google / python-fire

Python Fire is a library for automatically generating command line interfaces (CLIs) from absolutely any Python object.
Other
27.08k stars 1.45k forks source link

[bug] short flags/arguments does not work with `**kwargs` #454

Open Diogo-Rossi opened 1 year ago

Diogo-Rossi commented 1 year ago

Description:

Short flags/arguments (e.g. -u for --username) does not work with **kwargs

Example that works OK:

The following example works ok:

import fire

def cli(first_arg="left", second_arg="right"):
    """Prints the 2 arguments separated by bar

    Parameters
    ----------
    first_arg : str
        the first arg
    second_arg : str
        the second arg
    """
    print(f"{first_arg} | {second_arg}" )

if __name__ == '__main__':
  fire.Fire(cli)

Help output

❯ python .\example.py -- --help
NAME
    example.py - Prints the 2 arguments separated by bar

SYNOPSIS
    example.py <flags>

DESCRIPTION
    Prints the 2 arguments separated by bar

FLAGS
    -f, --first_arg=FIRST_ARG
        Default: 'left'
        the first arg
    -s, --second_arg=SECOND_ARG
        Default: 'right'
        the second arg

Usage with short flags

❯ python .\example.py -f="hello" -s="word"
hello | word

Example that does not work:

The following next example does not work with short flags, even when they are showing on the help output. It is using **kwargs. It seems the short flags are going to the **kwargs dictionary.

import fire

def cli(first_arg="left", second_arg="right", **kwargs):
    """Prints the 2 arguments separated by bar

    Parameters
    ----------
    first_arg : str
        the first arg
    second_arg : str
        the second arg
    kwargs : str
        additional args
    """
    print(f"{first_arg} | {second_arg}" )
    print(kwargs)

if __name__ == '__main__':
  fire.Fire(cli)

Help output

❯ python .\example2.py -- --help
NAME
    example2.py - Prints the 2 arguments separated by bar

SYNOPSIS
    example2.py <flags>

DESCRIPTION
    Prints the 2 arguments separated by bar

FLAGS
    -f, --first_arg=FIRST_ARG
        Default: 'left'
        the first arg
    -s, --second_arg=SECOND_ARG
        Default: 'right'
        the second arg
    Additional flags are accepted.
        additional args

Usage with short flags

❯ python .\example2.py -f="hello" -s="word"
left | right
{'f': 'hello', 's': 'word'}

In summary: the -f and -s arguments should be parsing to --first_arg and --second_arg but they are parsing to kwargs

parthosa commented 11 months ago

Do we have any updates on this bug?