tphinney
commented
2 years ago This is a bit belated, but….
I strongly suspect using a path at the correct coordinates with fill="none" is used to ensure correct positioning of the icon within a virtual box, to get the desired alignment.
Most of the rest is outside my personal expertise, though. As of a week and a couple of days ago, I am now doing initial triage on issues in the repo.
You are correct that the things here are being generated elsewhere and this is not the “true source.” But it is the right place to report issues. Those look like a nice set of things to report as separate issues!
A quick grep for the invalid tag
<g/>inside this repo reveals...Click to expand
``` ./material-design-icons/src/av/queue_music/materialiconsoutlined/24px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/av/queue_music/materialiconstwotone/24px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/av/airplay/materialiconsoutlined/24px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/av/airplay/materialiconstwotone/24px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/av/web/materialiconsoutlined/24px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/av/web/materialiconstwotone/24px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/av/pause_circle_filled/materialiconsoutlined/24px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/av/pause_circle_filled/materialiconstwotone/24px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/av/forward_10/materialiconsoutlined/24px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/av/forward_10/materialiconstwotone/24px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/av/replay/materialiconsoutlined/24px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/av/replay/materialiconstwotone/24px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/av/surround_sound/materialiconsoutlined/24px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/av/surround_sound/materialiconstwotone/24px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/av/fast_forward/materialiconsoutlined/24px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/av/fast_forward/materialiconstwotone/24px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/av/mic/materialiconsoutlined/24px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/av/mic/materialiconstwotone/24px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/places/storefront/materialiconssharp/24px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/places/storefront/materialiconsoutlined/24px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/places/storefront/materialicons/24px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/places/storefront/materialiconsround/24px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/places/storefront/materialiconstwotone/24px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/image/euro/materialiconssharp/20px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/image/euro/materialiconssharp/24px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/image/euro/materialiconsoutlined/20px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/image/euro/materialiconsoutlined/24px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/image/euro/materialicons/20px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/image/euro/materialicons/24px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/image/euro/materialiconsround/20px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/image/euro/materialiconsround/24px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/image/euro/materialiconstwotone/20px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/image/euro/materialiconstwotone/24px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/image/details/materialiconsround/24px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/social/emoji_nature/materialiconssharp/20px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/social/emoji_nature/materialiconssharp/24px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/social/emoji_nature/materialiconsoutlined/20px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/social/emoji_nature/materialiconsoutlined/24px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/social/emoji_nature/materialicons/20px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/social/emoji_nature/materialicons/24px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/social/emoji_nature/materialiconsround/20px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/social/emoji_nature/materialiconsround/24px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/social/emoji_events/materialiconssharp/20px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/social/emoji_events/materialiconsoutlined/20px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/social/emoji_events/materialicons/20px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/social/emoji_events/materialiconsround/20px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/social/emoji_events/materialiconstwotone/20px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/social/emoji_objects/materialiconssharp/20px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/social/emoji_objects/materialiconssharp/24px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/social/emoji_objects/materialiconsoutlined/20px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/social/emoji_objects/materialiconsoutlined/24px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/social/emoji_objects/materialicons/20px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/social/emoji_objects/materialicons/24px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/social/emoji_objects/materialiconsround/20px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/social/emoji_objects/materialiconsround/24px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/social/emoji_objects/materialiconstwotone/20px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/social/emoji_objects/materialiconstwotone/24px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/social/emoji_symbols/materialiconssharp/20px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/social/emoji_symbols/materialiconssharp/24px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/social/emoji_symbols/materialiconsoutlined/20px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/social/emoji_symbols/materialiconsoutlined/24px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/social/emoji_symbols/materialicons/20px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/social/emoji_symbols/materialicons/24px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/social/emoji_symbols/materialiconsround/20px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/social/emoji_symbols/materialiconsround/24px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/social/emoji_symbols/materialiconstwotone/20px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/social/emoji_symbols/materialiconstwotone/24px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/social/emoji_flags/materialiconssharp/20px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/social/emoji_flags/materialiconssharp/24px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/social/emoji_flags/materialiconsoutlined/20px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/social/emoji_flags/materialiconsoutlined/24px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/social/emoji_flags/materialicons/20px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/social/emoji_flags/materialicons/24px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/social/emoji_flags/materialiconsround/20px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/social/emoji_flags/materialiconsround/24px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/social/emoji_flags/materialiconstwotone/20px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/social/emoji_flags/materialiconstwotone/24px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/social/emoji_transportation/materialiconssharp/20px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/social/emoji_transportation/materialiconssharp/24px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/social/emoji_transportation/materialiconsoutlined/20px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/social/emoji_transportation/materialiconsoutlined/24px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/social/emoji_transportation/materialicons/20px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/social/emoji_transportation/materialicons/24px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/social/emoji_transportation/materialiconsround/20px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/social/emoji_transportation/materialiconsround/24px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/social/emoji_transportation/materialiconstwotone/20px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/social/emoji_transportation/materialiconstwotone/24px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/social/emoji_food_beverage/materialiconssharp/20px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/social/emoji_food_beverage/materialiconssharp/24px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/social/emoji_food_beverage/materialiconsoutlined/20px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/social/emoji_food_beverage/materialiconsoutlined/24px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/social/emoji_food_beverage/materialicons/20px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/social/emoji_food_beverage/materialicons/24px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/social/emoji_food_beverage/materialiconsround/20px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/social/emoji_food_beverage/materialiconsround/24px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/social/emoji_food_beverage/materialiconstwotone/20px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/social/emoji_food_beverage/materialiconstwotone/24px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/social/emoji_people/materialiconssharp/20px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/social/emoji_people/materialiconssharp/24px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/social/emoji_people/materialiconsoutlined/20px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/social/emoji_people/materialiconsoutlined/24px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/social/emoji_people/materialicons/20px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/social/emoji_people/materialicons/24px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/social/emoji_people/materialiconsround/20px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/social/emoji_people/materialiconsround/24px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/social/emoji_people/materialiconstwotone/20px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/social/emoji_people/materialiconstwotone/24px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/social/people_alt/materialiconssharp/20px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/social/people_alt/materialiconssharp/24px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/social/people_alt/materialiconsoutlined/20px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/social/people_alt/materialiconsoutlined/24px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/social/people_alt/materialicons/20px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/social/people_alt/materialicons/24px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/social/people_alt/materialiconsround/20px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/social/people_alt/materialiconsround/24px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/social/people_alt/materialiconstwotone/20px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/social/people_alt/materialiconstwotone/24px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/social/emoji_emotions/materialiconssharp/20px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/social/emoji_emotions/materialiconssharp/24px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/social/emoji_emotions/materialiconsoutlined/20px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/social/emoji_emotions/materialiconsoutlined/24px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/social/emoji_emotions/materialicons/20px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/social/emoji_emotions/materialicons/24px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/social/emoji_emotions/materialiconsround/20px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/social/emoji_emotions/materialiconsround/24px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/social/emoji_emotions/materialiconstwotone/20px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/social/emoji_emotions/materialiconstwotone/24px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/content/amp_stories/materialiconssharp/20px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/content/amp_stories/materialiconssharp/24px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/content/amp_stories/materialiconsoutlined/20px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/content/amp_stories/materialiconsoutlined/24px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/content/amp_stories/materialicons/20px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/content/amp_stories/materialicons/24px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/content/amp_stories/materialiconsround/20px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/content/amp_stories/materialiconsround/24px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/content/amp_stories/materialiconstwotone/20px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/content/amp_stories/materialiconstwotone/24px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/content/policy/materialiconssharp/20px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/content/policy/materialiconssharp/24px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/content/policy/materialiconsoutlined/20px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/content/policy/materialiconsoutlined/24px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/content/policy/materialicons/20px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/content/policy/materialicons/24px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/content/policy/materialiconsround/20px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/content/policy/materialiconsround/24px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/content/policy/materialiconstwotone/20px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/content/policy/materialiconstwotone/24px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/content/dynamic_feed/materialiconssharp/20px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/content/dynamic_feed/materialiconssharp/24px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/content/dynamic_feed/materialiconsoutlined/20px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/content/dynamic_feed/materialiconsoutlined/24px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/content/dynamic_feed/materialicons/20px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/content/dynamic_feed/materialicons/24px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/content/dynamic_feed/materialiconsround/20px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/content/dynamic_feed/materialiconsround/24px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/content/dynamic_feed/materialiconstwotone/20px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/content/dynamic_feed/materialiconstwotone/24px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/maps/menu_book/materialiconssharp/24px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/maps/menu_book/materialiconsoutlined/24px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/maps/menu_book/materialicons/24px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/maps/menu_book/materialiconsround/24px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/maps/menu_book/materialiconstwotone/24px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/maps/design_services/materialiconssharp/20px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/maps/design_services/materialiconssharp/24px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/maps/design_services/materialiconsoutlined/20px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/maps/design_services/materialiconsoutlined/24px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/maps/design_services/materialicons/20px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/maps/design_services/materialicons/24px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/maps/design_services/materialiconsround/20px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/maps/design_services/materialiconsround/24px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/maps/design_services/materialiconstwotone/20px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/maps/design_services/materialiconstwotone/24px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/editor/height/materialiconssharp/20px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/editor/height/materialiconssharp/24px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/editor/height/materialiconsoutlined/20px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/editor/height/materialiconsoutlined/24px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/editor/height/materialicons/20px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/editor/height/materialicons/24px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/editor/height/materialiconsround/20px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/editor/height/materialiconsround/24px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/editor/height/materialiconstwotone/20px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/editor/height/materialiconstwotone/24px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/editor/post_add/materialiconssharp/20px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/editor/post_add/materialiconssharp/24px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/editor/post_add/materialiconsoutlined/20px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/editor/post_add/materialiconsoutlined/24px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/editor/post_add/materialicons/20px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/editor/post_add/materialicons/24px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/editor/post_add/materialiconsround/20px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/editor/post_add/materialiconsround/24px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/editor/post_add/materialiconstwotone/20px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/editor/post_add/materialiconstwotone/24px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/action/addchart/materialiconssharp/24px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/action/outbond/materialiconssharp/24px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/action/outbond/materialiconsround/24px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/action/sync_alt/materialiconssharp/20px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/action/sync_alt/materialiconssharp/24px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/action/sync_alt/materialiconsoutlined/20px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/action/sync_alt/materialiconsoutlined/24px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/action/sync_alt/materialicons/20px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/action/sync_alt/materialicons/24px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/action/sync_alt/materialiconsround/20px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/action/sync_alt/materialiconsround/24px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/action/sync_alt/materialiconstwotone/20px.svg ./material-design-icons/src/action/sync_alt/materialiconstwotone/24px.svg ```I'm currently using this repo to generate SVG data URLs to use within CSS as an alternative to the icon font. After taking a good look at my output I actually noticed quite a few worrying things about the quality of MOST of the SVGs. For example, useless (and broken)
<g>tags, paths withfill="none"that seemingly do nothing, the use ofbaseProfile,fill-rule, andenable-background. All of which I mentioned cannot be fixed with SVGO, at least not with their defaults.Where would I go to PR or at least discuss these issues, if anywhere? It seems like this repository is not the original source for the icons, just the output of a build hosted elsewhere.