greatscottgadgets / cynthion

USB test instrument
https://greatscottgadgets.com/cynthion/
BSD 3-Clause "New" or "Revised" License
92 stars 21 forks source link

Compatibility with usbip-attached devices #171

Open clintoncampbell opened 3 months ago

clintoncampbell commented 3 months ago

After applying the patch in #144, I'm able to proxy a local device (Yubikey 5) successfully to the target machine. I'm testing whether Cynthion could be useful for establishing an over-the-network USB proxy, and so I've extended this test to try proxying the same device when attached via usbip. While the initial results seem positive, the test ultimately fails with the Yubikey and all other devices I've tried.

Here's an outline of the desired state:

  1. Yubikey attaches to RPi A via USB
  2. RPi A runs usbip bind and usbipd to advertise the device
  3. RPi B runs usbip attach to mount the device.
  4. RPi B connects to cynthion via control and runs usbproxy.py
  5. macOS device connects to cynthion via target C in order to consume the proxied device

I'm currently able to complete all steps without error and can see the proxied device listed on the USB bus from system info on macOS, but I don't get any other signs of life from the device at this point.

From a troubleshooting perspective, I've observed the following:

Assuming that this setup should work, I'm happy to provide any logs or additional details to aide with troubleshooting and replication. The objective in this case is to be able to test and demonstrate phishing resistant authentication flows against a variety of end-user devices that the members of my mostly remote team would like to centralize and access via web-based KVM. If we can get this working, I'm eager to get my hands on a few more Cynthions in order to centralize our pool of test devices.

mossmann commented 3 months ago

We've had https://github.com/greatscottgadgets/facedancer/issues/25 open for a long time with nobody working on it. I think we assumed that we would need a new Facedancer backend, but I guess it ought to be possible with usbip attach on the Facedancer control host. (A special backend would be nice for cross-platform support.)

Can you show us the Facedancer console output?