Gridcoin Project Process Listing v2

G-UK commented 6 years ago

Current Process (v1) -- #194 De-Listing Process Discussion -- #201

The Proposal: Gridcoin Project Listings v2.docx Calculation Spreadsheet: Whitelist 06-03-18.zip Listing Reasoning (WIP): Gridcoin Project Listings Reasoning.docx

Change Summary for v2:

Addition of De-Listing Process from #201
Change of all Polls to require both greater than 50% vote share by number of voters and greater than 50% vote share by Mag & Balance weight.
- Attempt to make votes fairer.
Addition of 48 hour timeout for a project when it is Greylisted
- To prevent projects bouncing in and out of the Greylist, once Greylisted they will remain so for a minimum of 48hrs
Addition of Requirement for project reported Recent Average Compute Power to be greater than 2500GFlops where statistic is available.
- "Soucefinder" fix, attempt to weed out very low compute projects.

To-Do List:

[ ] Document explaning logic behind each item in the Process
[ ] Process inclusion to Blue Paper
[ ] Publication of Greylist on https://gridcoin.us
[ ] Creation of auto-updated Greylist with stats scrape on https://www.griscoinstats.eu

NeuralMiner commented 6 years ago

50% vote share by number of voters This is far too easy to manipulate.

G-UK commented 6 years ago

I know, I'm hoping the discussion in economics can agree something better and I am willing to follow whatever ends up being agreed for CBR.

tomasbrod commented 6 years ago

I do not support removing projects from grey/white-list unless it is absolutely necessary or requested by vote. Security suspicion should automatically force project out of white-list as fast as possible. Being in grey-list for 60 days should not be a reason to de-list a project.

I would like to see the condition results as a list of flags. Then the final whitelist status will be given by Boolean function. Like: F := (WAS=green) and (stats_export_T < 2d) not admin_denied and ...

grctest commented 5 years ago

G-UK: I know, I'm hoping the discussion in economics can agree something better

Mag + Balance

Security suspicion should automatically force project out of white-list as fast as possible.

What classifies as a security suspicion? PG GRC security rant could have triggered this, yet it's a subjective analysis not conclusive evidence of harm (say malware).

tomasbrod commented 5 years ago

Security suspicion is anything that affects security of cruncher computer, security of the network, or attempts to cheat the credits.

gridcoin-community / Gridcoin-Tasks

Gridcoin Project Process Listing v2 #213