harmony-one / ethhmy-bridge.frontend

Ethereum<>Harmony two way bridge (trusted version) - frontend part
25 stars 62 forks source link

Horizon Bridge UI Feedback #155

Open polymorpher opened 2 years ago

polymorpher commented 2 years ago

I was asked to make a quick evaluation of new UI for Horizon bridge at https://bridge-validator-1.web.app/busd and to provide some initial feedback. I added them in https://docs.google.com/document/d/1utiqGhkMN2eE7h1cfo1p9xw5DHprM5D3A0O1BqFEEM8/edit# . Here is a copy:

Inconsistent branding colors

header image

icon image

main website image

Text hard to read and memorize

image

Too many menu items with overlapping meanings

Need Help v.s. FAQ Assets v.s. iToken

image

Unnecessary or vague menu items

iToken: unclear Transactions: own transactions or all bridge transactions? Harmony only or all networks?

image

Hidden buttons

Also unexpectedly triggers MetaMask

image

Arrows inconsistent with bridging direction

image

Token type button too small

image

Icon inconsistent with intended functionalities

image

Error messages abruptly inserted in the middle of key information visual elements

image

Default address value not provided

image

Hidden input fields

image

image

MetaMask plus icon inconsistent with intended functionality

image

Typo “MetaMask”

image

MetaMask button and use inconsistent with branding guideline

https://github.com/MetaMask/brand-resources https://community.metamask.io/t/metamask-logo-for-reproduction/15430/2

Abrupt error message on default address value

image

Layout not following information importance or interaction flow

image

Button missing hover effects

image

Unnecessary Button

image

Warning too obscure

image

Branding cropped

Bottom right

image

FAQ/Help not searchable by default due to collapsed state

image

FAQ/Help not categorized

image

Tnx Fee text should not be wrapped

image

Cropped tables due to the lack of responsiveness

image

Uncomfortable delay in switching menu items

more than 2 seconds without any visual feedback after clicking

image

polymorpher commented 2 years ago

Inconsistent corners

round

image

square

image