Interpolate user variables within other user variables

[brettswift]

packer version: 0.7.2

Packer doesn't allow variables to be interpolated into other variables.

This would be helpful when I want to switch to a different version of RHEL for instance, so I could do something like the following:

  "variables": {
    "iso_url": "http://myserver/ISOs/rhel-server-{{ user `rhel_version`}}-x86_64-dvd.iso",
    "iso_checksum": "d717af33dd258945e6304f9955487017",
    "rhel_version": "6.3",
  },

Then via command line just pass in rhel_version.

The only way of getting around this that I can think of now would be to split up the iso_url field into 3 parts, and use the 3 parts everywhere.. which is a little messy.

[sethvargo]

Interesting. I think this is a very valid use case :smile:

[dragon788]

If you want to override that {{user rhel_version}} with a passed in var you could do an environment variable, but I agree, being able to just use -var MY_VAR to override otherwise fallback to the one defined elsewhere in variables would be nice.

[William-Yeh]

+1

[leroux]

My current workaround for this: https://github.com/mitchellh/packer/pull/1047#issuecomment-122199027

[joshuaspence]

Hmm, why was this issue closed as wontfix? :(

[mwhooker]

Hi all,

I closed this because it was an old issue that hadn't had any activity for more than a year. Apologies for not communicating that at the time.

It seems like people do want this feature, so for now I'll re-open it. Would be very happy to take a look at PRs if anyone would like to submit one.

As we near our 1.0 milestone release, I'll be continuing to trim down issues that don't look like they'll make it in. If this issue gets closed again, it's only because we're trying to trim the open issue list down to what we think we can accomplish for that release, not because we don't think it's a good feature. We'll be tagging those types of issues with the pre-1.0/wontfix tags, so we can easily find things that didn't make it into the 1.0 release.

[jessekempf]

I've run into essentially the same problem as @brettswift has. It's great that it's documented and all, but duplicating information across multiple user variables is pretty lame.

[kfealey]

I'm running into this issue as well - would love to see interpolated user variables at some point. It's been a few years - wondering if this is entering the road map any time soon.. Based on commentary, looks like it was only marked as "wontfix" for the pre-1.0 release.

[azr]

This is probably a use case for when we implement HCL2 ! 🙂

[andrijapanicsb]

+1

[ghost]

I'm going to lock this issue because it has been closed for 30 days ⏳. This helps our maintainers find and focus on the active issues.

If you have found a problem that seems similar to this, please open a new issue and complete the issue template so we can capture all the details necessary to investigate further.