gorhill / httpswitchboard

Point & click to forbid/allow any class of requests made by your browser. Use it to block scripts, iframes, ads, facebook, etc.
GNU General Public License v3.0
1.33k stars 83 forks source link

CDN problem and possible Firefox port? #420

Open lawrencehartkog opened 10 years ago

lawrencehartkog commented 10 years ago

A visit to the shopping sites (where the action is, according to the analytics sickos) nowadays demonstrates that almost no product of any kind can be searched for or compared without invoking CDN scripts. The CDN market has several big syndicates - let's take Amazon and its CDN subsidiary Cloudfront as an example, which appear on many commercial sites nowadays: Privacy for Cloudfront is regulated by Amazon's privacy policy, which in turn happily admits that they do fingerprinting.

Alternatives in this situation:

Since NoScript is not a very convincing concept (first allow scripts, then forbid one by one, etc.), and making Chromium as fingerprint-resisting as the Tor-Firefox fork is really a lot of work, I'd kindly ask:

How much work would it be to port httpswitchboard to Firefox? Could it be done with a reasonable community effort?

gorhill commented 10 years ago

How much work would it be to port httpswitchboard to Firefox?

I am in the midst of refactoring HTTPSB into uMatrix. I have come to see HTTPSB as a nice but quite sub-optimal prototype with many issues arising from this, and I want to bring the code to a better state than what it has grown into. That said, I will keep the porting issue as a top issue as I refactor. Then once done, I will be able to have a better view on the issue.

lawrencehartkog commented 10 years ago

That is nice to hear.

wisiwig commented 10 years ago

I am very grateful to you for the development of this addon. And I am especially grateful for the work on porting it to the Firefox. Thank you!

xdmx commented 10 years ago

@gorhill, have you tried to talk to @futpib? He's working on Policeman, which is very similar to httpswitchboard, but for firefox. Maybe you could join the forces