search

gs1 / EPCIS

Draft files being shared for EPCIS 2.0 development
Other
20 stars 7 forks source link

What happens after public review and where are the comments? #350

Open sgpinkus opened 2 years ago

sgpinkus commented 2 years ago

README states:

Anyone can submit comments, whether you participate in the GS1 Global Standards Management Process (GSMP) or not - further details at the link above. Public review for EPCIS/CBV 2.0 ends on 11th November 2021.

I made a couple of comments. There is not much detail at the link about what happens after 11//11. Comments could just be sent to /dev/null and I'd be none the wiser. What's the process after 11/11? Could the README be updated?

mgh128 commented 2 years ago

Thank you for providing comments. I can assure you that all comments will be considered by the work group and where appropriate, corrections, improvements and adjustments will be made. Unfortunately I'm not sure that we can provide visibility of all comments to all submitters - but all feedback will be considered. We're prioritising corrections, clarifications and fixing anything that is considered to be ambiguous or potentially broken. Some requests for enhancements may need to be deferred to a future version, depending on the time and complexity of the suggested changes. For comments submitted by GSMP members, we usually expect to reply to the submitter of the comment with the decision about how the comment will be treated. I am not sure if the process is exactly the same for replying to submitters of comments who are not GSMP members but will try to find out. Thanks again for your review - we appreciate the feedback.

VladimirAlexiev commented 2 years ago

@sgpinkus If your comments are about some significant defects, please post them as github issues.