Closed Snudz closed 3 months ago
https://bugs.documentfoundation.org/show_bug.cgi?id=127293#c44
LibreOffice 24.8 will have XLOOKUP in the core application.
Can you please test LibreOffice 24.8 to see if this issue is resolved?
Thank you
LibreOffice has implemented nesting XLOOKUP functions https://bugs.documentfoundation.org/show_bug.cgi?id=159467
LibreOffice Help also includes the XLOOKUP function https://help.libreoffice.org/master/en-US/text/scalc/01/func_xlookup.html
Can you please test and report any bugs? https://bugs.documentfoundation.org/show_bug.cgi?id=127293
Thank you
Sorry, been busy/away. What a palava trying to find 24.8. I don't normally use libreoffice. Only doing this as a friend asked for a librecalc version of an excel spreadsheet I'd written.
Anyway, it sort of works but not completely.
If I do:
XLOOKUP( search1, lookup1, XLOOKUP( search2, lookup2, return2 ) )
and the search criteria can be found then it works.
If I do:
XLOOKUP( search1, lookup1, XLOOKUP( search2, lookup2, return2 ), "not found" )
and the search criteria cannot be found then rather then "not found" I get Err: 504
It therefore follows that the problem I initially reported i.e.
XLOOKUP( search1, lookup1, return1, XLOOKUP( search1, lookup2, return2, "not found" ) )
Also reports Err: 504
(Use of Search1 twice is intentional. The original problem was to find a value in one of two tables.)
Thank you for testing and commenting.
Your comment has been added at https://bugs.documentfoundation.org/show_bug.cgi?id=159467#c9 for the LibreOffice developers
Apologies. The example I gave when testing was a quick example I grabbed of the web to test it. This was doing a 2D lookup which is not what I was actually trying to do in my real set-up. So my testing was flawed.
Have had more time to look at it and the example I have above doesn't work for me in Excel either. So, I grabbed the actual excel spreadsheet I was transferring to LibreCalc and used that directly and the nested XLOOKUP as being used in that spreadsheet does now work in LibreCalc.
The actual example I should have used was a generic scoring system. Assume a team is the home team and find their score, if not found then they must be the away team, so search the away teams and get their score.
So:
XLOOKUP( TeamName, HomeTeams, HomeScores, XLOOKUP( TeamName, AwayTeams, AwayScores, "Error not found") )
Apologies again for wasting your time and thank you for fixing the original problem.
@Snudz can you please reply to https://bugs.documentfoundation.org/show_bug.cgi?id=159467#c10
@Snudz does that mean that LibreOffice 24.8 will solve this issue? If so, can you please close this issue?
As far as I'm concerned, yes, 24.8 will fix my issue.
Using a 2nd XLOOKUP as the [if not found] argument does not appear to work.
XLOOKUP( value, lookup1, return1, XLOOKUP( value, lookup2, return2, "not found" ) )