search

gruninger / Common-Logic

Documents for the developments of ISO 24707 Editiion 2 (Common Logic)
8 stars 3 forks source link

Comments on bindings in XCL #20

Closed greenTara closed 11 years ago

greenTara commented 11 years ago

Defect Nos.: 19

Submitter: Chris Angus

References in Document: p.65 C.2 3.1.5

Nature of Defect: The abstract syntax metamodel does not support a Binding having comment associated with it (nor does CLIF), however XCL allows a element to contain zero, one or more comments. This would
appear to prevent XCL being syntactically fully conformant.

Proposed Solution: Either add support for comments being associated with a Binding to the abstract syntax metamodel and CLIF or remove them from XCL. NEED SPECIFIC TEXT CHANGES HERE

greenTara commented 11 years ago

The DTD in Annex C will be replaced by a Relax NG schema describing a completely revised XCL syntax.

Therefore this issue is moot.

I recommend that this issue be closed.

greenTara commented 11 years ago

The Abstract Syntax could be revised to allow comments to be optionally attached to bindings, or to names in general.

This is relevant to issue #26.