Better default markdown support

[adriens]

:grey_question: About

I use mesop to interact with an AI Agent API that is able to reply complex markdown... with lists and sub-items... but when display its answers I got sub-item appearing at the wrong level :

In other words, sections are messed-up and all go to the same level

:pray: Feature request

Make mesop better handle list and sublists.

For now, the only workaround I foud is to asj my agent to reply in markdown in raw format... causing the final display to be right but properly displayed (I have to copy/paste it into any markdown previewer to enjoy it).

[richard-to]

Thanks for pointing that out. As an experiment I've been thinking of creating a web component that renders markdown on the client side, which I think could improve https://github.com/google/mesop/issues/591.

So first I want to try it as a web component to see if it works. And if it does work, I think we could update the core markdown component to also render markdown on the front end.

So it's possible using the markdown web component could render the markdown better.

---

On the other hand, it is strange that the markdown is not being rendered correctly for you, especially a simple thing like nested lists. I'll see if I can reproduce it.

Do you have an example output for testing?

[richard-to]

Yeah I can confirm that the sub list is not working. This can be seen also in the demo gallary for the markdown example. The sublist is not indented.

It looks like a rendering issue since it gets rendered a one level list and not nested.

[richard-to]

So looks like the reason is the markdown module we're using requires four space indention. See https://github.com/Python-Markdown/markdown/issues/1378

This is expected behavior for this module.

---

I'd agree that this isn't ideal. As a workaround is it possible to tell the agent to render the sublist with four spaces?

[adriens]

I'd agree that this isn't ideal. As a workaround is it possible to tell the agent to render the sublist with four spaces?

In my case, I asked my agent to generate a markdown so I can put it in Github issue... and let him do the job.

[richard-to]

We're planning to update the markdown object to render using javascript instead of python. This has the side effect of allowing two spaces for nested lists.

[adriens]

great news ! We did a demo yesterday and enjoyed a lot the Dark theme toggle btw. I made an internal issue to force markdown output... so we'll wait for the next release.

Thanks for the very cool feedback and the resulting devex 🙏

[adriens]

here is the yesterday pari-programming session :

• https://github.com/google/mesop/issues/816

[richard-to]

Just for clarification, we haven't finished the implementation yet for the markdown rendering change. I'll probably start on that this week. And in reference to #816, we should have a copy and paste button.

[adriens]

I'll probably start on that this week

No rush, no pressure 🙏