gysmo38 / domoticz-python-melcloud

A plugin in python for Domoticz
13 stars 14 forks source link

[Idea] : use DZ "thermostat" device type for the temperature #41

Closed rezzalex closed 6 months ago

rezzalex commented 7 months ago

what do you think ?

Patricen1 commented 7 months ago

what do you think ?

+1 fully agree!

https://github.com/gysmo38/domoticz-python-melcloud/issues/39#issuecomment-2078196326

rezzalex commented 6 months ago

@Patricen1 , I discovered the work was already done by nonolf... after coding it myself,

So please find here the version with all latest modifications (I think) and the thermostat device type working. Not tested a lot, but it seems to work.

plugin.zip

Patricen1 commented 6 months ago

Great ! Thanks!

janpep commented 6 months ago

Maybe I do not understand it well, but I do not see the expected result. I put this plugin.py in my test environment. What I see is that the temp setting of my airco's now are stated as 'undefined'. I expected the setpoint to appear., but It looks they are not created. Am I missing something?

rezzalex commented 6 months ago

Maybe I do not understand it well, but I do not see the expected result. I put this plugin.py in my test environment. What I see is that the temp setting of my airco's now are stated as 'undefined'. I expected the setpoint to appear., but It looks they are not created. Am I missing something?

Did you remove all other plugin devices ?

janpep commented 6 months ago

No none, Why should I remove them all to be recreated? May be because of the existing naming? Missing a little 'Readme'

rezzalex commented 6 months ago

I think I saw in the plugin code that devices are created only if there is none already existing.

janpep commented 6 months ago

OK Thank you! I dd not notice that. I will try and let it know.

Patricen1 commented 6 months ago

Hello, you should delete the old temp settings multilevel devices and accept new devices. You'll then have a setpoint device that appears, much more convenient!

rezzalex commented 6 months ago

no, in my case, I need to delete EVERY devices ; not only the one I want the plugin to recreate.

Patricen1 commented 6 months ago

no, in my case, I need to delete EVERY devices ; not only the one I want the plugin to recreate.

Yes, sorry you are right

janpep commented 6 months ago

Indeed. Thank you, When I deleted all, they where recreated.

Disadvantage I see for this solution is that the airco settings are not longer grouped together under the tab 'Switches'. I have to find it in the 'Utility' tab to adjus the temp. In fact I had no problem with the level for setting the temp. So it is nice !! that the old setting (commented out) is still there. For the time being I keep using that. Also because most of the setting are done automatically by script.

FYI: I'm using a four-stage rocket.

  1. A wall transmitter can activate a scene (1 push = on, 2 x push = off), for bedroom and livingroom.
  2. These scenes, turn a switch device on or off (, which I can of course also operate manually from my dashboard).
  3. The switch change triggers a script. (one for bedroom, one for livingroom)
  4. These scripts (triggered on the switch, a set time or variable 'day-evening-night') controls whether the air conditioning is turned on or off, on heating or on cooling (based on current temperature), whereby a selected standard temperature for cooling or warming is set. Usually this is sufficient and I don't have to do anything other than switch it on or off when I want.
    • Trigger based on the switch is clear.
    • Trigger based on time: When the air conditioning in the bedroom is on, it turns off again in the morning.
    • Trigger based on the variable: When I go to bed (variable for night mode is then activated), the script is triggered and the air conditioner in the bedroom turns on if the radiator knob is above a certain temperature. If the air conditioning in the living room is on, it turns off at the same time.
Patricen1 commented 6 months ago

Hello, I'm using Aurora theme that groups setpoint and room temp on home screen, very convenient for TRV's , as well as Melcloud.