search

govex / open-data-portal-requirements

Open Data Portal Requirements
http://labs.centerforgov.org/open-data-portal-requirements/
Other
14 stars 7 forks source link

Public comments, or private comments? #4

Open waldoj opened 9 years ago

waldoj commented 9 years ago

In "Community Features," in the "Customers" section, appears the following requirement:

must be able to provide comments and feedback on individual data resources

I assumed that this meant private comments and feedback (e.g., an email link), but under the "Publishers" section there appears:

may be able to review and approve visibility of customer comments and feedback

Are you saying that public comments on individual data resources is a must feature? Or private comments? Whichever is the case, the language should be clarified.

technickle commented 9 years ago

This was left ambiguous to allow for variations in policy. Visitors should be able to provide feedback, and it's up to the government to determine if that feedback is automatically public, moderated to be public, or kept private. Does that make sense? And if so, is there a better way to capture that in the requirements based upon the current structure? (I'm also very open to structural changes.)

waldoj commented 9 years ago

Sure, that makes sense. But since ambiguity is likely to lead to confusion, perhaps you might want to point out that a range of features is acceptable? e.g., "must be able to provide comments and feedback on individual data resources (which may either be displayed publicly or sent privately to the government)."