Closed guibranco closed 3 days ago
โฑ๏ธ Estimated effort to review [1-5] | 2, because the script is straightforward and primarily involves shell scripting with basic error handling. |
๐งช Relevant tests | No |
โก Possible issues | Error Handling: The script does not handle cases where the `git diff --staged` command fails, which could lead to unexpected behavior. |
Hardcoded Branch Name: The branch name is hardcoded as "branch-name", which may not be appropriate for all use cases. | |
๐ Security concerns | No |
Category | Suggestion | Score |
Possible issue |
Add validation for the commit message file to ensure it is provided and valid___ **Ensure that the script checks if theCOMMIT_MSG_FILE variable is set and is a valid file before proceeding to avoid potential errors.** [.githooks/prepare-commit-msg [17]](https://github.com/guibranco/gstraccini-bot-api/pull/12/files#diff-dcfff605ffad618dd937de6369eb0e61d25656d8e2a0ba5ed3546b025c39678dR17-R17) ```diff -COMMIT_MSG_FILE=$1 +if [ -z "$1" ] || [ ! -f "$1" ]; then echo "Error: Commit message file is not provided or does not exist." >&2; exit 1; fi; COMMIT_MSG_FILE=$1 ``` Suggestion importance[1-10]: 9Why: This suggestion addresses a potential issue that could lead to runtime errors, making it crucial for the script's robustness. | 9 |
Enhancement |
Use the current branch name dynamically instead of a hardcoded value___ **Instead of hardcoding "branch-name", consider using a command to dynamically fetch thecurrent branch name for better accuracy.** [.githooks/prepare-commit-msg [22]](https://github.com/guibranco/gstraccini-bot-api/pull/12/files#diff-dcfff605ffad618dd937de6369eb0e61d25656d8e2a0ba5ed3546b025c39678dR22-R22) ```diff -AI_MESSAGE=$(dotnet-aicommitmessage generate-message -m "$CURRENT" -b "branch-name" -d "$GIT_DIFF" ) +AI_MESSAGE=$(dotnet-aicommitmessage generate-message -m "$CURRENT" -b "$(git rev-parse --abbrev-ref HEAD)" -d "$GIT_DIFF" ) ``` Suggestion importance[1-10]: 8Why: This suggestion enhances the script's accuracy by dynamically fetching the branch name, which is important for correct functionality. | 8 |
Maintainability |
Improve the error message for clarity on AI message generation failures___ **Consider using a more specific error message for when the AI message generation fails,indicating that the issue might be with the input or the tool itself.** [.githooks/prepare-commit-msg [23]](https://github.com/guibranco/gstraccini-bot-api/pull/12/files#diff-dcfff605ffad618dd937de6369eb0e61d25656d8e2a0ba5ed3546b025c39678dR23-R23) ```diff -echo "Error: Failed to generate AI commit message. Using original message." >&2 +echo "Error: AI message generation failed. Please check the input and ensure dotnet-aicommitmessage is functioning correctly." >&2 ``` Suggestion importance[1-10]: 7Why: The suggestion improves clarity in error messaging, which is beneficial for debugging, but it does not address a critical issue. | 7 |
Best practice |
Specify the shell in the shebang for consistent script execution___ **Consider adding a shebang line for a specific shell (e.g.,#!/bin/bash ) to ensure consistent behavior across different environments.** [.githooks/prepare-commit-msg [1]](https://github.com/guibranco/gstraccini-bot-api/pull/12/files#diff-dcfff605ffad618dd937de6369eb0e61d25656d8e2a0ba5ed3546b025c39678dR1-R1) ```diff -#!/bin/sh +#!/bin/bash ``` Suggestion importance[1-10]: 6Why: While specifying the shell can improve consistency, it is a minor improvement and does not significantly impact the script's functionality. | 6 |
User description
Closes #
๐ Description
โ Checks
โข๏ธ Does this introduce a breaking change?
โน Additional Information
Description
dotnet-aicommitmessage
.GIT_AICOMMIT_SKIP
environment variable.Changes walkthrough ๐
prepare-commit-msg
Add AI-powered commit message generation script
.githooks/prepare-commit-msg