Add autoRenewAccount and autoRenewPeriod to all entities other than scheduled transactions

hashgraph / hedera-services

Crypto, token, consensus, file, and smart contract services for the Hedera public ledger

Apache License 2.0

313 stars 136 forks source link

Add autoRenewAccount and autoRenewPeriod to all entities other than scheduled transactions #1194

Closed qnswirlds closed 2 years ago

qnswirlds commented 3 years ago

Currently, a file is not associated with an autoRenewAccount (nor autoRenewPeriod) so a file can only be renewed by a fileUpdate transaction.
Accounts and contracts are entities that already own/self-own an account to be able to automatically renew themselves. Would we allow another account to be responsible for an account/contract autorenew fees, i.e. also adding autoRenewAccount and autoRenewPeriod for account and contract entities? https://github.com/hashgraph/hedera-services/pull/1190#discussion_r599657540

qnswirlds commented 3 years ago

Please discuss and vote for also adding autoRenewAccount and autoRenewPeriod for account and contract entities. @lbaird, @donaldthibeau, @noshmody, @steven-sheehy, @tinker-michaelj. Thanks!

steven-sheehy commented 3 years ago

In my opinion, it should. Both to be consistent and also for use cases like custodial wallets. I mentioned to @atul-hedera and he also agreed.

noshmody commented 3 years ago

@steven-sheehy The Admin account for all entities (other than files) was planned to be used to renew the entity. For the scope of the current feature, files will remain non-renewal. In a future release we can add Admin an account to a file which can be used for auto renewal.

tinker-michaelj commented 2 years ago

Duplicate of #103