Summary:
Paper forecasting the 2024 US election using "poll-of-polls" approach.
Strong positive points:
Informative repo name
Nicely organized
Great data visualizations
Critical improvements needed:
Complete the unfinished part
Suggestions for improvement:
Complete the unfinished part
Evaluation:
R cited: [ 0/1]
Data cited [0 /1]
Class paper [0 /1]
LLM Usage [ 0/1]
Title [ 2/2] -
Author, date, Repo [ 2/2] -
Abstract [0/4] - not done yet
Introduction [0/4] - not done yet
Estimand [0/1] - not done yet
Data [0/10] - not done yet
Measurement [0/4] - not done yet
Model [0/10] --
Results [0/10] - not done yet
Discussion [0/10] - not done yet
Prose [0/10] -
Cross-References [0/1] --
Captions [0/2] - no graphs yet of your own in the paper
Graphs/tables/etc [0/4] - no graphs/tables yet of your own in the paper
Idealized methodology [0/10] - not done yet
Idealized Survey [0/4] - not done yet
Pollster methodology [0/10] - not done yet
Referencing [0/4] -
Commits [0/2] --
Sketches [0/2] --
Simulation [0/4] --
Tests - sim [0/4] --
Tests - actual [0/4] -
Reproducible workflow [0/4] --
misc [ 0/3] --
total mark: 4/124.
Overall: A great start of a nice paper, still a plenty of time to finish it.
Summary: Paper forecasting the 2024 US election using "poll-of-polls" approach.
Strong positive points: Informative repo name Nicely organized Great data visualizations
Critical improvements needed: Complete the unfinished part
Suggestions for improvement: Complete the unfinished part
Evaluation: R cited: [ 0/1] Data cited [0 /1] Class paper [0 /1] LLM Usage [ 0/1] Title [ 2/2] - Author, date, Repo [ 2/2] - Abstract [0/4] - not done yet Introduction [0/4] - not done yet Estimand [0/1] - not done yet Data [0/10] - not done yet Measurement [0/4] - not done yet Model [0/10] -- Results [0/10] - not done yet Discussion [0/10] - not done yet Prose [0/10] - Cross-References [0/1] -- Captions [0/2] - no graphs yet of your own in the paper Graphs/tables/etc [0/4] - no graphs/tables yet of your own in the paper Idealized methodology [0/10] - not done yet Idealized Survey [0/4] - not done yet Pollster methodology [0/10] - not done yet Referencing [0/4] - Commits [0/2] -- Sketches [0/2] -- Simulation [0/4] -- Tests - sim [0/4] -- Tests - actual [0/4] - Reproducible workflow [0/4] -- misc [ 0/3] --
total mark: 4/124.
Overall: A great start of a nice paper, still a plenty of time to finish it.