[x] Add Best Practices reference (and possibly Fig1)
[x] Require both methods for the exercise
[x] Update intro section to emphasize building up knowledge and background prior (lit review).
Per Slack w/ Faisal:
cjfields [10:07 AM]
Ok
One other point that might be worth thinking about. We have two alternative methods (alignment and pseudoalignment); should they know both or only be required to run one? It's not clear in the SOP.
Some of the questions expect both. Most obvious: "How do counts between the two methods (alignment vs. pseudoalignment) compare?"
Faisal Fadlelmola [10:08 AM]
I think it better to include both
cjfields [10:09 AM]
I agree
I can tweak the wording with that in mind
Faisal Fadlelmola [10:10 AM]
A survey of best practices for RNA-seq data analysis
this is one of the best paper we used during our assessment
cjfields [10:11 AM]
Is that referenced in the SOP?
Faisal Fadlelmola [10:11 AM]
no
cjfields [10:11 AM]
We can easily add it
I'm going to add a Github issue to track these two points (requiring both methods, adding the reference) to make sure they get done
Just in case
Faisal Fadlelmola [10:13 AM]
I like their Figure 1:
Pasted image at 2018-10-30, 6:12 PM
cjfields [10:14 AM]
Can see if that's Creative Commons, if so we could add it in as well.
Faisal Fadlelmola [10:15 AM]
Citation: A survey of best practices for RNA-seq data analysis
Genome Biology, 2016, Volume 17, Number 1, Page 1
Ana Conesa, Pedro Madrigal, Sonia Tarazona, David Gomez-Cabrero, Alejandra Cervera, Andrew McPherson, Michał Wojciech Szcześniak, Daniel J. Gaffney, Laura L. Elo, Xuegong Zhang, Ali Mortazavi
A few updates for the SOP:
Per Slack w/ Faisal:
cjfields [10:07 AM] Ok One other point that might be worth thinking about. We have two alternative methods (alignment and pseudoalignment); should they know both or only be required to run one? It's not clear in the SOP. Some of the questions expect both. Most obvious: "How do counts between the two methods (alignment vs. pseudoalignment) compare?"
Faisal Fadlelmola [10:08 AM] I think it better to include both
cjfields [10:09 AM] I agree I can tweak the wording with that in mind
Faisal Fadlelmola [10:10 AM] A survey of best practices for RNA-seq data analysis this is one of the best paper we used during our assessment
cjfields [10:11 AM] Is that referenced in the SOP?
Faisal Fadlelmola [10:11 AM] no
cjfields [10:11 AM] We can easily add it I'm going to add a Github issue to track these two points (requiring both methods, adding the reference) to make sure they get done Just in case
Faisal Fadlelmola [10:13 AM] I like their Figure 1: Pasted image at 2018-10-30, 6:12 PM
cjfields [10:14 AM] Can see if that's Creative Commons, if so we could add it in as well.
Faisal Fadlelmola [10:15 AM] Citation: A survey of best practices for RNA-seq data analysis
Genome Biology, 2016, Volume 17, Number 1, Page 1 Ana Conesa, Pedro Madrigal, Sonia Tarazona, David Gomez-Cabrero, Alejandra Cervera, Andrew McPherson, Michał Wojciech Szcześniak, Daniel J. Gaffney, Laura L. Elo, Xuegong Zhang, Ali Mortazavi