iOS Edge Beta: no longer opening USDZ files in ARQL - Githubissues

google / model-viewer

Easily display interactive 3D models on the web and in AR!

https://modelviewer.dev

Apache License 2.0

6.71k stars 799 forks source link

iOS Edge Beta: no longer opening USDZ files in ARQL #4571

Open milesgreen opened 7 months ago

milesgreen commented 7 months ago

Description

In iOS Edge (beta) USDZ files and generated USDZ blobs are no longer opened in ARQL. Instead, Edge simply displays the filename.

Live Demo

https://modelviewer.dev/

Click on the AR icon on the astronaut.
Observe Edge open a window that displays the filename, rather than opening 3D model to ARQL.

Also happens on non Model-Viewer content, such as: https://developer.apple.com/augmented-reality/quick-look/

Has been reported through the in-app feedback channel. But I do not have a way to escalate or follow up.

iOS Edge is pretty small audience share. However, Model-Viewer compatibility checking currently assumes iOS Edge to be compatible. If Edge does not fix, may have to remove Edge from ARQL candidate list.

Version

model-viewer: any

Browser Affected

[ ] Chrome, version: xx.x.xxxx.xx
[x] Edge, 117.0.2045.12 beta
[ ] Firefox
[ ] IE
[ ] Safari

OS

[ ] Android
[x] iOS, 17.2 beta 3 (21C5046c)
[ ] Linux
[ ] MacOS
[ ] Windows

AR

[ ] WebXR
[ ] SceneViewer
[x] QuickLook

Screenshots

After clicking on AR button:

elalish commented 7 months ago

Interesting, that sounds like an old iOS Chrome bug - I wonder if they updated to a bad (for us) version of Chromium.

sugarfreejaz commented 7 months ago

happening for me as well.

milesgreen commented 5 months ago

Retesting with:

Edge 121.0.2277.70 beta
iOS 17.4 beta (21E5195e)

Same issue still persists.

Will try testing on some non-beta releases of Edge/iOS.

But might have to drop support for iOS Edge...

elalish commented 4 months ago

Fair enough - is it just me or is QL getting shakier and shakier? It seems to take longer than ever to load a model.

milesgreen commented 2 weeks ago

Also being discussed here:

https://github.com/google/model-viewer/discussions/4781