hagezi / dns-blocklists

DNS-Blocklists: For a better internet - keep the internet clean!
GNU General Public License v3.0
6.89k stars 229 forks source link

Videos on nascar.com #2450

Closed xenia-09A closed 7 months ago

xenia-09A commented 7 months ago

Hi On nascar.com videos stopped playing when using pro ++ list and chrome , they worked before I believe

Pro ++ seem to be blocking ads only so it not 100% clear what blacklisted domain is breaking this so can you advise if they are force breaking this and requires ad domains to be open to view these videos?

this is breaking with NExtDNS DoH and pro++ list , removing Pro++ list for few seconds video plays

thanks I'm a big fan thanks for all you do

hagezi commented 7 months ago

@xenia-09A Thanks, I'll have to see if I can reproduce that in my region. Do you perhaps have the block page in NextDNS active?

hagezi commented 7 months ago

I can reproduce this, but also with unfiltered DNS without a content blocker in any browser. Tried with Cloudflare and Google DNS. I can't get the videos to work. @yokoffing could you maybe have a look when you have time?

yokoffing commented 7 months ago

On Chrome with uBO Lite and Quad9 DNS, the videos won't load at all.

If I disable uBO Lite, the video loads.

yokoffing commented 7 months ago

Doesn't work with Firefox Strict ETP either using Cloudfare DNS. I have to disable uBO and switch ETP to Standard on Firefox.

hagezi commented 7 months ago

I can't get the videos to start at all. Regardless of whether I switch off browser tracking protection or not. I have tried Edge, Chrome, Thorium and Firefox. I have tried Cloudflare and Google DNS as upstream.

xRuffKez commented 7 months ago

Not loading, using unfiltered named.cache

xenia-09A commented 7 months ago

@xenia-09A Thanks, I'll have to see if I can reproduce that in my region. Do you perhaps have the block page in NextDNS active?

I can't get the videos to start at all. Regardless of whether I switch off browser tracking protection or not. I have tried Edge, Chrome, Thorium and Firefox. I have tried Cloudflare and Google DNS as upstream. no that block page caused me many headaches it turned off for good ... interesting.. I got the video to play just removing pro++, then putting it back broke it again

hagezi commented 7 months ago

Yes, unfortunately I can't find out for myself which domains need to be unblocked. I need someone to run the videos for that.

xenia-09A commented 7 months ago

I see smetrics.nascar.com being blocked unlblocking didn't help

xRuffKez commented 7 months ago

Fixed! You need to accept cookie consent!

wontfix

@hagezi

yokoffing commented 7 months ago

related: https://www.reddit.com/r/uBlockOrigin/comments/1bv0s4q/

hagezi commented 7 months ago

Thanks @yokoffing, since you are getting the videos to run, could you test with the Pro++ to see if there is an additional blocklist issue?

yokoffing commented 7 months ago

@hagezi The videos need access to moatads.com.

I allowlisted z.moatads.com and mb.moatads.com in Control D, along with the adblock filter fix from Reddit, and the videos worked. (Still broken with Firefox Strict ETP though.)

hagezi commented 7 months ago

Many thanks @yokoffing for the great support.

@xenia-09A This is definitely something for the personal allowlist if only one website is affected.

xenia-09A commented 7 months ago

Many thanks @yokoffing for the great support.

@xenia-09A This is definitely something for the personal allowlist if only one website is affected.

yes thank you I do now see z.moatads.com is blocked but this is a known tracker correct? but to keep my marriage happy I guess I can allow it , thanks so much LOL , allowing both above it still broken for me so I will need to keep messing with it

xenia-09A commented 7 months ago

Hagezi do you agree with this? If so wouldn’t we want to advise the admin of nascar.com?

the answer I’m looking from you is what is the reason why this is blocked in your block list . Is it malware , trackers and I should leave the video broken or what thanks

my review: Yandex Safe Browsing Website moatads.com is not present in the Yandex Safe Browsing blacklist. Malware Phishing Diagnostics Page → WEBSITE REPORT Google Safe Browsing Website moatads.com is not present in the Google Safe Browsing blacklist. Malware Phishing Diagnostics Page →

I found in apple forum but it a little old :

https://discussions.apple.com/thread/8061639?sortBy=best

Moatads.com is certainly a distributor of malware... the link below is the report from threatcrowd.org which maps the various virus/malware/"corruption" the server transmits.

hagezi commented 7 months ago

No, its Advertising/Tracking

https://www.netify.ai/resources/domains/moatads.com

https://duckduckgo.github.io/tracker-radar-wiki/domains/moatads.com.html

xenia-09A commented 7 months ago

No, its Advertising/Tracking

https://www.netify.ai/resources/domains/moatads.com

https://duckduckgo.github.io/tracker-radar-wiki/domains/moatads.com.html

Thanks so much you efforts are a great help we really appreciate all these lists you maintain

yokoffing commented 7 months ago

Just a quick update @hagezi @xenia-09A. Easylist fixed the adblock issue https://github.com/easylist/easylist/issues/18918.

For DNS, I disabled allowlisting moatads.com and used Hagezi's DNS - Pro list. I can watch videos on nascar.com with:

xenia-09A commented 7 months ago

Thanks , it seems at one point they now required these trackers to load videos