font’s axis registry before Estedad (and Mikhak) can be onboarded. However, a Kashida axis isn’t getting enough traction because it’s technically identical to a Glyph Extension (GEXT) axis, and Google Fonts is apprehensive of introducing duplicate concepts for the sole reason of them being culturally unique. See full discussion here.

Furthermore, his implementation of the Kashida axis, in my understanding, is wrong. His glyphs extend to both sides identically, which is not how Kashidas are used (they are inserted manually in meaningful places, and only there). His implementation is actually a width axis implementation because the dedicated Kashida character (U+0640) isn’t even playing a role. In other words, there are multiple problems here.

So unless the author withdraws from his insistence to register a Kashida axis, both fonts cannot be onboarded to Google Fonts sadly.

davelab6 commented 7 months ago

@yanone upstream requested a new review @ https://github.com/aminabedi68/Estedad/issues/17