hashgraph-online / hcs-improvement-proposals

HCS Working Group Improvement Proposals / Simple
https://hashgraphonline.com/
MIT License
1 stars 1 forks source link

Feat: HCS-2 Advanced Topic Registries #5

Closed HGraphPunks closed 4 months ago

HGraphPunks commented 5 months ago

Couple questions, but close to complete I think for a PR

t_id: Should this just be a topic id OR should we add hcs://1/ , hcs://2/ requirement and change to hrl?

I'm torn, one is more flexible and less fragile, while the other helps indexers know the protocol before digesting information.

Reasoning for t_id:

Reasons against t_id:

Thoughts?

kantorcodes commented 4 months ago

Realizing I left my comments for HCS-2, on the HCS-6 PR 🤦

Could we introduce a ttl field to help support external infrastructure? I believe this will play well with DNS like registries in the future as well.