search

guillaumechereau / goxel

Goxel: Free and Open Source 3D Voxel Editor
GNU General Public License v3.0
2.74k stars 219 forks source link

Model 3D export #235

Closed bztsrc closed 2 years ago

bztsrc commented 3 years ago

More and more people are asking for this. So much that I really need this. This just a single file without any dependencies, it won't bother you, but it would make users happy.

Let's make a deal. If you accept this PR then in return I'll fix some of the file import/export issues. For example, adding material support to obj files or handling vox layers.

Deal?

Cheers, bzt

bztsrc commented 3 years ago

Just some issues I could help with in exchange: issue #224 issue #208 issue #203 issue #159 issue #135

Cheers, bzt

bztsrc commented 3 years ago

Please?

hellocatfood commented 3 years ago

It's not an ideal solution but until this PR is merged you could export as .vox and then use a .vox blender importer (e.g. https://github.com/technistguru/MagicaVoxel_Importer or https://github.com/RichysHub/MagicaVoxel-VOX-importer ) to import into blender and then export as .obj or other file format.

Until then I guess the other issues can still be worked on?

bztsrc commented 3 years ago

It's not an ideal solution but until this PR is merged you could export as .vox and then use a .vox blender importer

Thanks, I already have a better solution, m3dconv can directly convert .vox (and many other formats) into .m3d, and I also have mtsedit which can import .gox (Goxel native) or .vox (although that code is limited to 256x256x256 volume). The issue is, all of these require an additional step, and that's what my users are complaining about.

It is possible to create voxel models in Blender and then export with the Blender .m3d exporter too, but using Blender for that is cumbersome, my users would like to use Goxel because it is a lot more simpler and user friendlier.

But thanks for the suggestion, anyway.

Until then I guess the other issues can still be worked on?

I am. But I don't want to share anything because I haven't heard from guillaumechereau as of yet.

Cheers, bzt

hellocatfood commented 2 years ago

Was this closed because it was fixed/merged?

bztsrc commented 2 years ago

Was this closed because it was fixed/merged?

Sadly no. @guillaumechereau closes my issues without any comments for some reason. I don't know what's his issue with this patch, but I really would like to know. It is a separate file, would merge without conflicts.

Cheers, bzt

guillaumechereau commented 1 year ago

I closed because I don't want to add support for non well known formats, adding complexity to the software. For this kind of things the best is I think to use an intermediary format as suggested. If goxel had support for plugins that would also be a good fit.

pegvin commented 1 year ago

You should've just looked into model3d format not saying to merge it, it's really just 1 c file and it's highly efficient and that's why i chose it over the default gox format.