google / recaptcha

PHP client library for reCAPTCHA, a free service to protect your website from spam and abuse.
http://www.google.com/recaptcha/
BSD 3-Clause "New" or "Revised" License
3.48k stars 770 forks source link

"Select all squares with" mostly does not work. #528

Open immibis opened 1 year ago

immibis commented 1 year ago

In most cases it is far from obvious which squares are meant to be selected, especially if there are only a few pixels in a square, or an ambiguous label. Is a traffic light just the light or is it also the pole?

I am definitely human, and I pass this style about 20% of the time.

Legion303 commented 9 months ago

I passed that style 0% of the time and after about a week of failing and getting kicked to the "select all squares with fire hydrants / cars / bicycles / Sundar Pichai's Dumpster Fire of a Company" style, they've trained me to immediately hit reload whenever it tries to show me the style that never works, and keep hitting reload until it gives me the one that works most of the time (except when they think a van and a bus are the same).

beamblitz commented 3 months ago

It's been months since I've passed this one. I have to keep refreshing until I'm served one of the "select all images with" options. The other day I cracked and thought, I'm going to keep doing these "select all squares with" options until I pass, and I gave up after 20 minutes. I tried doing it quickly, doing it slowly, moving my cursor around hesitantly, selecting squares even if there was only a couple pixels, ignoring those...all of it. None of them ever, ever worked. Since I'm on a VPN, I've probably been served these well north of a thousand times recently, and I've passed Z-E-R-O of them. This captcha has always been horrible, but the trick always seemed to be that, if you moved the cursor around like you were a sleep-deprived centenarian, you could pass. But that is evidently no longer the case.

bkowenswork commented 3 weeks ago

ReCaptcha is now a system that only AI's can pass.
This insanity will continue until every McKinsey alumni is blacklisted from ever working in the tech industry.